The fight over a 5,000-year-old burial site in California

How a state law to expedite affordable housing erased a tribe’s right to consultation.

 

Editor’s note: On July 28th, 2021, the Supreme Court of California denied review of this case.  Developers and landowners Ruegg & Ellsworth and the Frank Spenger Company will be granted a permit to develop on the West Berkley Shellmound and Village Site.

After a six-year fight to protect the West Berkeley Shellmound, an appeals court granted a developer the right to build an apartment complex there. The area is currently fenced off by barbed wire.

Over the course of three weeks in the fall of 2005, Corrina Gould and dozens of others walked approximately 270 miles around California’s San Francisco Bay. Activists from the group she co-founded, Indian People Organizing for Change, alongside allies from the Bay Area and abroad, paused to pray at shellmound sites scattered across the area, from Vallejo to San Jose and up to San Francisco.

This was one of many walks that Gould, the tribal chair for the Confederated Villages of Lisjan, one of several Ohlone tribes, coordinated over the years to raise awareness about the approximately 425 shellmounds that once dotted the landscape. These structures, which were assembled by humans from layers of shell deposits and used as burial and ceremonial grounds, have all but disappeared underneath urban San Francisco and its surroundings, buried by railroad tracks, apartment buildings and shopping malls. In some instances, the shells themselves were hauled off to pave roads in the city.

On one of these walks, Gould held prayers at the West Berkeley Shellmound, one of the oldest sites and a place that has deep significance for her tribe. “This was the very first place that we began to build shellmounds — our cemeteries along these waterways,” said Gould. Ohlone people were laid to rest here before their souls traveled on to Alcatraz Island and passed through what Gould knows as the western gate, site of the present-day Golden Gate Bridge. 

But like so much of her tribe’s history, it might soon be destroyed. This past April, after a six-year fight to protect the shellmound and its greater historic site, an appeals court granted a developer the right to build an apartment complex there. The City of Berkeley and the Confederated Villages of Lisjan appealed that decision in May, bringing the case before the Supreme Court of California. But the court reviews only a small percentage of the cases that reach its jurisdiction — and if the case is dismissed, the developer will receive the permit. At a time when California Gov. Gavin Newsom has publicly issued an apology to tribes and formed a Truth and Healing Council, which could later recommend actions including reparations, this case proves just how difficult it will be for the state to honor such commitments if they collide with other priorities.  

Brdiget Brehen at candlelight vigil to protect the West Berkeley Shellmound on March 20, 2021. Hundreds attended.

IN 2015, REAL ESTATE developers and landowners Ruegg & Ellsworth and the Frank Spenger Company submitted an application to develop a 135-unit apartment complex and retail space located on the West Berkeley Shellmound and Village site, which was designated as a city landmark in 2000. As part of the process, the developer submitted a draft environmental impact review (DEIR), claiming that an archaeological dig in 2014 showed the apartments would not overlap with the Shellmound site. However, in letters to the planning and development department, Christopher Dore, an archaeologist who had previously worked with the City of Berkeley, pointed out that the 2014 sampling methods had been inadequate to make a determination about the location of the shellmound. At the time, some Ohlone tribal members said that proposed mitigation efforts, such as sending any found human remains to a cemetery, simply added to the injustice. (One Ohlone tribal member, who has worked as a consultant for the developers, disagrees, saying that the shellmound’s location is not as vulnerable as opponents allege.)

Even if it did constitute a structure, the company maintains that it merely represents the “remnants” of what once existed.

But those concerns no longer mattered in 2017, when then-Gov. Jerry Brown signed Senate Bill 35 into law. The controversial legislation incentivized the construction of affordable housing at the expense of local review processes, allowing developers to bypass the California Environmental Quality Act, the state’s version of the National Environmental Policy Act, if a development met an affordable housing requirement. As a result, Ruegg & Ellsworth withdrew its application and submitted a new proposal that expanded the size of the project and designated half of the units as low-income. This halted the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) process, which would have required an environmental impact report, as well as public input and consultation with local tribes.

