The last two feature stories (“What Are We Doing Here?” HCN, 8/6/18; “Where the West Is Moving — and Why,” HCN, 8/20/18) were especially objective, well-researched, poignant and heartwarming. I’m a somewhat elderly dude who has spent much of my life working with and enriched by a wide variety of diverse folks. Also, my church is […]
Letter to the editor
Resonant ruminations
I write in appreciation of Cally Carswell. She relates, with uncanny precision and brittle clarity, what it is to be a Westerner confronting the transformation of a beloved landscape. Her moving rumination, personal and profound, resonates on many levels. What a writer. Pat CassenMiramonte, California This article appeared in the print edition of the magazine […]
‘Welcome to Hell’
Of our 46 summers in this part of southern Arizona, this one has been the worst (“What are we doing here?” HCN, 8/6/18). Gone are the rare days when the temperature hit 100 degrees Fahrenheit; now it’s seemingly endless weeks of 101, 103, even 106 degrees. Gone are the almost daily afternoon thunderstorms that left […]
Erosive grooves
Daniel Greenstadt’s article, “Mountain bikes shouldn’t be banned from wild landscapes” (Writers on the Range, 8/7/18), covered all the complaints of the wannabe wilderness bike riders without addressing the reason for their exclusion. Bikes, like all other wheeled vehicles, create a continuous groove in soft earth that serves to channel running water from rain or […]
Misguided new direction
After 30-plus years of constant reading, I have read my final issue of HCN (8/20/18). Brian Calvert’s recent editor’s notes and many of your more recent essays and writers’ opinions have left me saddened that what was once the finest journal on the issues affecting the Intermountain West seems to have become just another “woke” partisan magazine. […]
A fire deficit
Cally Carswell’s piece on life in the Southwest during aridification hit home with me, living as I do on the edge of the national forest near Santa Fe. The town sits at the base of two large national forest watersheds, both of which are heavily forested and choked with thickets of decadent trees born of […]
Human rehabilitation
“Restoration’s crisis in confidence” (HCN, 8/6/18) is a breath of fresh air. For far too long not only restoration’s promoters but also the media, foundations and government agencies that fund restoration projects have ignored the movement’s inherent contradictions, as well as its failure to deliver the “restoration” that has been promised. The problem, however, is […]
Shifting baselines
In “Restoration’s crisis of confidence” (HCN, 8/6/18), Maya Kapoor offers a thoughtful summary of current debates about the role of history in ecological restoration. Kapoor correctly describes how restorationists in the Southwest are moving away from their traditional focus on recovering historic baseline, or “reference,” conditions. Baselines have always been arbitrary and difficult to describe, […]
Double down on success
Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once said, “Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.” Gloria Dickie’s investigation (“Pay for Prey,” HCN, 7/23/18) into Oregon’s flawed wolf compensation program was welcome sunlight for a state that prides itself on its conservation ethic, but whose leaders have regrettably thrown wolves to the self-serving cattlemen. The […]
Funds and fortitude
Cally Carswell’s article “What are we doing here?” in the Aug. 6 issue finally prompted me to write and say what I’ve been meaning to for some time. I can’t express how your publication touches and moves me. You are doing great work conveying the issues and your perspective on life in the West and […]
Political theater
I really enjoyed Elliott Woods’ detailed and perceptive account of the July Donald Trump rally in Great Falls, Montana (“Montanans sightsee at a political circus,” HCN, 8/6/18). Great piece of reporting and analysis of the spirit behind these rallies, which are nothing if not repetitive, reductive and as habit-forming to our president as any opioid. […]
A never-ending fight
Congratulations to Anna V. Smith on her great article (“Reclaiming the Klamath,” HCN, 6/11/18). It’s really well done. I was a biologist with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service managing the Klamath River Restoration Program from 1975 to 1980, and I worked closely with the Yurok Tribe, gathering salmon harvest and population data on the […]
Gorilla in the room
“Pay for Prey” (HCN, 7/23/18), written by Gloria Dickie, nicely detailed Oregon’s efforts to manage both ranchers and wolves. Economic compensation programs exist in other Western states grappling with ongoing wolf colonization. Concerns raised in both camps with regard to data accuracy and program graft also persist. Still, cultural divides have always best clarified this issue, […]
The long view
Thank you, Anna V. Smith, for your article “Reclaiming the Klamath” (HCN, 6/11/18). And thank you, Amy Cordalis, for your hard work toward this end. A recreation outreach meeting was held in Copco, California, on June 12 by the Klamath River Renewal Corporation. Four community liaisons gave a presentation to an unfriendly, disruptive audience. Dam […]
The population problem
I was touched and saddened by Ben Long’s eloquent lament on the extinction of the Selkirk caribou (“A quiet goodbye to the Selkirk caribou,” HCN, 5/28/18). He rightly points out the necessity of ecosystem services provided by healthy forests to avoid the “emergency room” of the Endangered Species Act. He closes by wishing that America […]
A double-edged sword
I always appreciate Jonathan Thompson’s excellent journalism, but I didn’t quite get the point of his recent essay on air travel (“Jet Lag,” HCN, 5/14/18). I just returned from a multi-week cross-country trip myself, which is why I only now got around to reading it. Certainly air travel is uncomfortable and at times dehumanizing, but far […]
Hidden costs
While the serious potential economic (and other) costs of genetically engineered/genetically modified plants escaping into natural and agricultural landscapes (“Little Weed, Big Problem,” HCN, 6/25/18) are only beginning to be realized, they as yet pale in comparison to the massive and well-documented costs of the myriad non-genetically engineered/genetically modified plants that have escaped to invade […]
Misleading comparisons
I find the update on the Kilauea Volcano (HCN, 6/11/18) puzzling in the extreme. First of all, it describes the 1980 eruption of Mount St. Helens as the backstory to Kilauea’s current eruption, claiming that “Lessons from Mount St. Helens are proving useful in understanding Hawaii’s Kilauea Volcano.” The two volcanoes are entirely different with […]
Nothing new
Since the acquittal of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge occupiers in October 2016, HCN Associate Editor Tay Wiles has suggested that extremists on the radical right — bent on privatizing federal lands in the American West — have made great headway in rallying rural Westerners to their cause. “A Separatist State of Mind” (HCN, 1/22/18) argues that right-wing troubadours […]
A tailings-pile childhood
Ah, fond memories of growing up playing in the Animas (“The River of Lost Souls,” HCN, 5/28/18). I, too, well remember the dust from the tailings pile swirling through the valley and dusting the town. My brother, Woody, used to sneak over and ski the tailings pile. I’ve always wondered: Did the rare cancer that […]
