You are here: home   Issues   Are you a local?   On Science and dogma
Topic: Politics & Policy     Department: Letters

On Science and dogma

Document Actions

As a former resident of Colorado's Front Range, I found Emily Guerin's fire-science story, about forest ecologists' disagreement about whether all dry Western forests are to be considered overly-dense and in need of restoration, to be fascinating ("Fire fights," HCN, 9/17/12).  While the article interprets the "controversy" as a lack of consensus among forest ecologists, it clearly reveals several of the researchers it mentions as more simply taking issue with those who challenge the dogma of the "Southwest model."

Aiming to disprove hypotheses – and therefore to challenge conventional dogma - is at the heart of the scientific method, and those who operate in this manner should be applauded rather than alienated. Criticism about flaws in study design or interpretations are always important and relevant; concerns that a study questioning conventional wisdom could undermine policy or management efforts are not. At the very least, the Williams-Baker study should be lauded as one that stimulates critical questions about what we think we know about Western forest systems, not as an "anchor dragging us backwards" as scientist Peter Brown called it.

Dan Kashian
Detroit, Michigan

Email Newsletter

The West in your Inbox

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Follow our RSS feeds!
  1. Rancher vs BLM: a 20-year standoff ends with tense roundup |
  2. Photos of a standoff | Armed militia members join a Nevada rancher to pro...
  3. After the standoff, what's next for Bundy and BLM? |
  4. The energy haves and have-nots | Will rooftop solar owners get off the grid — and...
  5. Why homes are lost to wildfire | This Forest Service expert says it's as much a soc...
  1. Why homes are lost to wildfire | This Forest Service expert says it's as much a soc...
  2. Locals resist a Bakkenization of the Beartooths | South-central Montanans oppose new drilling, forew...
  3. Photos of a standoff | Armed militia members join a Nevada rancher to pro...
  4. The energy haves and have-nots | Will rooftop solar owners get off the grid — and...
  5. Will the Colorado River reach the Gulf of California once more? | Photographs of last month's historic water pulses....
HCN Classifieds
Subscriber Alert
 
© 2014 High Country News, all rights reserved. | privacy policy | terms of use | powered by Plone