The message of trees marked in blue

 

In late December, just after the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated protection for all of the roadless national forests we have left in the West, I walked up Deadwood Ridge in southern Idaho to see what we'd saved.

The trail climbs through a ponderosa pine forest that continues to evade logging. Back in 1996, it was targeted by the Salvage Rider, thanks to Congress, that negated public review and environmental laws. But the Forest Service made a major tactical error: It marked the trees to be cut with bright blue paint.

That allowed conservationists the chance to take dozens of citizens, TV, radio and newspaper reporters, congressional staff and various Forest Service staffers up this trail to see 40-inch-in-diameter, orange-barked, fire-resilient ponderosa pine giants. There they stood, magnificent and ringed in blue paint.

Ponderosa pine evolved to withstand flames passing below and around them. On Deadwood Ridge and in other old growth stands, trees stand far apart in open grassy slopes, with limbs beginning 30 feet above the ground. The big pines told the story of ecology losing out to logging, and people could see the loss for themselves.

Blue trees also funded what turned out to be an effective set of pit-bull activists with a legal bent, the Idaho Sporting Congress. The small group won $26,000 in legal fees after showing that the $450,000 the Forest Service spent marking 86,000 trees -- both big trees and small -- committed resources before an official decision.

Six years later, all the marked trees remain, their paint flaking off. Some trees have died, becoming snags and wildlife habitat. Over time, more trees will die and fall into the river, providing habitat for fish, while others will rot into the ground and add nutrients to the soil. This is the place where the Forest Service once expected to log 20,000 acres out of 50,000 acres of this remnant forest and haul out as much as 50 million board-feet. That's the equivalent of 10,000 truckloads.

Only public outrage and the promise of lawsuits stopped logging here and elsewhere in the roadless forests of the West. Wildlife and fish studies, economic analyses and public opinion polls all showed greater benefits for leaving forests as forests. Except for what logging does to boost local economies, forests left intact always bring greater benefits.

The closest sawmill to Deadwood Ridge, at Horseshoe Bend, relied on old-growth timber. It closed in 1998. The area's biggest sawmill, at Cascade, which depended on clearcuts, closed in 2001. Most, if not all, of the timber workers at these mills would have preferred another six months on the job. But this leads to an obvious question: Is it worth it to log the last roadless forests?

It's hard to find anyone who thinks so. At a sawmill that closed in northwest Montana late last year, one operator finally owned up to the crushing market conditions he was facing. He said he had no leeway to hang on for another year, much less establish sustainable practices.

It is well established that the Forest Service loses money on virtually every roadless timber sale. Other kinds of losses are the damage to streams and erosion of security for wildlife from new roads, and the recreation opportunities displaced during logging, which some say are lost forever.

Meanwhile, on Deadwood Ridge, it's no secret that wildfire is coming; the question is when. Do we light it ourselves or wait for lightning or human error? If we'd spent the hundreds of thousands of dollars on prescribed fire at Deadwood, instead of on its failed logging plans, we'd be far safer.

Maybe we could even have agreed to remove brush and small trees if we weren't fighting over logging the giants. But prescribed fire wasn't considered a viable alternative on its own. When the cut was jettisoned, good planning went out with the bad.

These roadless protection issues go beyond this place; they've become another political ping-pong ball. The Bush administration has shown that it won't embrace roadless protection by choice; it will chip away at what we have left with a "balanced approach" that allows so-called temporary roads and thinning. But continuing outmoded practices to maintain political support from an industry in decline is not a fair trade for mismanaging our intact forests.

It's time to move on, farther up the trail.

John McCarthy is a contributor to Writers on the Range, a service of High Country News in Paonia, Colorado (hcn.org). He lives in Boise, Idaho, and directs policy for the Idaho Conservation League, which intervened in court as a supporter of the Clinton administration's roadless rule.

High Country News Classifieds
  • RANCH GENERAL MANAGER
    Ranch General Manager for a large family-owned Ranch on the island of Molokai, Hawaii. Diversified operations include: an agro-tourism educational retreat center, renewable energy and...
  • COMMUNICATIONS AND PROJECT COORDINATOR CONTRACTOR
    POSITION SUMMARY: The Communications and Project Coordinator will support the Executive Director (ED) in campaign and administrative related tasks. The Coordinator is responsible for research...
  • HOMESICK: WHY HOUSING IS UNAFFORDABLE AND HOW WE CAN CHANGE IT
    A timely, damning, and ultimately hopeful investigation of housing in the United States. Essential reading in the West.
  • OREGON AGRICULTURAL LAND EASEMENT (ALE) PROGRAM COORDINATOR
    Status: Full time Reports to: Conservation Program Manager Salary Range: $60,000-65,000 Duration: Position is funded for 12 months, with the expectation of annual renewal Benefits:...
  • VICE PRESIDENT OF CONSERVATION
    The Vice President of Conservation will arrive at a time of remarkable growth and opportunity within the organization. Guided by the bold and ambitious goals...
  • WINTER WILDLANDS ALLIANCE IS HIRING!
    Help us inspire and empower people to protect America's wild snowscapes! We are a small, mighty and growing team dedicated to our work and looking...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR- ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION COMMITTEE OF WEST MARIN
    The EAC's Executive Director provides overall leadership for the operation of the organization. The Executive Director is responsible for implementing programs and policies set by...
  • UTE LEGENDS
    These carefully researched stories reflect a deep and abiding understanding of Ute culture and history. These authintic, colorful legends also illustrate the Ute's close connections...
  • FUNDRAISING ASSOCIATE - HIGH COUNTRY NEWS
    High Country News seeks an organized and collaborative Fundraising Associate to drive donor discovery and the cultivation and acquisition of mid-level and recurring gifts. This...
  • MONTANA CONSERVATION ASSOCIATE
    GYC is hiring! Please see our careers page for more details greateryellowstone.org/careers
  • WYOMING AND NORTHERN UTAH DIRECTOR
    Western Watersheds Project seeks a Director to continue and expand WWP's campaign to protect and restore public lands and wildlife in Wyoming and northern Utah,...
  • 12 ACRES IN EAGLE, COLORADO!
    Tranquility & land are becoming more and more rare. This land is a haven for peace, where nature beckons & flourishes. Enjoy the mountain views...
  • SURGICAL SHARPENING SERVICE
    is a Denver-based mail order surgical instrument sharpening service established in 2009. Specialties include surgical scissors, dental elevators, trocar sets, and gynecological biopsy forceps.
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    California Coalition for Rural Housing (CCRH) seeks a strategic and visionary Executive Director: View all job details here- https://bit.ly/CCRHED
  • MONTANA BLUES
    Thrilling new crime novel by ex-HCN editor Ray Ring : A rural White horsewoman and an urban Black man battle White supremacists in a tough...
  • CANYONLANDS FIELD INSTITUTE
    Field seminars for adults in natural and human history of the northern Colorado Plateau, with lodge and base camp options. Small groups, guest experts.
  • COMING TO TUCSON?
    Popular vacation house, everything furnished. Two bedroom, one bath, large enclosed yards. Dog-friendly. Contact Lee at [email protected] or 520-791-9246.
  • WESTERN NATIVE SEED
    Native plant seeds for the Western US. Trees, shrubs, grasses, wildflowers and regional mixes. Call or email for free price list. 719-942-3935. [email protected] or visit...