The film shoot, to folks living nearby, seemed to emerge out of nowhere.
In late September, orange-and-white traffic barricades shut down a normally quiet residential street east of the neon lights and brick facades of Livingston, Montana’s picturesque downtown. Cameras began rolling and actors dressed as Antifa rioters and U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement officers began firing blank rounds. The film crew eventually blew up a car.
The less literal explosions that followed weren’t confined to the closed streets, or even to Livingston. Soon, real-life protesters demonstrated against the movie, while extras portraying activists rioted on set. As cameras rolled, a private security team wielding functional weapons patrolled the street closures. Passersby observed the filming through the set’s barricades, many seemingly perplexed.
The movie — working title Pawn Shop — became politicized across the globe as both supporters and detractors of the film railed about the conflict on social media. The film features well-known Hollywood names, including Danny Trejo and Harvey Keitel. The Daily Wire, a conservative media outlet founded by right-wing commentator Ben Shapiro, is set to distribute the film on the organization’s streaming platform, which it markets as being “free of corporate influence and Leftist ideology.”
The dispute quickly became a proxy battle over immigration, free speech and the country’s political divide, which was mirrored in this small, southwestern Montana town of about 9,000 people just north of Yellowstone National Park. But more than a month after cameras stopped rolling and the online firestorm died down, Livingston residents and the people elected to represent them are still grappling with whether the controversial production, with its weeks of street closures, staged gunfire and explosions, exposed a hole in city planning.
“There’s a lot of checks and balances that were missed here,” said protester Brooklyn Wilde, whose Instagram and TikTok reels helped spread the word about the film across the country.
Now, officials and many community members say the city’s film regulations need an overhaul, raising even larger questions about how local governments balance economic opportunity, freedom of speech and their responsibility to protect their residents. Mountain Journal and High Country News spoke with more than a dozen community members, city officials, producers not affiliated with the shoot, and permitting experts to understand what went wrong. They described a permitting process and a city government ill-equipped for the scale of the production. But Pawn Shop producers still deny the city’s process was lax.
“The culture vultures protesting our movie are hiding behind a permitting regulatory process as a way to bludgeon their city commissioners into submission,” lead producer Dallas Sonnier said in an email. “This protest was 1,000% political from the start.”
SOON AFTER FILMING BEGAN, Keegan Nashan, a fiery protester in her early 30s, urged residents to disrupt the shoot on social media. Residents obliged. Passersby honked horns. Car alarms sounded down the road. Unhappy neighbors fired up power saws and DJed in their garages. Small, often loud, groups of protesters gathered near the set.

Nashan and others were concerned about the movie’s pro-ICE slant. In the weeks that followed, a new and larger group of people would voice different concerns about planning and regulation. But in the first hours of the shoot, Nashan and other protesters had obtained a leaked script, which Mountain Journal and High Country News also reviewed. It largely portrays illegal immigrants as criminals, rapists and gang members, and immigrants who entered the country legally as protagonists. One scene in particular drew detractors’ ire. The film’s main character, an ICE agent, shoots and kills a protester through her windshield. The movie portrays the agent’s actions as justified. But in that scene, protesters saw echoes of the real-life killing of Renee Good. ICE agents shot Good through her windshield in early 2026.
“The movie is pro-ICE for sure,” Ben Shapiro said in a YouTube video about the controversy.
Shapiro did not respond to an interview request, and producers declined to comment on the plot of the film. Too much detail, they said, could spoil it.
The production came to Livingston in part through real estate developer and filmmaker Carter Boehm. Boehm is executive producer on the movie and co-owns the Yellowstone Film Ranch in Paradise Valley, about a half hour south of town. He said producers approached him about filming in a building he owns in downtown Livingston as the movie’s “hero location.” He said his personal politics didn’t play a role and he didn’t think much ahead of time about the controversy that might ensue from filming a movie glorifying ICE operatives in a public space in the city.
“I really didn’t give a shit,” he said. “We’re bringing money into this town.”
Tina Kilborn, a property manager who catered meals for the Pawn Shop set and helped house cast and crew, was flummoxed to see the pushback. She welcomed the business.
“This is all pretend,” Kilborn said. “It’s just a movie. You guys know that Darryl Hannah isn’t really a mermaid, right? You know that Leonardo DiCaprio wasn’t on the Titanic. Where is all this anger coming from?”
In the early days of filming, Nashan stormed onto the set, shouting into a microphone. Video of the incident shows Nashan chanting and screaming obscenities — some of which she chose to mirror what an ICE agent said after killing Renee Good. In the video, Nashan’s amplified speech drowns out a stunt coordinator giving directions through a megaphone. That, producers later said, created dangerous conditions and disrupted delicate instructions that preserved actors’ safety.
Nashan said she was simply exercising her freedom of speech; no one told her at the time that she was endangering workers. In her mind, producers had a right to film their movie, but she also had a right to speak against it.
“I came in hot and I was mad,” Nashan said. “Maybe not my best moment, honestly.”
In response to early protests — the film crew also says someone drove on set, though the driver says he did so accidentally — producers asked to expand street closures and hired six private security guards. The city OK’d the moves. The guards donned bulletproof vests and carried several clips of ammunition as well as handguns and pepper spray. The security, protesters and some residents said, increased the tension in the community.
“They resemble paramilitary,” said protester Quenby Iandiorio, a Livingston-based musician. “And what’s more, they exactly resemble ICE patrol.”
Asked about the connection, Sonnier, the lead producer, simply said: “No idea.”
Iandiorio, in turn, wore a neon orange “Peaceful Observer Do Not Shoot” vest she picked up while protesting in the Twin Cities last winter after ICE agents killed Good and Alex Pretti.
“We increased security because protecting the people working for us is our responsibility,” producer Amanda Presmyk told the Livingston City Commission at one of two contentious hearings about the production’s permit. “That is very different than bringing armed security personnel into town to intimidate the public.”
Online, commenters on all sides fanned the flames. Millions of people viewed social media posts and news stories about the movie. In Livingston, a coffee shop fought off one-star Google reviews after a white nationalist group Tweeted about an anti-ICE sign in their window. Producers, security and protesters all reported death threats, doxxing and constant fear stemming from the hostile digital discourse. By the time filming concluded on Oct. 10, Nashan and at least five others had received criminal citations, most for charges like disturbing the peace and disorderly conduct.
FROM HER OFFICE in the Livingston Food Resource Center, Executive Director Kaya Patten-Fusselman watched the facade of the movie’s titular pawn shop go up across the street before the filming — and protests — started in late September. Her organization, a nonprofit food pantry, serves 1 in 8 Park County residents.
Patten-Fusselman said she had to call the city to find out what was going on. She learned her building was in the set closure. Patten-Fusselman said she first heard from producers themselves on Sept. 22, shortly before filming began. Ordinarily, her organization asks for at least a month of notice to prepare for any event that could change how people access the pantry, which serves some of the area’s most vulnerable residents. This time, she said, she had only days to respond and no input on what happened next.
“I had no way of saying, ‘No, you can’t do this,’” Patten-Fusselman said. “I wasn’t part of that conversation.” Producers, however, say they followed the city’s instructions. In commission testimony, they said they were in touch with the food pantry every day service was disrupted.

“We operated under a city issued permit, followed its parameters, and performed the work that the city authorized us to do,” Presmyk, the producer, said in a commission meeting. “Nobody on this production wants anyone to miss a meal or feel unwelcome accessing essential services.”
When the shoot moved from a residential street to the food pantry’s neighborhood downtown, armed security guards stopped cars on their way to the pantry, multiple sources said. Additional street closures added to confusion about how patrons could access pantry services at all. Patten-Fusselman said some patrons turned around when they saw the scene and attendance at the food pantry hit an 8-week low during the shoot.
Rather than protesting the film’s politics, Patten-Fusselman, along with hundreds of other community members, showed up at the two marathon city commission meetings in October to talk about what the movie meant for people caught in its path. She and others argued that Livingston hadn’t adequately accounted for the community disruption, and that the regulatory process wasn’t robust enough for a shoot that closed down city streets for two and a half weeks.
“We have clients who live in their cars in the valley who we didn’t see for three weeks, who don’t have access to housing, who were too scared to come,” she said. “In the absence of policy, where does human decency come in?”
Patten-Fusselman and other residents who hadn’t participated in the protests began raising a broader question: How had a production of this scale been approved in the first place?
At the two packed public meetings, commissioners heard from concerned residents and supporters of the film. Nashan and other protesters stood shoulder-to-shoulder with a different set of community members like Patten-Fusselman, voicing new concerns around city planning and community safeguards, wholly separate from the movie’s content.
“Ryan Gosling could be riding a unicorn in the streets,” community member Bex Frucht told commissioners. “If one child missed their macaroni and cheese or one grandma couldn’t get to her groceries, I would say the same thing: Shut it down, revoke the permit.”
In the first meeting, the commission voted to pause the permit. Then, the filmmakers’ attorney, Bozeman-based Matthew Monforton, sent a legal threat alleging that Livingston residents who didn’t like the movie’s subject matter had initiated a “sustained, escalating campaign of intimidation and sabotage.” Monforton argued that the production pause violated the First Amendment. City commissioners reversed course. Filming continued, with more conditions attached to the permit: focusing the security guards on cast and crew, not residents; maintaining access to the food pantry; and blocking simulated violence from view.
