Why Justice Anthony Kennedy wasn’t good for Indian Country

The retiring Supreme Court justice leaves a legacy of anti-tribal votes.

 

My most enduring memory of Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy is watching him lean over the bench, red-faced and angry, lecturing attorney Neal Katyal during the Dollar General Corp. v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians oral argument.

At issue in that case was whether tribal courts had jurisdiction over civil claims: Dollar General had opened a store on the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians’ reservation and signed a lease saying that legal disputes would be tried in Choctaw court. When the store’s non-Indian manager made sexual advances toward a 13-year-old Choctaw boy, the boy’s family took the matter to tribal court. Dollar General decided that tribal court was unacceptable and took the matter to the Supreme Court.

Supreme Court Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington. Kennedy's voting record was overwhelmingly oppositional to tribes, voting in favor of tribal interest 11 times and against 45 times.
Manuel Balce Ceneta

That day, I finally understood that Kennedy was so disturbed by tribal jurisdiction over non-Indians that he would angrily protect a sexual predator from the horror of being subject to a tribal court, a position completely in line with his previous stands on Indian cases.

Kennedy, who announced his retirement in June, was confirmed to the Supreme Court in 1988. He heard around 60 Indian law cases, and during his tenure, tribal interests won 15 cases and lost 40. Just under 30 percent of cases were won by tribal interests, making Kennedy’s time on the court a bad time for Indian people and Indian tribes.

His voting record was overwhelmingly oppositional to tribes. He voted  in favor of tribal interest 11 times and against 45 times. He wrote only a small number of opinions in Indian law cases.

The most important majority opinion Kennedy wrote was Duro v. Reina. In Duro, the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community attempted to prosecute Albert Duro, a member of the Torres-Martinez Desert Cahuilla Indians who had been living and working on the Pima reservation. The Supreme Court held that tribes could not prosecute non-member Indians because they were not citizens of the tribes prosecuting them.

Kennedy wrote that the Salt River Pima–Maricopa Indian Community could not prosecute a member of the Torres-Martinez Desert Cahuilla Indians who had been living and working on the Pima reservation.
Ken Lund

Kennedy’s Duro opinion shouldn’t be considered important as it was clearly wrong on many levels – Congress enacted a fix restoring tribal jurisdiction within weeks of the decision – but it could be examined as the climax of decades of legal thinking. The principles Kennedy advanced in Duro were principles he had been working on since at least the 1970s, when he dissented as a 9th Circuit Court of Appeals judge in Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe. The Supreme Court later adopted the same position, ruling that tribes had no criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians that committed crimes in tribal territories.

In Kennedy’s America, non-Indian and Indian alike must consent to the state; Indians consent to being the subject of tribal jurisdiction while non-Indians lack the ability to consent because they cannot be tribal citizens. Perhaps the biggest problem for Kennedy’s consent theory is that it’s non-sensical and not grounded in either the constitution or reality. He laid out his consent theory in United States v. Lara, the case confirming the Duro fix, and waited for an opportunity to challenge the fix, but that vehicle never came. 

For all my criticism, I do have a favorite Kennedy opinion: United States v. Finch. In that case, Kennedy faithfully applied Indian law by writing strongly in favor of the Crow Nation’s ownership of the Bighorn River as guaranteed by treaty. Justice William Rehnquist’s Supreme Court took up the case in 1980 in Montana v. United States, and decided that the Crow did not possess the river because Crows only ate bison, never fish, and therefore wouldn’t have even wanted the Bighorn River. 

If Kennedy had respected the foundational principles of Indian law he showed in Finch during his tenure as a Supreme Court justice and refused to side repeatedly with the likes of Rehnquist, he’d be celebrated, even worshipped, by Indian Country. Instead, it’s the red-faced Kennedy shown in the Dollar General case that we’ll remember most.

Matthew L.M. Fletcher is professor of law at Michigan State University College of Law and director of the Indigenous Law and Policy Center. He is a member of the Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa and Chippewa Indians. Find his writing on Turtle Talk.

