State judges get political

Special-interest money pours into hotly contested judge campaigns

  • Judge-o-mat cartoon

    Matt Wuerker
 

With the help of real estate agents, builders, loggers and other industry groups, Cindy Younkin has raised more than $160,000 for her Montana campaign.

Meanwhile, in Washington, Jim Johnson, who is also backed by builders and property-rights advocates, has raised more than $200,000. And in Nevada, anti-tax crusader John Mason has amassed a war chest of more than $700,000.

Along with their impressive dollar totals, these candidates have a few other things in common: They’re all political conservatives, and they’re campaigning for seats on their states’ supreme courts.

In the West, state judgeships are elected offices. Some states select judges in popular elections; in others, they are appointed by governors or special commissions, but required to run for re-election if they seek subsequent terms. Until recently, the chief influence in these elections has been the liberal trial lawyers who have applied campaign money, endorsements and legwork to elect judges who would be sympathetic to lawsuits against corporations. But since 2000, "business interests have made very strategic efforts to influence judicial elections," says John Echeverria, head of the Environmental Law and Policy Institute at Georgetown University.

In the increasing melee, political parties and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, which represents 3 million business members, are pouring money into targeted races. In the 2002 elections, business interests spent more than $8 million on state supreme court races, lawyers spent more than $10 million, and the political parties spent nearly $3 million, according to the Washington, D.C.-based watchdog group Justice at Stake. It’s a trend that alarms many observers.

Whether it’s pressure from liberals or conservatives, "The real threat is to the impartiality of the courts," says Bert Brandenburg, acting director of Justice at Stake. "If judges have to look over their shoulder at special interests, and worry about how they’ll be treated (on election day)," they’ll be more likely to be influenced when deciding court cases.

Reformers want limits on judicial campaign spending, or an entire shift to merit-based appointments for judgeships. But reform looks unlikely, and a 2002 U.S. Supreme Court ruling has encouraged even more politicking. Citing the right to free speech, the highest court tossed out many states’ prohibitions on judicial candidates taking stands on issues. So candidates are speaking out, and TV ads are getting as ugly as "barroom brawls," Brandenberg says.

This year, Younkin’s campaign in Montana is attracting the most attention from environmentalists. She’s trying to oust Justice Jim Nelson, a former Democratic county attorney who was appointed to the Montana Supreme Court by a Republican governor 11 years ago. Nelson has repeatedly been in a majority of the court’s seven justices, upholding the state’s environmental laws and shaking up traditions such as open range. In particular, he’s defended Montana’s unique constitutional guarantee of a "clean and healthful environment."

In a 2002 case about fish poaching, Nelson wrote: "I can only hope the State ... enforces this constitutional imperative the next time some individual or business poisons Montana’s ground, water and air with toxic wastes and pollutants and when laws and administrative rules are enacted which weaken the protections ..."

Younkin, a Republican legislator, has supported some environmental measures, but she has earned low ratings overall from the nonprofit Montana Conservation Voters. She led an effort that severely limited the Montana Environmental Policy Act’s analysis of impacts of industrial developments. She’s "made a career taking the lead in attacking cornerstone environmental laws," says Theresa Keaveny, director of Montana Conservation Voters.

Younkin charges that the Montana Supreme Court has been taken over by the "radical left." She points to a study by University of Montana law professor Jeffery Renz, which says Montana Supreme Court justices since 1970 have been "the most active in Montana’s history," overturning a high number of previous court rulings. Asked about the fact that so many industry groups back her, Younkin says, "They don’t think they’re getting a fair shake out of the Supreme Court." And she promises she’ll be impartial if she’s elected to the court.

Nelson says he’s "proud of protecting the constitutional rights that Montanans have (since 1972) — at least 17 civil rights and liberties that are not (specifically) protected under the U.S. Constitution." In a state that leans Republican, Younkin has an edge. But as of Sept. 10, Nelson was ahead in dollars — he’d raised about $188,000, largely from trial lawyers and conservationists. It’s expected that significant "soft money" from outside the state will make its way to the race in the homestretch.

The author is editor in the field for High Country News.

