Montana court defends law defying Citizens United

  • An editorial cartoon depicting the average Montana citizen dwarfed by King Copper was printed in the Montana Lookout newspaper in 1910.

    Carole Mackin
  • Montana Supreme Court Justices James Nelson, left, and Brian Morris listen to Montana Attorney General Steve Bullock last September in Helena. The court was hearing arguments over the state's 1912 Corrupt Practices Act. On Dec. 30, it ruled the ban on corporate political spending should remain in place.

    AP Photo/Matt Gouras
 

Judge William Clancy, who presided over a state district court in Butte, Mont., was a heavy drinker who often dozed off during lawyers' arguments; when awake, he showered a spittoon with tobacco juice gobs. Another Butte judge, Edward Harney, cheated on his wife with an employee of a mining company that was a defendant in his courtroom. He ruled for his lover's company, but the Montana Supreme Court eventually ordered a new trial, denouncing Harney's conduct as "a carnival of drunkenness and debauchery."

Both judges were elected with the help of a powerful mining baron's political machine. In return, in hundreds of lawsuits, they allowed him to hijack a fortune in ore from other people's mines.

All this occurred in the early 1900s, and it helped inspire Montana voters to pass a 1912 ballot initiative, the Corrupt Practices Act, which prohibits corporate expenditures on state political campaigns. Yet the issue came up again Dec. 30, when the Montana Supreme Court ruled on a lawsuit challenging the 1912 law. A right-wing advocacy group, Western Tradition Partnership (now called American Tradition Partnership), argued that the law should be junked because of the U.S. Supreme Court's sweeping 2010 decision in the Citizens United case, which held that corporations have a First Amendment right to make unlimited campaign contributions.

Twenty-four other states have repealed or revamped their campaign finance laws to comply with Citizens United, but the Montana Supreme Court, in a 5-2 decision, stood firm, finding that Montana's unique history of corruption in the era of the Copper Kings justifies the state's exemption from its reach. According to the Montana court, Citizens United doesn't make all prohibitions of corporate campaign contributions unconstitutional, and the state's chronic "issues of corporate influence, sparse population, dependence upon agriculture and extractive resource development ... and low campaign costs make Montana especially vulnerable to continued efforts of corporate control to the detriment of democracy and the republican form of government."

The Montana Supreme Court ruling emphasized the need to protect the integrity of the state's judicial elections. The majority opinion, written by Chief Justice Mike McGrath, said judicial elections "would be particularly vulnerable to large levels of independent spending ... (and) litigants appearing before a judge elected after a large expenditure of corporate funds could legitimately question whether their due process rights were adversely impacted." A dissenting opinion by Justice James Nelson -- who attacked the reasoning behind Citizens United but said he was "duty-bound" to apply it in Montana -- warned that thanks to the U.S. Supreme Court, "judicial elections will become little better than the corporate wars that elections for partisan officers have already become."

High Country News Classifieds
  • ACTING INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS DESK EDITOR
    High Country News is seeking an Acting Indigenous Affairs Editor to oversee the work of our award-winning Indigenous Affairs Desk while our editor is on...
  • GRANTS PROGRAM DIRECTOR
    The Cinnabar Foundation seeks an enthusiastic, team-oriented and knowledgeable Grants Program Director to work from their home in Montana. Established in 1983, the Cinnabar Foundation...
  • ARTEMIS PROGRAM MANAGER
    The Artemis Program Manager will work with National Wildlife Federation sporting and public lands staff to change this dynamic, continue to build upon our successful...
  • ALASKA SEA KAYAK BUSINESS FOR SALE
    Well-known and successful sea kayak, raft, hike, camp guiding & water taxi service. Sale includes everything needed to run the business, including office & gear...
  • MEMBERSHIP AND EVENTS PROGRAM COORDINATOR
    Great Old Broads for Wilderness seeks a detail-oriented and enthusiastic Membership and Events Coordinator to join our small, but mighty-fun team to oversee our membership...
  • PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT FACILITATOR
    ABOUT THE HIGH DESERT MUSEUM Since opening in 1982, HIGH DESERT MUSEUM has brought together wildlife, culture, art and natural resources to promote an understanding...
  • LAND STEWARD, ARAVAIPA
    Steward will live on-site in housing provided by TNC and maintains preserve areas frequented by the visiting public and performs land management activities. The Land...
  • DEVELOPMENT WRITER
    Who We Are: The Nature Conservancy's mission is to protect the lands and waters upon which all life depends. As a science-based organization, we create...
  • CONNECTIVITY SCIENCE COORDINATOR
    Position type: Full time, exempt Location: Bozeman preferred; remote negotiable Compensation: $48,000 - $52,000 Benefits: Major medical insurance, up to 5% match on a 401k,...
  • EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT
    ArenaLife is looking for an Executive Assistant who wants to work in a fast-paced, exciting, and growing organization. We are looking for someone to support...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    The Mountain Lion Foundation is seeking an Executive Director. Please see our website for further information - mountainlion.org/job-openings
  • WASHINGTON DC REPRESENTATIVE
    Position Status: Full-time, exempt Location: Washington, DC Position Reports to: Program Director The Western Organization of Resource Councils (WORC) is seeking a Washington, DC Representative...
  • REGIONAL CAMPAIGN ORGANIZER
    Position Title: Regional Campaign Organizers (2 positions) Position Status: Full-time, exempt Location: Preferred Billings, MT; remote location within WORC's region (in or near Grand Junction...
  • STAFF ATTORNEY
    Western Watersheds Project seeks a Tenth Circuit Staff Attorney to bring litigation in the interests of protecting and restoring western watersheds and wildlife, particularly focused...
  • DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT
    Position Title: Director of Development Status: Full-Time/Exempt Reports to: Executive Director Location: Remote (California preferred) About the Native American Land Conservancy As one of the...
  • DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
    Driggs, ID based non-profit. Full time. Full job description available at tvtap.org. Submit cover letter and resume to [email protected]
  • ENVIRONMENTAL AND CONSTRUCTION GEOPHYSICS
    - We find groundwater, buried debris and assist with new construction projects for a fraction of drilling costs.
  • SPRING MOUNTAINS SOLAR OFF GRID MOUNTAIN HOME
    Located 50 miles northwest of Las Vegas, Nevada in the pine forest of Lee Canyon at 8000 feet elevation. One of a kind property surrounded...
  • MAJOR GIFTS MANAGER - MOUNTAIN WEST, THE CONSERVATION FUND
    Cultivate, solicit and steward a portfolio of 75-125 donors.
  • NATURE'S BEST IN ARAVAIPA CANYON
    10 acre private oasis in one of Arizona's beautiful canyons. Fully furnished, 2123 sq ft architectural custom-built contemporary home with spectacular views and many extras....