Rants from the Hill: “Lawn Guilt”

 

“Rants from the Hill” are Michael Branch’s monthly musings on life in the high country of western Nevada’s Great Basin Desert.

Henry David Thoreau’s neighbors generally thought of him as a lazy, confrontational, sanctimonious pain in the ass. They might be interested to know that he turned out to be right about nearly everything, from his strident support for the abolition of slavery, to his scathing exposure of the injustice of the Mexican-American War, to his embracing of then-new evolutionary theory, to his claim that the American relationship to nature was becoming commodified, superficial, and exploitative. Perhaps the best example of Thoreau being right ahead of his time is offered by his vehement condemnation of the American lawn. In his remarkable 1862 deathbed essay, “Walking,” Thoreau wrote that “Hope and the future are not in lawns.” Instead, he imagined establishing his home on a plot of land covered with wild plants and trees. “Why not put my house, my parlor, behind this plot,” he asked, “instead of behind that meager assemblage of curiosities, that poor apology for a Nature and Art, which I call my front yard?”

Calling his neighbors’ front yards a “poor apology for a Nature and Art” is the sort of sarcastic face slap that cranky Uncle Henry specialized in, and it tells you something that one of his final utterances before leaving this world was a condemnation of lawns. As usual, he turned out to be right. Riddle: considered acre-for-acre, what is the most pesticide, herbicide, water, labor, and cash-intensive crop grown in the U.S.? Right. Your lawn. In America our turf grasses, which are non-native, cover 21 million acres (think the state of Maine), cost 40 billion dollars per year (more than U.S. foreign aid), consume around 90 million pounds of fertilizer and 80 million pounds of pesticides per year (which sometimes end up contaminating our ground and surface water), and drink an inconceivable eight billion gallons of water per day (here in the West, where we can least afford to squander the liquid gold, as much as half of all residential water use is associated with lawns and landscaping).

Satellite image of the Ranting Hill, with tiny lawn, surrounded by juniper-dotted sagebrush ocean.

All this is before we reckon the colossal time suck that lawns represent: each year Americans spend an average of three billion hours pushing or (even worse) riding mowers, most of which pollute at a rate ten times that of our cars. In fact, if a lawn were a car, it would be a hummer: a resource-intensive, plainly unsustainable luxury item that looks pretty good but isn’t especially useful. As for biodiversity, forget it. Lawns are exotic, barren monocultures. While they are sometimes referred to as “ecological deserts,” this characterization is an insult to deserts, which are often remarkably biodiverse ecosystems. Then there are the unhappy symbolic connotations of the lawn. As food writer Michael Pollan points out, the American lawn is the ultimate manifestation of our culture’s perverse fantasy of the total control of nature. As Pollan put it so memorably, “A lawn is nature under totalitarian rule.”

Now hang with me while I descend from my eco-soapbox to offer this surprising confession: I have a lawn. I’m a westerner. A desert rat. An environmentalist. Even an admirer of Thoreau (though it does chap my hide that he’s always right). But I have a lawn and I love it. Of course my dual status as arid lands environmentalist and lawn-watering dolt has provoked in me a serious identity crisis, one that reminds me of another Thoreau insight (this one from Walden): “Do not let your left hand know what your right hand does.” Am I proud of my lawn? Hell no! I’m completely ashamed of it. I have a terminal case of lawn guilt. But at the risk of having my membership in the Wilderness Society revoked, it is time to come clean about my immoderate love of the lawn I have planted here on the Ranting Hill.

For me the first challenge is squaring a condition of brutal lawnlessness with fond memories of my suburban childhood, in which the grassy yard provided the most immediate respite from concrete and asphalt. Lawns were our play zones, the part of the vernacular landscape that could be experienced with all our senses, and one of the few suburban spaces not specifically designed to accommodate cars. Even if your old man was on his hands and knees pulling crabgrass every Saturday morning, for the rest of the week the lawn remained the sovereign province of children—a little patch of freedom that functioned as a clean, green canvas that we kids painted with our imaginations.

CoyotePups.jpg
Trio of coyote pups denning near the Ranting Hill.

