Should courts defer to the expertise of agencies?

Our new Supreme Court justice doesn’t think so.

 

Just last year, when he was a federal circuit court judge in Denver, the Supreme Court’s new justice, Neil Gorsuch, did something judges rarely do. Gorsuch wrote the main opinion, explaining why he and two other judges on the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the Obama administration in Gutierrez-Brizuela v. Lynch, an immigration case. But then he added an even longer analysis — just from himself — sharply criticizing a judicial precedent that federal agencies and environmental groups have relied on for decades to protect people, public lands and rare species. Known as the Chevron doctrine, it stems from a 1984 Supreme Court ruling.

Under Chevron, courts have given agencies wide leeway to interpret ambiguous statutes. Gorsuch wrote that the doctrine has allowed “executive bureaucracies to swallow huge amounts of core judicial and legislative power and concentrate federal power in a way that seems more than a little difficult to square with the Constitution.”

Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. and fellow justices watch as Neil Gorsuch signs the Constitutional Oath on April 10.
Franz Jantzen/Public Information Office Supreme Court of the U.S. via AP

Chevron has been pivotal in upholding key environmental regulations, from protecting habitat for endangered species to regulating pollution. Gorsuch’s aversion to it worries some Western legal experts, who fear that the nation’s highest court will no longer permit federal agencies to create safeguards for the West’s lands, waters, air and wildlife that are not explicitly required by Congress. “The statutory mandate of land-management agencies like the Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management and Park Service is old and creaky,” said Fred Cheever, a professor of natural resources and environmental law at the University of Denver Law School. “The combination of lack of deference and antiquated laws creates a potential conflict that may dramatically impact the West.”

And because of Gorsuch’s Western roots, Cheever says, other justices may follow his lead on regional issues as they followed former Western members of the court, such as Justice Sandra Day O’Connor. While the Denver-born Gorsuch, who served on the 10th Circuit since 2006, may have more insight into conflicts over public lands than most Eastern judges, other experts scoff at Gorsuch’s Western credentials. Gorsuch has spent much of his life in Washington, D.C., moving there as a teenager in the early 1980s, when his mother, Anne Gorsuch Burford, headed President Ronald Reagan’s Environmental Protection Agency. He attended high school, college and law school on the East Coast and spent his early legal career in the nation’s capital.

Gorsuch joins the Supreme Court at a time when there is growing criticism of Chevron. Though the majority of the court relied on Chevron and deferred to the Federal Communications Commission in the 2013 case City of Arlington v. FCC, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote a strongly worded dissent, warning of “the danger posed by the growing power of the administrative state.” In a 2015 case upholding the Affordable Care Act, Roberts expressly stated that the court wasn’t deferring to the agency under Chevron, as a lower court had, but instead was resolving the ambiguity in the statute itself. Meanwhile, congressional Republicans are trying to get rid of it altogether. The House passed a law in January that would instruct courts not to defer to agencies’ interpretations of ambiguous laws. The Senate has yet to act.

Environmental groups likely would cite Chevron in defending the Obama administration’s environmental rules, including the EPA’s Clean Water and Clean Power Plants rules and the BLM’s methane and hydraulic fracturing rules. But those cases may not make it to the Supreme Court; President Donald Trump already is trying to rollback many of these regulations. 

Chevron deference benefits whatever administration is in power — and consequently Gorsuch’s resistance to it could backfire on Republicans. In the original 1984 case, Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council Inc., the Supreme Court upheld an EPA air pollution rule — crafted while Gorsuch’s mother headed the agency — that benefitted industry, allowing more air pollution. That’s just the kind of regulation the Trump administration could be expected to write. But if the court, under Gorsuch’s influence, becomes increasingly reluctant to defer to agencies, that could make it harder for Trump’s team to write rules that benefit industry, or even to eliminate existing environmental and safety regulations. When those decisions are challenged in court, the Trump administration may be hampered by having to use other legal arguments instead of simply relying on Chevron deference. “Those who dislike Trump’s policies may find a friend in Gorsuch’s views on Chevron,” said Donald J. Kochan, law professor at
Chapman University, in Orange, California.

Gorsuch is only 49 and could be on the court for decades. How might his presence there determine what happens when future administrations try to expand protections for the West’s public lands and environment? That answer depends on unpredictable factors, including whether Trump has by then appointed additional justices who share Gorsuch’s antipathy for Chevron. What is clear is that Gorsuch will be pushing the court to reassert its role in interpreting statues — and will block agencies that try to regulate based on their own interpretations.

