Non-navigable River Blues

Muddied water-protection standards leave Western streams without oversight

  • Kayakers float the Los Angeles River near the Sixth Street Bridge in downtown L.A.

    Tom Andrews
  • The Santa Cruz River through Tucson is dry most of the year, but it can flood during summer.

    R.S. Walker
  • The Rillito and Santa Cruz rivers were raging in July 2007, where they come together in northwest Tucson.

    Andrew E. Winklejohn
  • Heather Wylie at the launch point on the L.A. River. She later was disciplined by the Army Corps of Engineers, and finally left the Corps after an undisclosed settlement.

    Tom Andrews
 

Page 3

Two decades ago, a small-time Michigan shopping-center developer named John Rapanos raised the property-rights banner on high: He filled in more than 50 acres of what his own consultant had told him were wetlands without getting a federal permit first. He was taken to court and found guilty of civil violations of the Clean Water Act; a circuit court later upheld the district court's ruling, which brought with it millions of dollars in fines.

Rapanos appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, and in 2006, five justices voted to vacate the civil judgment against the developer, and return the case to the lower courts. But the justices split 4-4-1 on the bigger question of what standards should be used for protecting rivers and streams.

Justice Antonin Scalia and three others agreed that washes had to be "relatively permanent" to warrant federal protection. Ephemeral and intermittent streams were out of the running. "By applying the term 'waters of the United States' " -- the Clean Water Act's benchmark for federal control of a wash -- to ephemeral streams, wet meadows, and "dry arroyos in the middle of the desert … the Corps has stretched the term … beyond parody," Scalia wrote. Justice John Paul Stevens and three others supported the existing system.

In a separate opinion that has become the ruling's most commonly cited passage, Justice Anthony Kennedy offered a different guidepost: that a wetland deserves protection if it connects to a tributary that has a "significant nexus" with a navigable waterway. But how do you determine that? "Case by case," replied Kennedy.

That left the Corps and the Environmental Protection Agency with the arduous task of figuring out exactly what a "significant nexus" is. Initially, the agencies showed sympathy for non-perennial streams: An early draft of the guidelines sent to the White House Council on Environmental Quality included a provision that would consider the combined effects of similar tributaries on a navigable stream when deciding whether a stream passes the nexus test. But Virginia Albrecht, an attorney for developers and other industries with a stake in the decision, objected. In a letter to Gregory Schildwachter, the Council's associate director, she argued that the provision was inconsistent with the "case by case" direction. 

Under pressure from the White House, the agencies ultimately withdrew the combined-effect provision, and instead included in its June 2007 guidelines a highly technical seven-page process for determining whether something is a "significant nexus." Developers winced at the prospect of going through the process, which seemed to promise more, not less, red tape. And enviros worried that desert streams would be left high and dry. Lance Wood, assistant counsel for the Corps in Washington, D.C., echoed that concern in an e-mail to Wylie, in which he wrote that the guidelines would make "it hard to assert jurisdiction over any particular ephemeral or not relatively permanent intermittent stream."

But Benjamin Grumbles, EPA's assistant administrator for water, said that the agency simply sought to strike a balance between environmentalists' desire to interpret Kennedy's "significant nexus" test as broadly as possible, and the government's determination to defend its decisions in court.

The waters only got murkier as a result.

High Country News Classifieds
  • DEVELOPMENT AND OPERATIONS COORDINATOR
    Development & Operations Coordinator Terms: 1.0 FTE (full-time), Salary DOE ($45,000 - $55,000) Benefits: Paid Time Off (12-24 days/year depending on tenure), Paid Holidays (10/year),...
  • GUIDE TO WESTERN NATIONAL MONUMENTS
    NEW BOOK showcases 70 national monuments across the western United States. Use "Guide10" for 10% off at cmcpress.org
  • CARBON RANCH PLANNER
    The Quivira Coalition (www.quiviracoaltion.org) is a Santa Fe-based nonprofit that builds resilience on arid working lands. We foster ecological, economic, and social health through education,...
  • EDUCATION AND OUTREACH DIRECTOR
    Education and Outreach Program Director The Quivira Coalition (www.quiviracoaltion.org) is a Santa Fe-based nonprofit that builds resilience on arid working lands. We foster ecological, economic,...
  • WESTERN DIVISION DIRECTOR OF FIELD PROGRAMS
    DEADLINE TO APPLY: October 29, 2021 LOCATION FLEXIBLE (WESTERN HUB CITY PREFERRED) Overview The Land Trust Alliance is the voice of the land trust community....
  • COMMUNICATIONS AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE
    Communications and Outreach Associate Position Opening: www.westernlaw.org/communications-outreach-associate ************************************************* Location: Western U.S., ideally in one of WELC's existing office locations (Santa Fe or Taos, NM, Helena,...
  • FREELANCE GRAPHIC DESIGNER & PROJECT COORDINATOR (REMOTE)
    High Country News (HCN) is seeking a contract Graphic Designer & Project Coordinator to design promotional, marketing and fund-raising assets and campaigns, and project-manage them...
  • FILM AND DIGITAL MEDIA: ASSISTANT PROFESSOR OF INDIGENOUS MEDIA, CULTURAL SOVEREIGNTY AND DECOLONIZATION (INITIAL REVIEW 12.1.21)
    Film and Digital Media: Assistant Professor of Indigenous Media, Cultural Sovereignty and Decolonization (Initial Review 12.1.21) Position overview Position title: Assistant Professor - tenure-track Salary...
  • REAL ESTATE SPECIALIST
    To learn more about this position and to apply please go to the following URL.
  • ENVIRONMENTAL GEOPHYSICS
    "More Data, Less Digging" Find groundwater and reduce excavation costs!
  • RARE CHIRICAHUA RIPARIAN LAND FOR SALE
    40 acres: 110 miles from Tucson: native trees, grasses: birder's heaven::dark sky/ borders state lease & National forest/5100 ft/13-16 per annum rain
  • CENTRAL PARK CULTURAL RESOURCE SPECIALIST
    Agency: Oregon Parks and Recreation Department Salary Range: $5,203 - $7,996 Position Title: Central Park Cultural Resource Specialist Do you have a background in Archaeology...
  • STAFF ATTORNEY
    Come live and work in one of the most beautiful places in the world! As our Staff Attorney you will play a key role in...
  • ARIZONA GRAZING CLEARINGHOUSE
    Dedicated to preventing the ecological degradation caused by livestock grazing on Arizona's public lands, and exposing the government subsidies that support it.
  • OPERATIONS MANAGER
    Position Summary: Friends of the Inyo (friendsoftheinyo.org) is seeking a new Operations Manager. The Operations Manager position is a full-time permanent position that reports directly...
  • WATER RIGHTS BUREAU CHIEF
    Water Rights Bureau Chief, State of Montana, DNRC, Water Resources Division, Helena, MT Working to support and implement the Department's mission to help ensure that...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    The Amargosa Conservancy (AC), a conservation nonprofit dedicated to standing up for water and biodiversity in the Death Valley region, seeks an executive director to...
  • DEVELOPMENT & OUTREACH ASSOCIATE
    Southeast Alaska Conservation Council is hiring! Who We Are: The Southeast Alaska Conservation Council (SEACC) is a small grassroots nonprofit based out of Juneau, Alaska,...
  • DESERT LANDS ORGANIZER
    Position Summary: Friends of the Inyo seeks a Desert Lands Organizer to assist with existing campaigns that will defend lands in the California desert, with...
  • IDAHO CONSERVATION LEAGUE
    Want to help preserve Idaho's land, water, and air for future generations? Idaho Conservation League currently has 3 open positions. We are looking for a...