CONTACTS:

Justice at Stake Washington, D.C 202-588-9700 http://justiceatstake.org/

U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform in Washington, D.C., 202-463-5724

High Country News Classifieds
  • TROUT UNLIMITED NORTH IDAHO FIELD COORDINATOR
    The field coordinator will work with TU members, other fishing organizations, community leaders, businesses and elected officials to build support for actions necessary to recover...
  • STEWARDSHIP COORDINATOR
    New Mexico Land Conservancy (Santa Fe, NM), Stewardship Coordinator - Seeking highly motivated individual with excellent interpersonal skills to coordinate stewardship activities and support conservation...
  • 40-ACRE LAMBORN MOUNTAIN RETREAT, PAONIA, CO
    One-of-a-kind gem borders public lands/West Elk Wilderness. Privacy, creek, spring, irrigation, access. $270,000. Info at https://hcne.ws/LambornMT or call 970-683-0588 or 970-261-5928.
  • RECRUITMENT & HIRING MANAGER WITH WRA
    Western Resource Advocates (WRA) is seeking a dynamic, organized, and creative person with great people skills to be our Recruitment & Hiring Manager to recruit...
  • CLEAN ENERGY ATTORNEY (NM) AND POLICY ASSOCIATE/ANALYST (AZ & NV)
    Western Resource Advocates (WRA) is looking for a variety of positions around the West with our Clean Energy Program. Currently we are hiring a Staff...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, HAWKWATCH INTERNATIONAL
    We are seeking an experienced dynamic leader for a growing conservation organization; $65,000-75,000 salary plus benefits; job description and apply at hawkwatch.org/executivedirector
  • FRIENDS OF THE INYO IS HIRING FOR THE SUMMER OF 2019
    Friends of the Inyo is excited to post our seasonal job offerings for the summer of 2019! We are hiring Trail Ambassadors, Stewardship Crew Members,...
  • DONOR RELATIONS MANAGER
    This position is responsible for the identification and qualification of major and planned gift prospects and assists in cultivating and soliciting donors through meetings, trips,...
  • STREAMFLOW RESTORATION IMPLEMENTATION LEAD (ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNER 4)
    Keeping Washington Clean and Evergreen Protecting Washington State's environment for current and future generations is what we do every day at Ecology. We are a...
  • SENIOR STORMWATER ENGINEER (ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEER 5)
    Keeping Washington Clean and Evergreen Our Water Quality Program is looking to hire a Senior Stormwater Engineer at our Headquarters building in Lacey, WA This...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    Do you enjoy rural living, wild places, family farms, challenging politics, and big conservation opportunities? Do you have leadership abilities, experience with rural land protection,...
  • MAJOR GIFT OFFICER
    University of Wyoming Foundation Haub School of ENR, Biodiversity Institute, Environmental/Natural Resource Programs https://uwyo.taleo.net/careersection/00_ex/jobdetail.ftl?job=19001001&tz=GMT-06:00
  • MONTANA LAND STEWARD
    The Montana Land Steward develops, manages, and advances conservation programs, plans, and methods related to TNC's property interest portfolio in Montana. For more information and...
  • RAISER'S EDGE DATABASE ADMINISTRATOR
    POSITION DESCRIPTION: RAISER'S EDGE DATABASE ADMINISTRATOR The Raiser's Edge Database Administrator ensures the integrity and effectiveness of the member/donor database by developing systems and processes...
  • DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT
    We are hiring a Director of Development Full time, competitive pay and benefits. Location: Bozeman,MT Visit www.greateryellowstone.org/careers for details GYC is an equal opportunity employer
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, KANIKSU LAND TRUST
    Kaniksu Land Trust, a community-supported non-profit land trust serving north Idaho and northwest Montana, is in search of a new executive director. The ideal candidate...
  • 3 POSITIONS: ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR, DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR, AND FOREST PROGRAMS ASSOCIATE
    Mountain Studies Inst (MSI) in Durango and Silverton, CO is hiring 3 staff: Please visit mountainstudies.org/careers for Assoc Director, Dev and Engagement Director, and Forest...
  • CENTER FOR COLLABORATIVE CONSERVATION DIRECTOR, COLORADO STATE UNIVERSITY
    The Center for Collaborative Conservation is hiring a full-time, permanent Director. Applications are due on March 31. Description can be found at http://jobs.colostate.edu/postings/65118 No phone...
  • CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER/DEPUTY DIRECTOR
    Friends of Cedar Mesa seeks a skilled non-profit leader to play a crucial role in protecting the greater Bears Ears landscape. Experience working with government...
  • LUNATEC HYDRATION SPRAY BOTTLE
    Clean off, cool off & drink. Multiple spray patterns. Better than you imagine. Try it.