The case currently before the state Supreme Court in part questions whether this new law should even apply to this site. That’s because the legislation has certain carve-outs that prevent the use of this streamlined permitting process — if, for example, the site holds a historic structure that could be demolished. From the developer’s perspective, the shellmound is not a historic structure; Ruegg & Ellsworth refer to it as “only a ‘mound’ or a ‘heap’,” according to court documents. Even if it did constitute a structure, the company maintains that it merely represents the “remnants” of what once existed. In April, the judges in the Court of Appeals agreed. (Neither the development company nor its lawyers would comment for this piece.)

Isabella Zizi (Northern Cheyenne Arikara and Muskogee Creek) speaks to a crowd gathered for a candlelight vigil to protect the West Berkeley Shellmound Sacred Site, one of the the earliest known Ohlone structures on the shores of what is now called the San Francisco Bay.

IT'S TRUE THAT IF you visited the area today, you wouldn’t be able to see the mound—which was at least 15 feet high, and approximately 600 feet long—that once stood there. Instead, you’d see the old parking lot of a now-closed seafood restaurant, Spenger’s Fresh Fish Grotto. And to be clear, only a portion of the mound may still lie below the site of the proposed development. But to Gould, the fact that a parking lot is all that sits on the site is itself a bit of a miracle. In a way, it has protected what little is left of her tribe’s history. “That place is especially important, because it has not been developed on, it has not been dug up,” she said. “And so we have to acknowledge that there’s something special, that this land for all of these years since colonization has been left virtually untouched.” 

 Since the state law did not define what makes a historic structure, it’s up for interpretation whether this site counts as one. As the City of Berkeley points out in court documents, the state’s own Historical Building Code defines a historical building as “any structure or property, collection of structures, and their related sites deemed of importance to the history.” The appeals court has chosen to go with a definition more akin to buildings that rise above ground and are still standing.  

“We have to acknowledge that there’s something special, that this land for all of these years since colonization has been left virtually untouched.” 

For Gould, the very concept is biased. “A ‘historical structure’ is always a funny word for me, as an Indigenous person,” she said. “Because they want to use only the history since colonization. They don't use the history beyond that. And so thousands of years of history is left behind.”

Dore, who studied the site in 1999, said that it is significant apart from the mound. “There are probably lots of other features within the site boundary and artifacts and, you know, maybe structures and other types of things beside the mound,” he said. “It’s quite plausible that there would be hearths, fire pits, and remains of buildings or shelters.” It’s also likely that there are burial remains there as well, he said. Just in 2016, four burials were uncovered across the street near the Spenger Restaurant. Dore thinks it meets all the criteria for being listed on the National Register. In 2020, it made the National Trust for Historic Preservation’s annual list of Americas 11 Most Endangered Historic Places.

Unfortunately, when the law is vague, courts don’t often rule in favor of tribal perspectives, said Courtney Ann Coyle, an attorney who is representing the United Auburn Indian Community, a tribe in California that submitted an amicus brief in support of the city of Berkeley and the Confederated Villages of Lisjan.

The tribe Coyle represents is worried the court’s decision could have wider implications for other tribes. “There is a serious risk that the court’s conclusion — that mounds cannot be structures and that they lose significance under state law if they are buried or otherwise disturbed — could be misused as precedent in other contexts, causing further harm,” their brief stated.

But the decision also points to a bigger problem within the court system as a whole, she said. “Judges are certainly human. And if they haven’t been trained to recognize implicit bias, societal bias, they just might fall back to what they are comfortable with and what they have been taught,” she said. In this case, “the (appeals) court twisted the definition of a historic structure … Which may show bias against tribes, their resources, and ways of knowing,” she later wrote in an email. (A 2020 amendment to SB35 means that there will be more protections for tribal cultural resources in the future.)

Perhaps more importantly, while the Berkeley Shellmound is part of a historical site, it continues to hold contemporary meaning to Gould and the other tribal members who to this day hold ceremonies and prayers there. In her biggest dreams, she or the city would be able to buy the property and turn it into a green space, a memorial of sorts. “It’s a place that we should all revere, and it should have the same protections as modern-day cemeteries,” she said.

Jessica Kutz is an assistant editor for High Country News. Email her at [email protected] or submit a letter to the editor.