The Livingston City Commission was not involved with the original permitting process. City Manager Grant Gager reviewed and approved the permit. He did not respond to repeated requests for an interview over phone, text and email.
Pawn Shop producers filled out Livingston’s 3-page filming questionnaire and sent it to Gager on Sept. 9, less than two weeks before the shoot’s start date, according to public records. Filmmakers sent him an urgent follow-up email the afternoon before filming began. Gager responded about 15 minutes later, approving the project with a set of conditions. The next day, Livingston’s Public Works Director Shannon Holmes told producers to notify area businesses and residents of the closures — and specifically encouraged the film team to talk with the food pantry.
The producers’ application didn’t mention a security team. Producers initially answered the question “What are your security plans” with “NA.” In its application, the city doesn’t say how film crews need to notify neighbors, and instead asks, “Have local neighborhood groups/businesses been notified of your event concept?” Producers said “Yes” to both and that notification was ongoing. Still, Patten-Fusselman argues the planning process in Livingston failed the city because residents weren’t adequately notified — and the process was too short. In Livingston, a single-day street closure for a special event requires at least six weeks’ notice. Pawn Shop gave less than two. And the food pantry, she maintained, was an afterthought.
“Sometimes, we don’t know that we’re missing something until something goes wrong,” Patten-Fusselman said. “The green-lighting of a permit that blocks access to an essential service went wrong.”
Film regulations
Across the United States, cities regulate a wide range of filming in different ways.
Some cities have dedicated film offices, boards or commissions, according to FilmUSA. Smaller municipalities often have less staffing and less formal processes in place. Livingston and Bozeman are the only cities in Montana with film permitting processes.
Some areas actively market their lack of regulations. “Most of our cities don’t require film permits, saving you time and money,” the Idaho Department of Commerce’s film website reads.
But where regulations are in place, local codes often exist to protect the public. In Bozeman, filmmakers need written permission from the police department if a shoot involves depictions of violence, and need the same written sign-off from local businesses within a street closure. In Boise, Idaho, producers are responsible for notifying all residents within a 300-foot radius of the production. In Atlanta, Georgia, regulations are even more protective of residents: Producers must notify everyone within three blocks of the shoot and obtain signatures in “sensitive areas.”
Some cities also have tiers of regulations based on the length and impact of shoots. “High-impact” shoots in Everett, Washington, require sign-offs from affected neighbors at least 72 hours in advance of filming.
FilmUSA representatives said it’s not common for film permits to receive public comment, but it does happen on occasion. In Pasadena, California, any resident can request a public hearing for “long-term” shoots that last more than six days in a residential neighborhood.
But Pawn Shop producers don’t think permitting was mishandled, or that it was particularly lenient in the first place.
“Don’t overestimate the permitting process here as a factor for why anyone shoots a movie in Livingston,” Sonnier said via email. “That process is relatively standard in all places except major cities like Los Angeles where they are over-regulated and politically hostile.”
See the “Film regulations” sidebar for more on how other cities regulate filmmaking.
In the end, Patten-Fusselman felt producers took advantage of the city’s lack of preparedness. The intensifying discourse around the movie’s content, she said, muddied deeper concerns about oversights in government processes and what they mean for the people affected by them.
In response to that sentiment, Sonnier said: “Anyone hiding behind the ‘permitting process gone awry’ excuse is a liar.”
“Inflammatory rhetoric is easier than nuance,” Patten-Fusselman said. After filming ended, she added, the food pantry went from seeing about 80 households a day shopping to more than 100. “The impact was poignant.”
LIVINGSTON IS NO STRANGER to Hollywood. A River Runs Through It was filmed here in the early 1990s, kicking off a wave of filmmaking interest in Montana’s wide-open spaces. Then, the television show Yellowstone premiered in 2018, spurring a new wave of cinematic interest in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem.
But before Pawn Shop, the city was accustomed to productions that lasted a couple hours, not a couple weeks. In his four years in Livingston, City Manager Grant Gager told commissioners in testimony that he’d handled only a handful of film permits. Most, he said, went largely unnoticed. Prior to Pawn Shop, the most impactful shoot he’d dealt with was a car commercial that required a two and a half-hour intermittent road closure on a Saturday morning.
The city had little experience with a production of this size and duration, let alone one that would generate such a fierce public backlash. The fallout may have been difficult to anticipate.
“When something goes wrong, one side always wants to blame the other side,” said Tony Armer, co-director of FilmUSA, an advocacy group for film commissions, which help attract productions to specific areas across the U.S. Critics could fault the production company for not being good neighbors, or city officials for not asking enough questions or communicating transparently with the public, he said. “But there’s more than enough blame to always go to both parties.”
