Saving the ranch

Can private conservation stave off ski-town sprawl?

  • Routt County and Steamboat Springs, Colo.

    Diane Sylvain
  • John and Criss Fetcher with son Jay and Gael Fetcher at their ranch

    Kent Meireis
  • Development stretches into farmland around Steamboat Springs, Colo.

    Rick Keister
  • Marty Zeller

    Florence Williams
 

STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Colo. - Drive away from the ski area on County Road 29, and you will find yourself shaded by cottonwood trees growing along the rushing Elk River. After a few miles the narrow gorge opens out to a view that may be unique so close to a ski area in the West.

As far as you can see - five miles across the valley and its rolling uplands - verdant hayfields spread beneath hills of gambel oak, aspen and spruce. A few ranch buildings dot the landscape.

But there are no subdivisions, no vacation homes. If the ranchers of the upper Elk River Valley have their way, there won't be. Ever.

"At night you drive around the corner at the schoolhouse, and you look up here and you see one light," says Jay Fetcher, sitting on his porch and looking south across his parents' 1,300-acre ranch. "If we can maintain or eliminate that one light 20 years from now, that would be pretty nice. And it's possible."

How? With conservation easements, which allow ranchers to sell the right to develop their land. His efforts have won the affable and articulate Fetcher a "Smart Growth" award from Colorado Governor Roy Romer, and have mobilized some local ranchers and politicians against the wave of development emanating from one of the state's busiest ski resorts.

Yet success is far from assured. Though the valley's ranchers recently signed an unusual voluntary compact which could protect the valley from developers who want to carve the land into ranchettes, little land is protected yet. And some ranchers are balking at the specifics of the plan as they, like other ranchers in Routt County, struggle with the idea that preserving their way of life means forgoing some property rights.

A ski resort is born

Ranchers first settled the Elk River Valley in 1881. In 1949, John and Criss Fetcher arrived from Philadelphia and bought their property. When John teamed up with three partners in the 1950s to build ski runs on what is now the Steamboat Springs ski area, he started an avalanche of growth that ended in a sobering irony for the Fetcher family. The growth spawned by the resort they began now threatens the very ranching culture they want to preserve (see story page 10).

With homegrown Olympian Billy Kidd, the dashing, cowboy-hatted downhiller, as its poster boy, the Steamboat Ski and Resort Corp. has become a regional economic force. Today the company counts more than a million skier days annually. Housing prices in Steamboat Springs, where half of Routt County's 14,000 residents live, are heading the way of Vail and Aspen. Average three-bedroom homes sell for well over $200,000.

Still, Routt County maintains a healthy ranching community, with 50 full-time ranchers and 16,000 head of cattle. Ranch-related activities comprise a small but solid 6 percent of the local economy, and residents and tourists alike seem committed to maintaining them. Nine out of 10 people surveyed in 1993 said they believe that ranch meadows and grasslands with grazing cows and horses enhance their lives.

The seeds of private land conservation were sown in the early days of a real estate boom which started in the late 1970s. Throughout the 1980s and early 1990s, Steve Stranahan, an heir to the Champion sparkplug fortune, bought 4,000 acres in the Elk River Valley to protect his 500-acre Home Ranch - now one of the most luxurious and spectacular dude ranches in the nation.

"Once we built the ranch," says his partner, Ken Jones, "we realized a lot of the quality of the ranch had to do with the aesthetics of what people didn't see here: lots of homes."

But Stranahan couldn't afford to buy the valley floor's remaining 8,000 acres. He approached the Fetchers with an idea they had talked about a decade earlier - limiting land use with conservation easements. Then he introduced the family to Marty Zeller, president of Denver-based Conservation Partners Inc., one of the most experienced conservation planners in the West.

Giving up condos for cows

During a year of discussions facilitated by Zeller, landowners quickly discovered a strong common bond: Everyone wanted the valley to remain essentially unchanged.

The details of achieving their goal fell to Washington, D.C.-based American Farmland Trust, which introduced the ranchers to the two central truths of conservation easements: Donating an easement strips land of its development potential and keeps it in agriculture. But it also strips it of a good deal of its market value (see story page 13).

This is a frightening prospect to ranchers, who customarily see their property as their retirement fund.

If conservation easements sound like they have overtones of elitism, they do. If they appear to neuter the rugged individualism of the Western rancher, they do. But their benefits extend beyond saving scenery and lifestyles. In the Fetchers' case, conservation easements would cut the estate taxes owed by Jay and his three siblings upon their parents death from $325,000 to zero. This is because the appraised value of the ranch would drop from $2.1 million to $1.07 million.

With the Fetchers leading the way, the Elk River ranchers produced the "Upper Elk Valley Compact." The non-binding, one-page vision statement proposes "protective development" to preserve the valley's ranching heritage.

