An 'unfair, inflexible' bid to clean Montana's water

  • Cartoon of bathtub and directive to Montana miners

    Greg Siple
 

Francis Bardanouve is not the man you might expect to see leading one of the year's most contested environmental initiatives. A rancher from Harlem, Mont., he spent nearly 30 years in the state Legislature, where he was known as a conservative Democrat. But along with a businessman, a retired rancher and a Republican legislator, Bardanouve is spearheading Montana's Clean Water Initiative, which supporters call a common-sense method of keeping long-lived mining wastes such as arsenic and heavy metals out of water.

When the state Legislature relaxed water pollution requirements for Montana's booming mining industry in 1995, environmentalists struggled to find the best way to respond.

They decided that to beat the well-funded mining industry they needed a very narrow initiative - Initiative 122 addresses only one aspect of the law and affects only some mines. Then the activists rounded up an unlikely coalition to lead the campaign.

Their strategy wasn't foolproof. Opponents - mostly miners and mining companies - maintain the initiative singles out their industry with standards that are impossible to meet, and they have raised $1.8 million to fight it. Most spending goes to radio and television advertising, and it appears to be paying off.

There's no logical reason for this initiative, argues Jerome Anderson, a veteran lobbyist who runs Citizens for Common Sense Water Laws/Against Initiative 122, a group set up and funded primarily by five mining companies that have been cited for 56 water quality violations in Montana.

Popular Gov. Marc Racicot, a moderate Republican with an 80 percent approval rating, delivered another blow to supporters when he offered to sift through the arguments and deliver his opinion. He came down squarely on the side of the miners.

The initiative is "unfair, inflexible, imprecise and inconsistent," Racicot concluded in September, "and its benefits to public health, aquatic life, fisheries and water quality range from negligible to illusory."

I-122 would apply only to new hard-rock mines or expanding mines that use cyanide. It would have no effect on the state's talc, coal or gravel mines.

Like other polluters such as cities and factories, mines get water discharge permits from the state government. Current law allows "mixing zones," which are designated runs of groundwater or surface water. Within those zones, state standards can be exceeded. However, at the downstream edge of the zone, all standards must be met.

A mixing zone is the practical application of the old adage that "the solution to pollution is dilution." But I-122 would mean that discharges from some mines must meet water quality standards sooner - at the end of the pipe or the ditch that feeds into the mixing zone.

TV ads from the opposition have shown people drinking water downstream from a mine. The ads claim the initiative would cost the state up to 2,700 jobs and $400 million in state and local tax revenue.

"Their numbers are fantasy," said Gary Buchanan, co-chair of Montanans for Clean Water, the initiative's sponsor. His group maintains the mining industry is fighting the initiative because it is cheaper than complying with it.

"If they can buy the election for less than it costs to clean up the water, then that's what they'll do," said Stan Fraser of Helena, an organizer for Montanans for Clean Water, which has raised only about $200,000.

But early in October, Commissioner of Political Practices Ed Argenbright ruled that the anti-I-122 group had violated state law for a six-month period by using a misleading name. The name "Citizens for Common Sense Water Laws' was inaccurate, he said, since a majority of the group's members were in the mining industry. State law requires that groups backing or fighting initiatives use names that accurately reflect the economic interests of most contributors.

The group could be fined up to $1.6 million, three times the amount of money it spent on advertising in the six-month period ending in September. Since that time, however, people outside the industry have joined the group. This prompted Argenbright to rule the name legal, even though almost all of its money still comes from mining companies. The issue is unlikely to be resolved before the election. I-122 opponents have hired a lawyer and asked Argenbright to review his decision.

Push polls

During the first week of October, thousands of Montanans received dinnertime phone calls from a telemarketing group called Midwest Research. The callers said they were conducting a political poll, but instead of asking the demographic information required of a poll, they asked leading questions about I-122, putting a negative slant on the initiative.

Such "push polls" that plant suspicion or doubt in the mind of voters are condemned by reputable pollsters. Supporters of the initiative have blasted the opposition for using these polls, but Anderson says his group has nothing to do with them.

Legitimate polls, however, say I-122 is slipping. A Lee Newspapers poll in May found 67 percent of voters supported the measure, 17 percent opposed it and 16 percent were undecided. Since then, the advertising blitz kicked in, Racicot condemned the measure, and a late September poll found I-122 with a lead of only 46 percent to 42 percent, with 14 percent undecided.