Gager described a “gray area” in Livingston city code around who bears responsibility for administering film permits. He took the lead and told commissioners his decisions were in line with past permitting decisions. The Pawn Shop production was at times “out of compliance” with its permit, Gager said, describing only one example involving profanity-laden graffiti on set. In that case, Gager said he worked with the production team to get things back on track.

In at least one instance highlighted by the public, Gager’s decisions may have conflicted with Livingston ordinance, which prohibits people from firing any firearm within city limits. The city’s film application doesn’t ask if film crews plan to fire blanks, but Gager implicitly gave permission for the Pawn Shop film crew to do so by requiring them to call the Livingston Police Department beforehand. “To my knowledge, that was done every time they used blanks,” Livingston Police Chief Wayne Hard told Mountain Journal and High Country News.
But allowing blank firing likely should have required sign-off from the city commission, said Dan Clark, the director of Montana State University’s Local Government Center. Much like in more ordinary events like waiving restrictions on open containers of alcohol for a music festival, firing guns — even on a film set — should need review from the city’s legislative branch if city law prohibits that otherwise, Clark said.
Wayne, the police chief, declined to comment when Mountain Journal and High Country News asked if he’d been consulted about the legality of firing blanks. City Attorney Jon Hesse did not respond to a similar request for comment.
If Gager in some way erred in making the decision around blank rounds, Clark said, it actually underscores what the city manager told commissioners: There’s a “gray area” about who’s responsible for film permitting. Should staff handle it without public input? Or should commissioners deliberate aspects of the permit in public meetings? Friction between the branches of local government is relatively common, Clark said.
“Life changes, things evolve,” he said.
Now, Livingston commissioners say they need to update their rules. In an Oct. 3 meeting, Commissioner James Willich described Pawn Shop as a large-scale shoot that required large-scale policy Livingston lacks. “I think we need to take a real hard look as a community and as the city entity. How do we move forward?” he said. “We’ve got a spotlight on the holes we’re missing, our loopholes. They were pointed out to us glaringly.”
About two weeks later, the city commission moved to overhaul the city’s film-permitting process as soon as possible.
Officials and residents have not, however, agreed on what those loopholes are. Commissioners have been reluctant to talk to the press about what, exactly, they see as the problem. But many residents Mountain Journal and High Country News spoke with wanted more public notice, particularly for events that could disrupt daily life.
In a brief interview, Commissioner Jessica Wilcox said Livingston needs a more robust public engagement process for regulating movies but declined to comment further until the public policymaking process plays out. Other commissioners declined repeated interview requests, instead pointing Mountain Journal and High Country News to the public record.
The political fallout over the shoot continues. In early November, commissioners asked Gager, the city manager, to resign. Ultimately, he did, less than a week later. In a public meeting about his resignation, commissioners were vague about the reasons, and instead cited breakdowns in communication and accountability, as well as differences in long-term visions for the city. Without concrete information, community members publicly debated whether his decisions around Pawn Shop were to blame. Gager did not respond to requests for comment about his resignation.
MORE THAN A MONTH after filming wrapped, the pawn shop facade, set barricades and armed security guards are gone. Boehm said Pawn Shop is scheduled to premiere in February 2027. But unlike other productions filmed near Livingston, he said the movie likely won’t debut in town. Still, he argued the producers came out on top in the attention economy.

“It’s the best thing that could happen,” Boehm said. Amid the coverage and outcry, millions of people who might otherwise never have heard of the movie learned its name. Boehm heard from The Daily Wire that new subscriptions had already covered the film’s $1.5-million budget.
“I guess I should thank Keegan [Nashan] for that,” Boehm said. “I won’t.”
Nashan has mixed feelings about her role in the protests and is still fighting her criminal charges. She felt a moral obligation to hold the movie and the security team accountable. “If you say nothing, then you are complicit, and I refuse to be complicit,” she said. But she also regrets unwittingly bringing attention to the production. “Shame is maybe too strong. But I feel sort of upset by doing that inadvertently, and wish I’d had a bit more forethought on how to go about doing what I’d wanted to do.”
She sighed. “But it’s all done.”
At least, until next time.
Mountain Journal and High Country News asked Sonnier, the lead producer, if, after all the drama from protesters and the city, he’d come back to shoot in Livingston again.
“You bet we will!” he said over email, citing one of his favorite filmmakers, Sam Peckinpah — renowned for graphic, often beautiful depictions of violence — who lived the last years of his life in a Livingston hotel. “Peckinpah wouldn’t have it any other way.”
This story was produced as part of the Western Environmental Reporting Collaborative, a partnership between the Mountain Journal and The Montana Free Press, High Country News, Report for America and local news organizations across the West.
We welcome reader letters. Email High Country News at editor@hcn.org or submit a letter to the editor. See our letters to the editor policy.

