« Return to this article

for people who care about the West

Indian law and injustice

The number of Indigenous lawyers is growing, after a long history of courts denying rights to American Indians.

 

Of the many cruelties that underpin the establishment of the American West, none is so pernicious as the denial of legal rights to American Indians. The rights of Indigenous peoples — to land, water and wildlife — are sometimes recognized by the courts, yet thoroughly undermined by a dominant American culture rife with ignorance and racism. Nevertheless, tribes have continued to assert their rights, and now hundreds of Indigenous lawyers are fighting legal battles for their nations.

What is commonly called “Indian law” developed among peoples at the mercy of a merciless system — beginning in 1831, when the Cherokee Nation went to court against the state of Georgia for the right to determine its own affairs. The struggle carried on through the 19th and 20th centuries, as the U.S. government executed a policy of extermination, isolation and brutal warfare against tribes from coast to coast. These tribal nations persisted, however, and Indian law developed, case by case.

What emerged when tribes had a fair shake was the legal doctrine that they are, in essence, sovereign nations with the right to self-determination. Although America is well into the 21st century, its legal and political systems consistently prove themselves inadequate for basic justice, even under this simple tenet. Legal scholar Matthew Fletcher, a member of the Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa and Chippewa Indians, has noted “an institutional bias against tribal interests” in the Supreme Court, despite 187 years of precedent. “Even when the federal government sides with tribal interests, the Court is unimpressed,” Fletcher wrote for the American Bar Association. “This institutional bias runs against the now-settled national policy favoring tribal self-determination.”

Brian Calvert, editor-in-chief.
Brooke Warren/High Country News

Despite such bias, Indigenous lawyers emerged to define Indian law in the 1970s, becoming mentors and educators for the next generation. Today, a growing cadre of young Indigenous lawyers is rising to meet legal challenges, old and new. As Assistant Editor Anna V. Smith reports in this issue’s cover story, the Yurok Tribe, in Northern California, now has one of its own citizens leading its most important legal battles — those over the Klamath River and the salmon it carries. As drought intensifies and non-Native farmers become increasingly desperate for irrigation, the stakes on the river are high. We will see in coming months and years whether the courts can deliver fair judgment on these and other tribal issues.

Either way, the Yurok general counsel, Amy Cordalis, continues to find solid legal footing for her tribe, working to change the system from within. Her story is one among many, as young Indigenous professionals contribute great things to their tribes and to the United States. All of them should be recognized as positive role models — not only for their communities, but for everyone.