On Election Day, Jaynie Parrish’s organization Arizona Native Vote, was fielding calls to organize rides to the polls for Indigenous communities in the Four Corners area affected by historic flooding. Parrish’s team works with voters on a community level to make sure their vote is counted. Alongside getting people to the polls, they were contemplating the impacts Proposition 144 in Arizona’s midterm election might have on voters. The ballot measure sought to change the state constitution to require voters provide identification when voting, including on absentee and mail-in ballots. Arizonans already have to show proof of citizenship when registering to vote and provide identification when voting in person according to state statute. 

“It’s already hard for our people to vote,” said Parrish, executive director of Arizona Native Vote and a citizen of the Navajo Nation. “This makes it that much more difficult.”

Ultimately, Prop 144 failed, and voters also rejected ballot measures in California and Colorado that would have introduced or added to existing voter ID requirements. Prop 144 and such ballot measures reflected a national push by Republican legislators and conservative groups to pass stricter voter identification laws, add federal voting restrictions, and bolster unsubstantiated claims by President Donald Trump of fraud in elections.

Native nations and voting rights organizations oppose these efforts because they disenfranchise Native voters. Laws that require government-issued photo identification can be a hurdle for Native voters because of the cost, or because they may have to travel long distances to obtain an ID. Some voter ID laws require ID with a photo or residential address, which tribal IDs may not include.

Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community took the step of urging voters not to pass Prop 144.

“Native people, including the members of this community, were the last people to become citizens of the United States through the Indian Citizenship Act 1924,” said Gary Bohnee, special assistant for congressional and legislative affairs for the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community and an enrolled citizen of the Gila River Indian Community. “But even though that was when it was passed, it took litigation in both 1928, and I believe in 1948 for litigation brought here in Arizona, for Native people to have access to the vote.”

It’s because of that history that the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community always weighs in on legislation or policies that would create obstacles for voters. Bohnee added, “Making it easier for people to be able to vote has been paramount.”

About 50% of the registered voters in the Community vote by mail, and Prop 144 would have required voters to provide identification on mailed-in ballots, although specifics of how or if tribal IDs would be acceptable was unclear, Bohnee said.

In Nevada, however, voters did pass a ballot measure by a wide margin to change the state’s constitution and require a government-issued identification when voting in person. The state currently doesn’t have requirements to show ID when voting at polls, and voting advocates are concerned that the change will negatively impact Native voters in particular. Jennifer Willett, senior campaign manager for All Voting is Local in Nevada, said that while tribal IDs are included on the list of acceptable identification that a voter can show, it also requires a photo on the ID, which not all tribal IDs have.

“That’s a problem through creating a barrier for people wanting to vote, but it’s also a problem with interfering on tribal sovereignty,” said Willett. “Tribes should be able to decide what’s on their ID.” 

Arizona has existing voter ID requirements but rejected the latest attempt to add more. Such requirements can result in some Native voters being turned away because poll workers are unfamiliar with tribal IDs, according to Natalia Sells, senior campaign manager for All Voting is Local in Arizona. 


“That’s a problem through creating a barrier for people wanting to vote, but it’s also a problem with interfering on tribal sovereignty. Tribes should be able to decide what’s on their ID.” 

Arizona’s failed ballot measure had previous iterations in the state legislature as unsuccessful bills. Gov. Katie Hobbs, a Democrat, has vetoed many of the dozens of introduced elections-related bills, which Bohnee said has increased in the state since the 2020 election. The bills often use language focused on preventing non-citizens from voting, Sells said, but include restrictions that would limit eligible voters.

This is one reason why the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community and other Native nations support the Native American Voting Rights Act. The bill “would protect or create a federal backstop to protect voter rights of everyone from states that may be attempting to change laws in ways that would impact tribal voters,” said Bohnee. The act would require a polling location in every tribal community, for example, and mandate voting materials be provided in Indigenous languages.

According to a midterms election poll by First Nations Development Institute and BSP Research released this week, the majority of Native voters polled are concerned about voter rights, and 77% want to see a new voting rights protection act passed in Congress. With Democrats now in control of the House and the Senate in Congress, there’s a real possibility that a bill in the near future could do just that.

We welcome reader letters. Email High Country News at editor@hcn.org or submit a letter to the editor. See our letters to the editor policy.

Spread the word. News organizations can pick-up quality news, essays and feature stories for free.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Anna V. Smith is an associate editor of High Country News. She writes and edits stories on tribal sovereignty and environmental justice for the Indigenous Affairs desk.