The writer works in Livingston, Montana. Heather Abel contributed to this report.

Note: this article is part of a feature package on ballot initiatives that includes these other articles:

- Has big money doomed direct democracy?

- Polluted waters divide Oregon

- Will Idaho voters derail nuclear trains?

- Colorado voters decide fate of 3 million acres

- Western hunters debate ethics tooth and claw

Copyright © 1996 HCN and Scott McMillion

High Country News Classifieds
  • WATER PROJECT MANAGER, UPPER SAN PEDRO (ARIZONA)
    Based in Tucson or Sierra Vista, AZ., the Upper San Pedro Project Manager develops, manages, and advances freshwater conservation programs, plans, and methods focusing on...
  • CAMPAIGNS DIRECTOR
    Southeast Alaska Conservation is hiring. Visit https://www.seacc.org/about/hiring for info. 907-586-6942 [email protected]
  • FINANCE & GRANTS MANAGER
    The Blackfoot Challenge, located in Ovando, MT, seeks a self-motivated, detail-oriented individual to conduct bookkeeping, financial analysis and reporting, and grant oversight and management. Competitive...
  • WADE LAKE CABINS, CAMERON MT
    A once in a lifetime opportunity to live and run a business on the shore of one of the most beautiful lakes in SW Montana....
  • CONTRIBUTING EDITOR, BOOKS, CULTURE AND COMMENTARY (PART-TIME, CONTRACT)
    High Country News is seeking a Contributing Editor for Books, Culture and Commentary to assign and edit inquisitive, inspiring, and thought-provoking content for HCN in...
  • STATEWIDE COMMUNITY ORGANIZER
    ABOUT US Better Wyoming is a nonprofit, nonpartisan advocacy organization that educates, organizes, and mobilizes Wyoming residents on behalf of statewide change. Learn more at...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    TwispWorks is a 501(c)3 that promotes economic and cultural vitality in the mountainous Methow Valley, the eastern gateway to North Cascades National Park in Washington...
  • CLEAN ENERGY ADVOCATE OR DIRECTOR
    Location: Helena, Montana Type: Permanent, full time after 1-year probationary period. Reports to: Director of Policy and Legislative Affairs. Travel: Some overnight travel, both in-state...
  • PROFESSIONAL GIS SERVICES
    Custom Geospatial Solutions is available for all of your GIS needs. Affordable, flexible and accurate data visualization and analysis for any sized project.
  • DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
    Restore Hetch Hetchy, a 501 (c)(3) nonprofit organization, seeks experienced development professional to identify and engage individuals and institutions who are inspired to help underwrite...
  • PUBLIC LANDS COUNSEL
    The successful candidate will be the organization's lead counsel on public lands issues, including reviewing federal administrative actions and proposed policy and helping to shape...
  • HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR
    Solar Energy International (SEI) is a 501(c)3 non-profit education organization with a mission to provide industry-leading technical training and expertise in renewable energy to empower...
  • TRAINING MANAGER
    This is a full-time position based out of our Paonia office. This position is responsible for organizing all of Solar Energy International's renewable energy trainings....
  • RANCH HAND & HOUSING OPPORTUNITY IN DURANGO, CO
    Remodeled home with the opportunity to work off part of rent. Renter(s) must be available to help with lifting, irrigation & outdoor chores, 15-40 hrs...
  • GUIDE TO WESTERN NATIONAL MONUMENTS
    NEW BOOK showcases 70 national monuments across the western United States. Use "Guide10" for 10% off at cmcpress.org
  • RARE CHIRICAHUA RIPARIAN LAND FOR SALE
    40 acres: 110 miles from Tucson: native trees, grasses: birder's heaven::dark sky/ borders state lease & National forest/5100 ft/13-16 per annum rain
  • ENVIRONMENTAL GEOPHYSICS
    "More Data, Less Digging" Find groundwater and reduce excavation costs!
  • LUNATEC ODOR-FREE DISHCLOTHS
    are a must try. They stay odor-free, dry fast, are durable and don't require machine washing. Try today.
  • 10 ACRES OF NEW MEXICO HIGH DESERT
    10 Acres of undeveloped high desert land in central NM, about 45 minutes from downtown Albuquerque. Mixed cedar and piñon pine cover. Some dirt roadways...
  • OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
    We are a Santa Fe-based nonprofit that builds resilience on arid working lands. We foster ecological, economic, and social health through education, innovation, and collaboration....