“A Cherokee for Trump” and “Party Favors” (12/9/19) by Graham Lee Brewer and Will Ford seem bookends to each other, detailing really bad politics. Both portend a dismal outcome for our nation. In Brewer’s article, the Oklahoma congressman seems to enjoy contradictory support from his own fragmented people.(“There are a lot of conservative hardcore evangelical Cherokees who believe […]
Letter to the editor
Kindergarteners connect to wildlife
The kindergarten/first grade class at the Idaho campus of Teton Science Schools’ Mountain Academy was thrilled to see your cover story about wildlife crossings (“Crossing to Safety,” 1/1/20). Throughout the fall and early winter, our class has been studying our local Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem and the animals that live here. Our focus turned towards animal […]
Patagonia goes grassroots
“How Big Rec picks its battles” (11/25/19) distorts Patagonia’s long-standing advocacy to protect public land. The reporter is right to care about border communities impacted by this administration’s grotesque policies and the lack of diversity in the outdoor industry; both are deeply concerning, and Patagonia is addressing them through direct action. But the implication that […]
Slick headgear
Is this part of HCN’s new slick magazine approach (“Worse for Wear,” 1/1/20)? To keep reposting simplistic analyses of headgear? I kept thinking of the often-printed image of HCN’s founder, Tom Bell, and what he would have thought of your cowboy hat editorial. I understand what the editorial was trying to accomplish, but is this […]
Electrifying existing dams
In “Is Renewable Energy’s Future Dammed?” (11/25/19) Nick Bowlin asks an important question, but fails to mention some critical facts that we need to weigh when thinking about future hydropower projects. According to the National Inventory of Dams, maintained by the Army Corps of Engineers, there are 91,468 dams in the United States — the […]
Entrance fee for newcomers
The folks who have been in Wyoming for generations would probably prefer that the decisions about Wyoming’s future were left to them, rather than all the “wonderful schemes” those moving from other places have in mind. (“Coal state struggles,” 12/9/19). What they should do is charge an entrance fee for all the newcomers and tourists. […]
Reporters in their own communities
This profile of Markwayne Mullin (“A Cherokee for Trump,” 12/9/19) by Graham Lee Brewer is an incredible piece, and yet another example from High Country News as to why it’s crucial for Native reporters and editors to be hired to cover their own communities. —Nick Martin This article appeared in the print edition of the […]
U.S. oppression or engineering marvel?
It couldn’t be that the Transcontinental Railroad opened up thousands of square miles of land, connecting it back to civilization (“Gilded Age problems,” 12/9/19). It couldn’t be that it was an engineering marvel of its time. Nor could it have been an economic boom at the time. Nope, HCN just takes history and spins it […]
Un-wilding wild horse lands
Jonathan Thompson aptly calls out Bureau of Land Management Acting Director William Perry Pendley’s big lie about the “existential threat” to public lands (“BLM chief ’s wild horse fixation,” 11/25/19). Sadly, Thompson goes on to refer to the estimated 88,000 wild horses on public lands, stating that their “hooves trample and lay waste to big swaths of […]
When the coal bubble bursts
It never ends well when a whole local economy is based on nonrenewable natural resource (“Coal state struggles,” 12/9/19). Communities all over the world want the jobs that mining brings, but then their children or grandchildren end up living through the burst of the bubble. —Taal Levi This article appeared in the print edition of […]
‘Destructive’ extraction taking up prime real estate
Whether coal has been “good to Wyoming” or not is pretty debatable (“Coal state struggles,” 12/9/19). Much of the cleanup costs will fall on the state’s taxpayers, and Wyoming doesn’t have much of a tax base as it is, much less after a large part of its income (and its workers) leaves. Wyoming needs to […]
Churlish review
At its core, Carl Segerstrom’s churlish review of Chris Ketcham’s This Land (“The West is more than heroes and villains” HCN, 11/11/19) provides perfect testimony to why the book is so needed at this time. The writing shatters the myths and illusions that ranchers are the salt of the earth, the very fabric that holds the […]
Eloquently missing the point
Carl Segerstrom’s harsh review of This Land (“The West is more than heroes and villains,” HCN, 11/11/19) dwells too much on the book’s style and tone, distracting from Christopher Ketcham’s compelling indictment of a century of severe and relentless damage to public lands in the Southwest. Segerstrom crafts clever turns of phrase to highlight his own […]
Energy and national security
Thank you for this important article pointing out the numerous vulnerabilities disproportionately faced by low-income residents and people of color during a crisis (“Solar inequalities,” HCN, 11/25/19). After Hurricane Katrina and every subsequent hurricane, I have said to a friend or co-worker that cities should have neighborhood resiliency centers with PV. I’ve been saying that, […]
Nailed it, Carl Segerstrom
You describe the West, with all its (“The West is more than heroes and villains,” HCN, 11/11/19). I could barely get through the inside cover of This Land; it’s a fiction of romantic idealism disconnected from the realities of our region, and the complex and pragmatic work to “save” it. Chase GunnellBallard, Washington, via Twitter This […]
Sea lions are acting naturally
I want to comment on a phrase that was used in the recent article entitled “The ineffectual bombing of sea lions” (HCN, 9/16/19). In it, the authors describe the behavior of the sea lions eating the fish out of the fishermen’s nets as “unabashed thievery.” This is the second time I have read an article […]
A reason not to hunt
“Killing the Goat” was a great article and reminds me of my decision to never hunt again. Halas’ lost goat was my lost elk years before in Colorado. Never again! Ron Mannhalter, via Twitter This article appeared in the print edition of the magazine with the headline A reason not to hunt.
False kinship
I have been reading HCN since 2001, during my early college days at Western State in Gunnison. I have never been as unimpressed by an essay as I was by Gabriela Halas’ “Killing the Goat” (HCN, 10/28/19). The writer’s “true kinship” with the two animals she killed retards the idea of hunting ethics and spirituality […]
Humans vs. predators
As far as I know, no one is currently sure of the history of chronic wasting disease (“Weighing the risks”). One theory is that it has been around for many millennia, but was controlled by predators like wolves, mountain lions and bears eating the ungulates that were less able to escape them. So predators removed […]
Modern hunting
Emily Benson diplomatically raises some of the issues surrounding hunting in a modern society (“The power of hunting,” HCN, 10/28/19). There are three additional items worth pointing out. First: Show me the cost-benefit analysis for hunting. It might prove out for subsistence hunters or rural folks shooting game in their hayfields, but for most urbanites, […]