High Country News Classifieds
  • 10 ACRES OF NEW MEXICO HIGH DESERT
    10 Acres of undeveloped high desert land in central NM, about 45 minutes from downtown Albuquerque. Mixed cedar and piñon pine cover. Some dirt roadways...
  • WATERSHED RESTORATION DIRECTOR
    $58k-$70k + benefits to oversee watershed restoration projects that fulfill our strategic goals across urban and rural areas within the bi-national Santa Cruz and San...
  • CUSTOMER SERVICE ASSISTANT - (PART-TIME)
    High Country News, an award-winning media organization covering the communities and environment of the Western United States, seeks a part-time Customer Service Assistant, based at...
  • OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
    We are a Santa Fe-based nonprofit that builds resilience on arid working lands. We foster ecological, economic, and social health through education, innovation, and collaboration....
  • COMMUNITY ORGANIZER
    Come work alongside everyday Montanans to project our clean air, water, and build thriving communities! Competitive salary, health insurance, pension, generous vacation time and sabbatical....
  • CAMPAIGN MANAGER
    Oregon Natural Desert Association (ONDA), a nonprofit conservation organization dedicated to protecting, defending and restoring Oregon's high desert, seeks a Campaign Manager to works as...
  • HECHO DEPUTY DIRECTOR
    Hispanics Enjoying Camping, Hunting, and the Outdoors (HECHO) was created in 2013 to help fulfill our duty to conserve and protect our public lands for...
  • REGIONAL REPRESENTATIVE, COLUMBIA CASCADES
    The Regional Representative serves as PCTA's primary staff on the ground along the trail working closely with staff, volunteers, and nonprofit and agency partners. This...
  • FINANCE AND OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
    The Montana Land Reliance (MLR) seeks a full-time Finance and Operations Director to manage the internal functions of MLR and its nonprofit affiliates. Key areas...
  • DIRECTOR OF CONSERVATION
    The Nature Conservancy is recruiting for a Director of Conservation. Provides strategic leadership and support for all of the Conservancy's conservation work in Arizona. The...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
    The Amargosa Conservancy (AC), a conservation nonprofit dedicated to standing up for water and biodiversity in the Death Valley region, seeks an executive director to...
  • BIG BASIN SENIOR PROJECT PLANNER - CLIMATE ADAPTATION & RESILIENCE
    Parks California Big Basin Senior Project Planner - Climate Adaptation & Resilience ORGANIZATION BACKGROUND Parks California is a new organization working to ensure that our...
  • SCIENCE PROJECT MANAGER
    About Long Live the Kings (LLTK) Our mission is to restore wild salmon and steelhead and support sustainable fishing in the Pacific Northwest. Since 1986,...
  • NEW BOOK BY AWARD-WINNING WILDLIFE BIOLOGIST, BRUCE SMITH
    In a perilous place at the roof of the world, an orphaned mountain goat is rescued from certain death by a mysterious raven.This middle-grade novel,...
  • MOUNTAIN LOTS FOR SALE
    Multiple lots in gated community only 5 miles from Great Sand Dunes National Park. Seasonal flowing streams. Year round road maintenance.
  • RURAL ACREAGE OUTSIDE SILVER CITY, NM
    Country living just minutes from town! 20 acres with great views makes a perfect spot for your custom home. Nice oaks and juniper. Cassie Carver,...
  • A FIVE STAR FOREST SETTING WITH SECLUSION AND SEPARATENESS
    This home is for a discerning buyer in search of a forest setting of premier seclusion & separateness. Surrounded on all sides by USFS land...
  • CARPENTER WANTED
    CARPENTER WANTED. Come to Ketchikan and check out the Rainforest on the coast, HIke the shorelines, hug the big trees, watch deer in the muskeg...
  • CAUCASIAN OVCHARKA PUPPIES
    Strong loyal companions. Ready to protect your family and property. Proven against wolves and grizzlies. Imported bloodlines. Well socialized.
  • ENVIRONMENTAL GEOPHYSICS
    "More Data, Less Digging" Find groundwater and reduce excavation costs!