'Wise use' plans abhor change


Note: this feature article is one of several in a special issue about growth and planning in the West.

Cody, Wyo. - This county on the eastern border of Yellowstone National Park has been so sparsely settled, the prospect of a little more than 100 people moving in to work a gold mine helped set off a planning emergency.

Anticipating growth linked to the proposed gold mine near the park, and responding to the land boom that's taking hold here, last year the county commissioners imposed a moratorium on subdivisions. They then hired a new planner to develop a countywide comprehensive plan.

Now, with significant citizen involvement, the county has a draft plan that would take some beginner steps to keep the county's private valleys uncluttered.

But surprising opposition has emerged. Some people who helped draft the plan have mounted a last-minute campaign one planning commissioner calls an attempted "hijack" of the process.

Opponents, most of them members of the Meeteetse and Park County "multiple-use" associations, are primarily ranchers and loggers who feel pinched by federal regulation of public lands. They say the county's plan is also too restrictive - in its regulation of private land - and they want it toned down.

The associations circulated a newsletter advocating land-use plans modeled on one adopted in 1991 by Catron County, N.M. More than 40 Western counties have adopted the "custom and culture" model, asserting the right to decide timber, grazing and mining levels on federal lands.

Park County is unlikely to adopt a Catron County-type plan, but the dynamics of its planning battle reverberate throughout the West. The counties adopting "custom and culture" plans largely abhor any form of planning for change and hope somehow to seal off their communities from outside forces.

In a sense, both the wise users and those who favor conventional planning say they pursue the same goal: preservation of existing society and land uses. But the pro-planning forces would do this through regulation and the wise use forces through a total lack of local, state or, expecially, federal regulation.

For example, while Catron County-type "planning" demands that federal lands be open to logging and grazing, those counties won't zone their private lands to protect ranch and forest lands from subdividing. Although a federal judge in Boundary County, Idaho, close to Canada, recently ruled unconstitutional a Catron County-type plan passed by commissioners there, dozens of counties in the West continue to consider adopting such plans (HCN, 5/22/93).

"I can't understand why a county would spend its precious resources on these unenforceable and illegal plans when it could be doing legitimate land-use plans," says Kathy Kilmer, a staffer for The Wilderness Society in Denver. "You can't just dig a hole and hide your heads in it."

But Aaron Harp, a rural sociologist with the University of Idaho, says the dug-heels reaction of these communities is understandable.

"The ranchers, miners and loggers view themselves as an indigenous culture, as second wave natives," says Harp. "To them, newcomers are carrying out a cultural genocide."

Some mad, some mellower

In Idaho, stubborn resistance to planning has reared its head in two of the counties Harp has worked with, Custer and Lemhi, both of which are more than 90 percent public land.

Yet the campaign by people loosely identified as part of the "wise use/multiple use" movement played out very differently in the two counties.

In Custer County, where some ranchers say they're being squeezed out by environmental regulations and newcomers, residents raised the banner of RAGE - Rebellion Against Government Excess. A leader of the RAGE group, state GOP Rep. Lenore Barrett of Challis, tells her people not to compromise.

"You know, your back is against the wall," Barrett told 300 ranchers at the first RAGE gathering last year. "The question is, are you ready to come out fighting?"

Barrett says, if the federal government backed off from raising grazing fees and enforcing other regulations, ranchers could stay in business. Then local governments wouldn't have to step in to protect ranches from being turned into ranchettes that serve the newcomers.

In neighboring Lemhi County, a local group, Grassroots for Multiple Use, wanted the county to follow the rebellious custom-and-culture protective model of planning. As a wider spectrum of residents got involved in planning, though, sentiment moved more toward cooperation. Ranchers who live along the Lemhi River wound up working with federal and state agencies to improve salmon habitat and restore historical salmon runs.

While Custer County has put very little into planning for growth on private lands, Lemhi County has adopted a comprehensive plan to increase control over new developments. Kelly Anglin, a member of the county's planning commision, says, "Part of our goal is, we're trying to protect a Western rural way of life."

Says Dave McFarland, a rancher and co-chairman of Lemhi County's land-use planning effort, "We're trying to come up with our best bet for the whole ecosystem."


Here in Park County, Wyo., the mood has shifted from cooperation to confrontation. "Multiple-use" advocates packed a planning commission meeting in July and called for the county to hire a consultant and revamp the comprehensive plan that had been drafted after months of public input. The sole environmentalist attending that meeting, Lamar Empey, a retired professor of criminology who sits on the board of the Greater Yellowstone Coalition, says he was flabbergasted.

"I stood up and said their suggestions were an insult to all the people who have worked for months on the new plan," says Empey, who was a member of a 75-member planning task force that included environmentalists, wise-use proponents and every perspective in between. "We achieved a remarkable consensus, and none of us got everything we wanted."