It encourages landowners to reserve a few low-impact building sites for future sales, and to place the rest of their property under conservation easements. The few building sites - perhaps 50 in the whole valley - will be more valuable than ranchettes because the overall landscape will stay intact. If a rancher wants to sell, the compact encourages him or her to find like-minded buyers. The document also calls for new, affordable housing for ranch employees near the Clark Store, in the center of the valley.

All parties agree that the voluntary nature of the compact is critical. But at this point, common ground is more prevalent than protected ground.

The Fetchers have donated an easement on their property, and Steve Stranahan has done the same on the 900-acre Whitmer Ranch, but landowners who once indicated they would give easements are hesitating. Even Stranahan is holding back on The Home Ranch and the 2,000-acre Murphy-Larson Ranch.

Fetcher estimates easements are likely on about 5,200 acres of land - roughly half the valley floor. He's not sure about another 2,800.

Owners of the 4,000-acre Chew Ranch at the head of the valley say they simply can't afford to donate easements.

"There's an initial excitement about these things," says Zeller, "and then (comes) the reality of the tough issues each of these families has to address."

Fetcher acknowledges conservation easements are a tough pill for many ranchers to swallow. "The people most interested in conservation easements are deep-pocketed people from outside the state," he admits. "There is a stigma there."

Still, Fetcher insists his fellow ranchers need to consider what they want the land to look like in the future and whether they want to give their kids a chance to continue ranching. "We've got to realize that one of our property rights is the right to give some of them up," he says.

As for rich outsiders, says Fetcher, they will inevitably be players around resorts, "so you might as well find those with good intentions who want to save the land."

The county steps in

Following on the heels of the Elk River Valley's work, Routt County undertook a land-use planning effort for the entire county. The plan, yet to be fully adopted, recognizes the same hard truth the Elk River ranchers are wrestling with: The bottom-line in land preservation is money.

If the public wants open space preserved, it has to compete for it on the market, often against developers. The most effective way to do that - a technique that a few, more urban areas like Boulder County, Colo., have begun to use - is to purchase development rights.

The county's draft land-use plan estimates Routt County needs to raise $1.25 million to $1.5 million annually for 10 or 20 years to have a shot at meaningful preservation of open space through purchased development rights. Whereas open land in south Routt County sells for $700 an acre, land threatened by development near Steamboat Springs goes for $10,000 an acre and up. The development rights are the difference between the appraised value at the current maximum zoning and the appraised value as agricultural land.

To an outsider, the idea that the public should subsidize a handful of ranchers just to keep them on the land might seem ridiculous. Why should the public spend money protecting land they can look at - but not touch?

"I really think the public looks at ag as their recreation and open space," says Jay Fetcher. "We need to be compensated for that."

Why shouldn't the county simply buy the land outright?

For starters, says Zeller, maintaining land is expensive. Ranchers will often do a better job of keeping down the weeds and maintaining the property than a public agency. Also, buying development rights can often be much cheaper than buying title to the land, he says.

Paying a rancher a handsome sum of money for his development rights can also have a ripple effect in the local economy, says Zeller.

"Most ranchers don't take their (development rights) money and run to Florida," he says. "They plow it back into their operation; they pay off debt, buy new equipment or build a barn. This benefits the local feed store owner, the veterinarian, the equipment dealer. If you lose that critical mass of ranchers, these other guys will be gone too."

But more important, says Zeller, many people in rural counties in the West, who already have vast tracts of public land in their back yards, are adamant about maintaining private lands in private hands.

"Keeping a working landscape says something about your community and its commitment to quality of life," Zeller says.

Whether the public is willing to pay to preserve land remains to be seen. The question will appear on the local ballot in the fall of 1996. Possible funding sources include property or sales taxes, a tax on land sales profits, and a development impact fee.

In the meantime, both the city of Steamboat Springs and Routt County have put up $125,000 for a pilot project to buy development rights. Zeller says he hopes the state will match the $250,000 with money from lottery proceeds.

Zeller says $500,000 could buy development rights from two ranchers and let ranchers and other residents "give it the smell test." If the aroma is pleasant, Zeller hopes more funding will follow.

"If we could buy development rights for 15 ranches in Routt County, that would really send a message," he says. "It would change people's perception that development is inevitable."

The county's plan goes beyond buying development rights to protect open space. Routt County commissioners approved in June a "land preservation subdivision" law to fight ranchettes. If a landowner agrees to cluster development, meet special design criteria and keep the balance of the property in open space, he or she will be allowed to build one extra house per 100 acres.

Under the new law, the city of Steamboat Springs recently acquired two parcels of land totaling 115 acres that will remain undeveloped forever.

Avoiding Aspen

Routt County seems to have all the tools needed to save its ranching community: some forward-thinking ranchers, planners, a deeply concerned and affluent public, and the support of the major economic force in the area, the ski resort.

But will these be enough to prevent it from becoming another highly developed Aspen or Vail? Routt County planner Ellen Crain says a number of Californians have recently moved to the area; Aspen refugees have also been poking around.

"It becomes a less desirable place if all you have is the billionaires and the people who don't speak English in the kitchen," says Crain. "If you've got to import the cowboys for the rodeo every Friday and Saturday night, you've lost something."