Like a lot of suburban boys, I also experienced the lawn as the first significant site of labor. Before I reached age 16 and landed a job stocking the beer cooler in the local drugstore, the lawn was the only game in town for an enterprising kid who was willing to work hard and needed a little cash. I built a pretty decent side biz as a mower, and in this sense the American lawn bought me a new bike, a fishing trip, and tickets to some memorable rock shows. As I got a bit older, lawn mowing even functioned as my French Foreign Legion. I spent one summer as a mower for a small company comprised entirely of guys who had been recently dumped by their girlfriends. My mowing partner that summer was a Harley dude named Chaos who somehow survived on a diet consisting solely of Schlitz beer and corn nuts. Sometimes Chaos and I would knock out 20 lawns in a day. Between yards we’d crank up Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band on the battered old truck’s cassette deck and lament that we’d been cast away by girls who, we told each other, just didn’t have their heads on straight. When I later got my own head on straight and went to college, so revered was the lawn that my school had a world famous precision lawnmower brigade that routinely stole the show from reputable marching bands during parades.

Of course those are memories from another place and time, and rationalizing turf grass here at 6,000 feet in the Great Basin Desert is another matter entirely. Still, I’m willing to attempt a modest defense. To begin with, our lawn is quite small, is on only one side of the house, and is surrounded by the rest of our property, 49 acres of wild desert that we have deliberately left undisturbed. I never use herbicides on the little yard, the fertilizer I apply is slow-release and organic, and the watering regime is strictly limited and carefully timed for efficiency. Outside the lawn, almost every tree and shrub I’ve planted is a local or regional native, most of which are hardy and xeric. The lawn keeps the dust down, and has also reduced the number of scorpions and rattlers we encounter immediately outside the house. Having the lawn also helps to cool the place in summer, working in tandem with our passive solar home design to make it possible for us to exist here without air conditioning.

Kris Loman
Kris Loman
Jul 08, 2014 02:16 PM
I was all prepared to go judgmental on you, but you made an excellent case. On the whole, your "firebreak"transgression is pretty darn minor. Now if you're still eating meat on the other hand...:)
Bob Hartung
Bob Hartung
Jul 08, 2014 02:53 PM
Be sure not to bite your tongue too hard.
Richard Crow
Richard Crow
Jul 08, 2014 03:47 PM
When we moved from Colorado Springs (golf course lawn with roses) to the mountains at 8,500' above seal level, we gave up a formal lawn for a wild natural one, and we love it. We have deer, bears, and foxes who bed down in it. The wild flowers are drought tolerant (we lost some varieties in the 2002 drought though). I don't have to mow it, fertilize it, water it ($200 a month if you do), or worry over it. Colorado is semi-arid and most lawns below the mountains should be desert plants, but aren't. When we went to Scottsdale, AZ in May I thought I was in Miami with all the heavily irrigated tropical plants and lawns. It was beautiful but totally inappropriate.
Carolyn Hopper
Carolyn Hopper Subscriber
Jul 08, 2014 09:57 PM
The monoculture of a lawn, the costs involved, the pressure to keep it green.... Read
Michael Pollen's "Second Nature" to discover how the whole idea of lawns and the supposed importance of having lawns began. We've all been hoodwinked by ancestors about the reason for having lawns. Time to begin the end of formal lawns - we'll all be better off. There should be a national movement to begin downsizing lawns. It will be a hard habit to break, but it must be done. It is completely unappropriate to have a lawn.
That said - I live in a subdivision that "requires" a lawn. Ugh. When I move I will find a place that does not. Yes they look nice and green, but so do wild grasses and wildflowers appear pleasant.
Carolyn Hopper
Carolyn Hopper Subscriber
Jul 08, 2014 09:57 PM
The monoculture of a lawn, the costs involved, the pressure to keep it green.... Read
Michael Pollen's "Second Nature" to discover how the whole idea of lawns and the supposed importance of having lawns began. We've all been hoodwinked by ancestors about the reason for having lawns. Time to begin the end of formal lawns - we'll all be better off. There should be a national movement to begin downsizing lawns. It will be a hard habit to break, but it must be done. It is completely unappropriate to have a lawn.
That said - I live in a subdivision that "requires" a lawn. Ugh. When I move I will find a place that does not. Yes they look nice and green, but so do wild grasses and wildflowers appear pleasant.
Bill Schiffbauer
Bill Schiffbauer Subscriber
Jul 09, 2014 07:33 AM
Your lawn is like a bit of Jack. Enjoy in moderation
Rosemary Carey
Rosemary Carey
Jul 09, 2014 04:03 PM
Instead of a bermuda grass or other common exotic turfgrass lawn, a much less thirsty alternative would be a Buffalograss cultivar (Buchloe dactyloides). Buffalograss is native from Nevada to Illinois and Texas to Saskatchewan, so there is a very large gene pool for breeders to choose from. Buffalo Supreme or UC Verde are two cultivars developed for hot, arid areas which bear looking into. This is a fine-bladed grass, so is soft to the touch. Buffalograss requires 75% less water than a bermuda grass lawn, so there's no need for guilt.