Kathleen Jachowski, a spokeswoman for a local lumber company and member of the Meeteetse and Park County "multiple-use" associations, says she doesn't want to waste the months of public effort, either. But she says the draft plan is filled with the personal perspectives of County Planner Mark Sawyer, and the county should hire a new planner who better understands Wyoming.

"Mark's only been here a year," says Jachowski, who moved to the state nine years ago. "If there's anybody who is an outsider here it's Mark Sawyer. It's too easy to put on a cowboy hat and jeans and say, "I'm with you." "

As for deciding the fate of private ranchlands, Jachowski says ranchers and farmers shouldn't bear the burden of providing aesthetically pleasing open country for newcomers. She opposes language in the new plan which says the county should promote the formation of a land trust to protect open space.

Planner Sawyer, speaking in the quiet tones of someone in a tight spot, says he understands why ranchers and loggers feel threatened by the rapid changes affecting the county. But "this community has far broader concerns than just protecting commodity use of public lands," he says.

Sawyer says multiple-use supporters fail to see that by resisting regulations on private lands they are actually accelerating change.

"Their attitude toward newcomers is "We'll sell you land and take your money but don't vote or express your opinion," " says Sawyer. Democracy doesn't work like that, he says. The former Californians and urbanites who buy land from ranchers will vote, says Sawyer, and they don't believe grazing and logging should be the dominant uses of public lands.

But the multiple-use/wise-use advocates' organizing abilities may keep them one step ahead of change, at least for awhile. In an August county commissioner election, they voted two of their own onto the five-person commission. One, Beryl Churchill, ran ads in the local paper saying the planning process was "rotten."

The following sidebar article accompanies this feature story:

- Careful planning avoids takings

High Country News Classifieds
    Job Announcement: Environmental Justice Associate Announcement date: June 18, 2021 Applications will be reviewed on an ongoing basis and first review will begin: July 13,...
    Job Announcement: Communications Associate Announcement date: June 18, 2021 Applications will be reviewed on an ongoing basis and first review will begin: July 13, 2021...
    Colorado Wild Public Lands (COWPL), based in Basalt, is an exciting nonprofit working to keep public lands open and accessible. Our growing organization is seeking...
    High Country News, an award-winning media organization covering the communities and environment of the Western United States, seeks a part-time business support assistant to provide...
    The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance (SUWA), Utah's largest conservation organization, has an immediate opening for a full-time Social Media and Digital Advertising Specialist. This position...
    Adjacent parcels above the Upper Sacramento river, near Dunsmuir. The smaller is just under 3 acres, with the larger at just under 15 acres. Multiple...
    Greater Yellowstone Coalition seeks a development professional to coordinate the organization's individual giving program. The position description is available at http://greateryellowstone.org/careers Please email a letter...
    The Wilderness Society is seeking a full time Idaho State Director who will preferably be based in Boise, Idaho. At least 8-10 years of experience...
    Conservation nonprofit Friends of Cedar Mesa in Bluff, Utah is hiring for two positions. We seek a Communications Manager to execute inspiring and impactful communications...
    Wilderness Volunteers Wilderness Volunteers (WV), a 24-year leader in preserving our nation's wildlands, is seeking a motivated person with deep outdoor interests to guide our...
    Hispanics Enjoying Camping, Hunting, and the Outdoors (HECHO) was created in 2013 to help fulfill our duty to conserve and protect our public lands for...
    Under the direct supervision of the Director of Shoshone-Paiute Tribe's Fish, Wildlife & Parks, in coordination with the Tribal Programs Administrator and the Tribal Chairman,...
    Founded in 1936, the National Wildlife Federation has grown into America's largest and most trusted grassroots conservation organization with 53 state/territorial affiliates and more than...
    STEWARDSHIP MANAGER Job Vacancy and Description Posted June 2, 2021: Open until filled The New Mexico Land Conservancy (NMLC) is a non-profit, regional land trust...
    KSJD is seeking a host/reporter. Please see for www.ksjd.org for more information. EEO compliant.
    Quiet, comfy house for rent in Bluff, Utah. Walk to San Juan River. Bike or hike to many nearby ruins and rock art sites. Beautiful...
    Come to Ketchikan and check out the Rain forest on the coast, Hike the shorelines, hug the big trees, watch deer in the muskeg meadows,...
    Start each month with a poem in your inbox by signing up for Taylor S. Winchell's monthly Poem+ Newsletter. No frills. No news. No politics....
    St. Lawrence University seeks to fill the position of Assistant Director in the Outdoor Program. To view the complete position description, including minimum qualifications required,...
    Yellowstone Llamas Successful Yellowstone NP concession Flexible packages