Correspondent Elizabeth Shogren writes HCN’s DC Dispatches from Washington.

Another version of this story was published in our print magazine on May 1, 2017.

High Country News Classifieds
  • OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
    We are a Santa Fe-based nonprofit that builds resilience on arid working lands. We foster ecological, economic, and social health through education, innovation, and collaboration....
  • COMMUNITY ORGANIZER
    Come work alongside everyday Montanans to project our clean air, water, and build thriving communities! Competitive salary, health insurance, pension, generous vacation time and sabbatical....
  • CAMPAIGN MANAGER
    Oregon Natural Desert Association (ONDA), a nonprofit conservation organization dedicated to protecting, defending and restoring Oregon's high desert, seeks a Campaign Manager to works as...
  • HECHO DEPUTY DIRECTOR
    Hispanics Enjoying Camping, Hunting, and the Outdoors (HECHO) was created in 2013 to help fulfill our duty to conserve and protect our public lands for...
  • REGIONAL REPRESENTATIVE, COLUMBIA CASCADES
    The Regional Representative serves as PCTA's primary staff on the ground along the trail working closely with staff, volunteers, and nonprofit and agency partners. This...
  • FINANCE AND OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
    The Montana Land Reliance (MLR) seeks a full-time Finance and Operations Director to manage the internal functions of MLR and its nonprofit affiliates. Key areas...
  • DIRECTOR OF CONSERVATION
    The Nature Conservancy is recruiting for a Director of Conservation. Provides strategic leadership and support for all of the Conservancy's conservation work in Arizona. The...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    The Amargosa Conservancy (AC), a conservation nonprofit dedicated to standing up for water and biodiversity in the Death Valley region, seeks an executive director to...
  • BIG BASIN SENIOR PROJECT PLANNER - CLIMATE ADAPTATION & RESILIENCE
    Parks California Big Basin Senior Project Planner - Climate Adaptation & Resilience ORGANIZATION BACKGROUND Parks California is a new organization working to ensure that our...
  • CUSTOMER SERVICE ASSISTANT - (PART-TIME)
    High Country News, an award-winning media organization covering the communities and environment of the Western United States, seeks a part-time Customer Service Assistant, based at...
  • SCIENCE PROJECT MANAGER
    About Long Live the Kings (LLTK) Our mission is to restore wild salmon and steelhead and support sustainable fishing in the Pacific Northwest. Since 1986,...
  • HUMAN RESOURCES GENERALIST
    Honor the Earth is an affirmative action/equal opportunity employer and does not discriminate based on identity. Indigenous people, people of color, Two-Spirit or LGBTQA+ people,...
  • DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
    Colorado Trout Unlimited seeks an individual with successful development experience, strong interpersonal skills, and a deep commitment to coldwater conservation to serve as the organization's...
  • NEW BOOK BY AWARD-WINNING WILDLIFE BIOLOGIST, BRUCE SMITH
    In a perilous place at the roof of the world, an orphaned mountain goat is rescued from certain death by a mysterious raven.This middle-grade novel,...
  • DESCHUTES LAND TRUST VOLUNTEER PROGRAM MANAGER
    The Deschutes Land Trust is seeking an experienced Volunteer Program Manager to join its dedicated team! Deschutes Land Trust conserves and cares for the lands...
  • PROGRAM DIRECTOR
    Now hiring a full-time, remote Program Director for the Society for Wilderness Stewardship! Come help us promote excellence in the professional practice of wilderness stewardship,...
  • WYOMING COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIPS COORDINATOR
    The Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership is seeking Coordinator to implement public education and advocacy campaigns in the Cowboy State to unite and amplify hunter, angler,...
  • MOUNTAIN LOTS FOR SALE
    Multiple lots in gated community only 5 miles from Great Sand Dunes National Park. Seasonal flowing streams. Year round road maintenance.
  • RURAL ACREAGE OUTSIDE SILVER CITY, NM
    Country living just minutes from town! 20 acres with great views makes a perfect spot for your custom home. Nice oaks and juniper. Cassie Carver,...
  • A FIVE STAR FOREST SETTING WITH SECLUSION AND SEPARATENESS
    This home is for a discerning buyer in search of a forest setting of premier seclusion & separateness. Surrounded on all sides by USFS land...