Reckoning with History: The Antiquities Act quandary

The law has created constant tension between the executive and legislative branches.

 

Reckoning with History is an ongoing series that seeks to understand the legacies of the past and to put the West’s present moment in perspective.

Writing to support the proposed U.S. Constitution in 1788, James Madison famously said, “If men were angels, no government would be necessary.” These words of wisdom come from The Federalist, No. 51, where Madison promised Americans that three branches of government would keep each other in check and prevent the concentration and misuse of power. Madison believed that he was articulating a universal principle, but history suggests that angels and demons are a matter of perspective. Consider the Antiquities Act, so much in the news recently. President Donald Trump believes that previous executives abused this law and that it’s mainly a ploy to give “a small handful of very distant bureaucrats” control over local landscapes.

In 1906, Congress authorized the president to protect “objects of historic or scientific interest” on public lands. The Antiquities Act was specifically designed to stop the theft and destruction of Native American artifacts by pot hunters and vandals, because Congress recognized that a significant part of the nation’s public heritage — the material relics of the continent’s human history — was at risk. Just as important as the law’s purpose was its procedures. The Antiquities Act gave proclamation power to the executive branch because the legislative process is designed to be slow-moving. A sense of urgency spurred the designation of most monuments; historically, presidents have protected places facing immediate threats just in time. The act is designed to allow presidents to save endangered artifacts with a certain amount of expediency, a pace and process that the law’s opponents resent.

In 1943, for example, President Franklin Roosevelt created Jackson Hole National Monument in Wyoming (the same state where Theodore Roosevelt established the first monument, at Devils Tower, in 1906). The Jackson Hole monument connected lowlands to Grand Teton National Park to preserve public access and open space, something Wyoming politicians had blocked in 1938. John D. Rockefeller bought up thousands of private acres in the Snake River Valley and offered them to the federal government. Roosevelt accepted Rockefeller’s gift and added a sizeable chunk from the Grand Teton National Forest to create a 221,610-acre national monument.

Angered by presidential proclamation that turned some Jackson Hole land into a National Monument, Wyoming ranchers drove their cattle across the area in 1943.
AP Photo

Previously, there had been little opposition to the Antiquities Act, but this use of executive power provoked anger. The Forest Service felt robbed; ranchers felt threatened; Wyoming politicians felt betrayed. One senator, Edward Robertson, compared the designation to the attack on Pearl Harbor. Local ranchers defied the National Park Service by driving cattle across the range. Wyoming’s sole U.S. representative, Frank Barrett, crusaded against the new monument, introducing legislation to eliminate it and later holding hearings to undermine not only the Jackson Hole monument, but federal conservation in general, Bernard DeVoto wrote in Harper’s.

Meanwhile, the challenge to executive power moved from politicians and periodicals to the courts. In May 1943, not even two full months after Roosevelt’s proclamation, the state of Wyoming sued the superintendent of Grand Teton National Park, arguing that, among other things, Jackson Hole had nothing of historic or scientific interest, a charge reminiscent of some claims today about both Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments. When the judge ruled, he avoided the topic of the area’s merits, as presented by the Park Service and Wyoming, simply noting that since Congress authorized the executive branch to protect land, it would be up to Congress to de-authorize it.

The episode brought the Park Service negative publicity and eroded congressional and Western governors’ support of the Antiquities Act. After years of concentrated executive power during the Great Depression and World War II, Congress reasserted its strength. Efforts to repeal the act failed, but in 1950 Congress passed legislation that absorbed Jackson Hole National Monument into a larger Grand Teton National Park — with a provision that prevented future presidents from using the Antiquities Act in Wyoming.

Three decades later, Congress clipped the president’s wings again, this time in Alaska. When Alaska achieved statehood in 1958, the state and federal governments were forced to reckon with the new state’s vast public domain. The 1971 Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act resolved Indigenous claims and obligated the secretary of the Interior to withdraw public land for the purpose of creating national parks, forests and refuges, as well as wild and scenic rivers. Congress was required to act within five years. Interior Secretary Rogers C. B. Morton sent his recommendations to Congress in 1973, but the legislative body mostly ignored the issue until 1977, only a year before the deadline. So President Jimmy Carter and his Interior secretary, Cecil D. Andrus, grabbed the reins. Citing Congress’ failure to act, Andrus advised Carter to use the Antiquities Act to protect 56 million acres of public land across Alaska. So audacious was the scale, the president asked Andrus, “Can I do that?” Andrus assured him that he could, and they went on to designate Misty Fjords, Gates of the Artic, Wrangell-St. Elias and more national monuments.

Andrus viewed Carter’s use of the Antiquities Act as “an absolutely vital tool” to protect land while forcing the legislative process forward. Congress soon passed the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act, in 1980, a law that confirmed most of Carter’s national monument designations. More important for the future, ANILCA required further executive withdrawals greater than 5,000 acres to have explicit approval by Congress, an effective brake on the Antiquities Act.