High Country News Classifieds
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    Seeking passionate full-time Executive to lead the oldest non-profit organization in Idaho. Must have knowledge of environmental issues, excellent organizational, verbal presentation and written skills,...
  • COLORADO PROGRAM MANAGER
    The National Parks Conservation Association, the leading non-profit conservation organization protecting Americas national parks, seeks a Program Manager for its Colorado Field Office located in...
  • CONSERVATION DIRECTOR
    Carbondale based public lands advocate, Wilderness Workshop, seeks a Conservation Director to help direct and shape the future of public land conservation on the West...
  • DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR WATER PLANNING WITH WRA'S HEALTHY RIVERS PROGRAM
    Founded in 1989, Western Resource Advocates (WRA) is dedicated to protecting the Wests land, air, and water to ensure that vibrant communities exist in balance...
  • TROUT UNLIMITED BIGHORN RIVER BASIN PROJECT MANAGER
    The Bighorn River Basin Project Manager identifies and implements projects to improve streamflows, restore stream and riparian habitat, improve fish passage and rehabilitate or replace...
  • NON-PROFIT OPERATIONS MANAGER
    One of the most renowned community-based collaboratives in the country seeks full-time Operations Manager to oversee administrative, financial, fund development, and board development duties. BS/BA...
  • RUSTIC HORSE PROPERTY
    in NM. 23 acres, off the grid, rustic cabin, organic gardens, fruit trees, fenced, call 505-204-8432 evenings.
  • DIRECTOR OF VISITOR SERVICES & BOOKSTORE OPERATIONS
    The San Juan Mountains Association in Durango, CO is seeking a Director of Visitor Services & Bookstore Operations to lead our visitor information program &...
  • SOLAR POWERED HOME NEAR CAPITOL REEF NATIONAL PARK
    1800 sf home on 4.12 acres surrounded by Natl Forest and recreational opportunities in a beautiful area (Happy Valley) between Torrey and Boulder. [email protected], www.bouldermoutainreality/properties/grover/off-the-grid-in-happy-valley,...
  • 40 ACRE ORGANIC FARM
    potential fruit/hay with house, Hotchkiss, CO, Scott Ellis, 970-420-0472, [email protected]
  • STAFF ATTORNEY
    STAFF ATTORNEY POSITION OPENING www.westernlaw.org/about-us/clinic-interns-careers The Western Environmental Law Center (WELC) is a nonprofit public interest environmental law firm with a 25-year legacy of success...
  • LAND CONSERVATION DIRECTOR
    Manage, develop and implement all stewardship and land management plans and activities on both private and public lands. Guide and direct comprehensive planning efforts, provide...
  • INTERNET-BASED BUSINESS FOR SALE
    Dream of owning your own business, being your own boss, working from home ... this is the one. 928-380-6570, www.testshop.com. More info at https://bit.ly/2Kgi340.
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    If you are deeply committed to public service and would like to become part of our high performing, passionate and diverse team, NCAT is looking...
  • TRIPLEX .8 ACRE KANAB, UT
    Create a base in the center of Southern Utah's Grand Circle of National Parks. Multiple residential property with three established rental units and zoning latitude...
  • FORGE & FAB SHOP
    with home on one beautiful acre in Pocatello, ID. Blackrock Forge - retiring after 43 years! Fully equipped 5,500 sf shop including office, gallery and...
  • SMALL FARM AT THE BASE OF MOUNT SHASTA
    Certified organic fruit/berry/veggie/flower farm. Home, barns, garage, separate apt, more. Just under 2 ac, edge of town. Famously pure air and water. Skiing, mountaineering, bike,...
  • FOREST STEWARDSHIP PROJECT DIRECTOR
    Become a force for nature and a healthy planet by joining the Arizona Chapter as Forest Stewardship Project Director. You will play a key role...
  • LIGHTWEIGHT FLY ROD CASES
    4 standard or custom lengths. Rugged protection for backpacking. Affordable pricing.
  • DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT
    will develop and execute Wild Utah Projects fundraising plan. Call, email or check full description of job online for more details: