Climate conflations


Thanks for your post-mortem on Initiative 1631 (“What Killed Washington’s Carbon Tax?HCN, 1/21/19). I think you missed one of the main reasons it failed. 1631’s design made it as much a “social justice” initiative as a climate initiative. Talk with some of those who backed Initiative 732, including Audubon. The Sierra Club and killed 732 because it didn’t meet their demands for carve-outs for the social justice movement. 1631 met those demands but was seen by most voters as a slush fund for special interests, not a climate solution. As long as the social justice folks conflate their wishes with meaningful climate action, I think we will be in gridlock.

David Engel 
Del Mar, California

High Country News Classifieds