“Ambition must be made to counteract ambition,” Madison wrote to explain balancing branches of government. “In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.” Congress did this for Alaska and Wyoming, but its monumental inability to legislate on environmental matters today has created a surge in the use of executive power, which fills the vacuum left by congressional gridlock. And this produces uncertainty, both for local land users and our system of government. While the balance of powers has been fundamental to American democracy, the practice of one president rescinding the monuments of another is surely not the system Madison intended to create.

Adam M. Sowards is an environmental historian, professor, and writer. He lives in Pullman, Washington.

High Country News Classifieds
  • CLIMATE JUSTICE FELLOW
    High Country News, an award-winning magazine covering the communities and environment of the Western United States, seeks applicants for a climate justice fellowship. The fellowship...
  • VIRGINIA SPENCER DAVIS FELLOWSHIP
    High Country News, an award-winning magazine covering the communities and environment of the Western United States, is offering a fellowship for early-career journalists interested in...
  • COLORADO WILD PUBLIC LANDS VIDEO CONTEST
    Please submit your video of 30 seconds or less, taken on public lands, to [email protected] by May 15th for a chance to win in one...
  • WMAN NETWORK COORDINATOR
    WESTERN MINING ACTION NETWORK (WMAN) CONTRACT OPPORTUNITY CLOSING DATE: Feb. 19, 2021 WMAN is seeking a team member to coordinate the various network activities to...
  • FRIENDS OF THE INYO IS HIRING TRAIL AMBASSADORS FOR THE SUMMER OF 2021
    Friends of the Inyo's Trail Ambassadors (TAs) support the Inyo, Sierra, & Humboldt-Toiyabe National Forests and other partners by providing positive public service, outreach, interpretation,...
  • LAND & CABIN ON CO/ UT LINE
    18 ac w/small solar ready cabin. Off grid, no well. Great RV location. Surrounded by state wildlife area and nat'l parks.
  • MANAGER PERMACULTURE LANDSCAPE CONTRACTOR
    Permaculture / Landscape Company Manager / Site Lead Red Ant Works, Inc. - 20+ year landscape construction and horticultural care company seeks manager and site...
  • CANYONLANDS FIELD INSTITUTE
    Field seminars for adults in natural and human history of the Colorado Plateau with lodge, river trip and base camp options. Small groups, guest experts.
  • COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER
    San Juan Citizens Alliance is looking for a passionate, dynamic, organized, and technology-savvy communications professional to help grow our membership and presence in the Four...
  • ENERGY AND CLIMATE PROGRAM ASSOCIATE
    San Juan Citizens Alliance seeks an Energy and Climate Program Associate to focus on public outreach, education and organizing to advance campaigns to mitigate climate...
  • REAL ESTATE SPECIALIST
    This position provides professional real estate services and is responsible for managing and completing real estate projects utilizing a project management database that is designed...
  • WILDFIRE MITIGATION SPECIALIST
    The Wildfire Mitigation Specialist is responsible for delivering wildfire risk mitigation information, recommendations and programmatic resources to wildland urban interface homeowners, community members and partners....
  • DEVELOPMENT POSITIONS
    Thorne Nature Experience is hiring for a Development Director and Senior Individual Giving Manager. Individuals will work collaboratively with Thorne's Executive Director to develop and...
  • SENIOR PROGRAM MANAGER, LANDSCAPE CONSERVATION & ENERGY
    The National Parks Conservation Association, a 100-year-old nonprofit advocacy organization and the nation's leading voice for national parks seeks a Senior Program Manager, Landscape Conservation...
  • BACKCOUNTRY AND FRONTCOUNTRY STEWARDSHIP CREW MEMBERS
    The San Juan Mountains Association (SJMA) is hiring a crew of ambassadors to work in partnership with the U.S. Forest Service to educate visitors on...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NATURAL HISTORY INSTITUTE
    The Executive Director is the chief executive officer of the Natural History Institute (NHI). The Executive Director has broad authority to lead and manage the...
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR AT FRIENDS OF CEDAR MESA
    - The Land, History, and People of the Bears Ears Region - The Bears Ears and Cedar Mesa region is one of the most beautiful,...
  • SENIOR DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATE
    Greater Yellowstone Coalition seeks a Senior Development Associate to coordinate the organization's individual giving program. The position description is available at http://greateryellowstone.org/careers Please email a...
  • TRAIL CREW TECHNICAL ADVISORS
    SEEKING TALENTED TRAIL CREWLEADERS The Pacific Crest Trail Association, headquartered in Sacramento, California ,is dedicated to protecting, preserving and promoting the Pacific Crest National Scenic...
  • WESTERN NATIVE SEED
    Native plant seeds for the Western US. Trees, shrubs, grasses, wildflowers and regional mixes. Call or email for free price list. 719-942-3935. [email protected] or visit...