In the Elk River Valley, ranching may go on, but despite the desire to avoid change, change will come. The homes to be built among the hayfields will be expensive and exclusive, which bothers Jay Fetcher. Some of the ranchers themselves may turn out to be tenants, working their cows on a costly vacation property held by an absentee owner. Elsewhere in Routt County, some lands will be preserved even as others are subdivided, creating a patchwork where there now is open space.

It won't be perfect, and it can't be what it is now. But it will be less of what it might have been, because some people tried to look ahead and agree on where to go.

"People ask me why I didn't sell out and move to Nebraska," says Jay Fetcher, as a sandhill crane stalks slowly across a distant field. "I don't think you can run away from it."

Hal Clifford writes from Aspen, Colorado.

The following sidebar articles accompany this feature story:

- Rancher John Fetcher recalls his years of ranching in the Elk River Valley

- Rancher's new cash crop will be scenery

- Conservation group ropes in a working ranch

- Trust in the Land

High Country News Classifieds
  • PUBLIC LANDS PROGRAM MANAGER
    Conserve Southwest Utah is seeking a candidate with excellent communication skills and a commitment to environmental conservation for the position of Public Lands Program Manager....
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    The Western Slope Conservation Center in Paonia, CO, seeks a dynamic leader who is mission-driven, hardworking, and a creative problem-solver. WSCC is committed to creating...
  • PLANNED GIVING OFFICER
    National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA), the nation's oldest and largest national parks nonprofit advocacy organization seeks a Planned Giving Officer. Do you find energy in...
  • NORTHERN NEW MEXICO PROJECT MANAGER
    Seeking qualified Northern New Mexico Project Manager to provide expertise, leadership and support to the organization by planning, cultivating, implementing and managing land conservation activities,...
  • REGIONAL TRAIL STEWARDSHIP COORDINATOR
    Are you passionate about connecting people to the outdoors? The Pacific Crest Trail Association (PCTA) is looking for someone with trail maintenance and volunteer engagement...
  • TRAIL CREW MEMBER
    Position Title: Trail Crew Member Position Type: 6 month seasonal position, April 17-October 15, 2023 Location: Field-based; The RFOV office is in Carbondale, CO, and...
  • CEO BUFFALO NATIONS GRASSLANDS ALLIANCE
    Chief Executive Officer, Remote Exempt position for Buffalo Nations Grasslands Alliance is responsible for the planning and organization of BNGA's day-to-day operations
  • IDAHO DIRECTOR - WESTERN WATERSHEDS PROJECT
    Western Watersheds Project seeks an Idaho Director to continue and expand upon WWP's campaign to protect and restore public lands and wildlife in Idaho, with...
  • DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT, NA'AH ILLAHEE FUND
    Na'ah Illahee Fund (NIF) is seeking a highly qualified Development Director to join our team in supporting and furthering our mission. This position will create...
  • DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS, NA'AH ILLAHEE FUND
    Na'ah Illahee Fund (NIF) is seeking a highly qualified Operations Director to join our team. This position will provide critical organizational and systems support to...
  • DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
    Grand Staircase Escalante Partners (GSEP) is seeking a leader to join our dynamic team in the long-term protection of Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument (GSENM). We...
  • GRASSLAND RESEARCH COORDINATOR
    The Grassland Research Coordinator is a cooperative position with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service that performs and participates in and coordinates data collection for...
  • HYDROELECTRIC PLANT
    1.3 MW FERC licensed hydroelectric station near Taylorsville CA. Property is 184 deeded acres surrounded by National Forrest.
  • "PROFILES IN COURAGE: STANDING AGAINST THE WYOMING WIND"
    13 stories of extraordinary courage including HCN founder Tom Bell, PRBRC director Lynn Dickey, Liz Cheney, People of Heart Mountain, the Wind River Indian Reservation...
  • GRANT WRITER
    JOB DESCRIPTION: This Work involves the responsibility of conducting research in the procurement of Federal, State, County, and private grant funding. Additional responsibilities include identifying...
  • ASPIRE COLORADO SUSTAINABLE BODY AND HOME CARE PRODUCTS
    Go Bulk! Go Natural! Our products are better for you and better for the environment. Say no to single-use plastic. Made in U.S.A., by a...
  • CANYONLANDS FIELD INSTITUTE
    Field seminars for adults in the natural and human history of the Colorado Plateau, with lodge and base camp options. Small groups, guest experts.
  • ATTORNEY AD
    Criminal Defense, Code Enforcement, Water Rights, Mental Health Defense, Resentencing.
  • LUNATEC HYDRATION SPRAY BOTTLE
    A must for campers and outdoor enthusiasts. Cools, cleans and hydrates with mist, stream and shower patterns. Hundreds of uses.
  • LUNATEC ODOR-FREE DISHCLOTHS
    are a must try. They stay odor-free, dry fast, are durable and don't require machine washing. Try today.