Scalia was Supreme Court’s leader on limiting environmental rules

A conservative legal foundation fears its winning streak may be over.


During Justice Antonin Scalia’s tenure on the Supreme Court, a conservative California-based legal foundation had six straight victories on property rights and Clean Water Act cases. The decisions bolstered private property owners’ ability to develop their land and restricted federal authority to protect waters and wetlands from being polluted or filled in. In the Pacific Legal Foundation’s biggest wins, the justices were split, 5-4 or 4-1-4. Scalia’s vote was essential for the firm’s favorable outcomes. With Scalia’s death last weekend, the Pacific Legal Foundation lost a powerful ally who showed deep enthusiasm for their cases, and who often took the role of writing the court’s decisions in their favor. “I do think it’s less likely that the Court will adopt additional restrictions” on the Clean Water Act, says Damien Schiff, a lawyer for the Pacific Legal Foundation

Former Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.
U.S. Supreme Court
Scholars say Pacific Legal Foundation is justifiably concerned. “If you lose Scalia, there’s nothing subtle about that change,” says Richard Lazarus, a Harvard Law School professor and expert in environmental and natural resource law and the Supreme Court. Scalia was deeply skeptical about a broad interpretation of the Clean Water Act and greatly concerned about private property rights. “There was no one more forceful than Justice Scalia; a very powerful voice is now missing from the bench,” Lazarus adds.  

In his opinion in the 2006 Clean Water Act case known as Rapanos, one of the Pacific Legal Foundation’s biggest triumphs, Scalia criticized “the immense expansion of federal regulation of land use that has occurred under the Clean Water Act — without any change in the governing statute — during the past five Presidential administrations.”

Scalia’s death dims the Pacific Foundation's chances in a major environmental case on the horizon. The Supreme Court is expected to eventually review Obama’s Clean Water Rule, which has been stayed by a lower court. Significantly for the arid West, the rule would protect tributaries, no matter how frequently water flows in them, as well as some wetlands, ponds and ditches. "With Justice Scalia’s departure, it’s fair to say it’s more likely to be upheld," Schiff says. “The impacts will be principally in the West. It’s precisely in the areas that are dry most of the year that you have the most significant disputes about the Clean Water Act.”

The first test of the impact of Scalia’s absence on a Pacific Legal Foundation case may come even sooner. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers v. Hawkes Co. Inc. is scheduled for oral arguments next month. At issue is whether a company that mines peat moss in Minnesota can challenge the Corps of Engineers’ decision that wetlands on the company’s property are protected under the Clean Water Act. Schiff says he’s confident that even the current composition of the court will rule in Hawkes’ favor. Although that case centers on a dispute in Minnesota, the decision could have broad ramifications, especially in the West.

Harvard's Richard Lazarus says without Scalia on the court, Schiff may be disappointed. Even if the justices are divided on the case 4-4, they may decide to hold it until they have a ninth Justice.

Of course, it’s not at all clear how Scalia’s replacement will be decided. Obama has promised to nominate one, but the Senate must confirm any new justice, and some Republicans have said the decision should be left to the next president.

If Obama or a Democratic successor names a Scalia replacement, that new justice likely would be more sympathetic to a broader view of the Clean Water Act to place stricter protections on waterways and wetlands. That could mean that not only would the rule be upheld, but the Court could start siding with environmentalists who believe protections should go even further.

Scalia’s death also could have big implications for the Clean Power Plan, which Lazarus calls the “single most important environmental regulation ever.” The plan requires states to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the electricity sector by about 32 percent by 2030. Just days before his death, Scalia provided one of the five votes necessary for the court to stay the rule. It was extraordinary for the Supreme Court to block a rule even before a lower court heard arguments on it. Without Scalia, the prospects that the rule will survive judicial review have improved significantly.

Scalia’s enthusiasm for environmental and property rights cases made the Supreme Court much more likely to take them up. Stanford University Law Professor Deborah Sivas recalls that 20 years ago, the Supreme Court was not very interested in environmental cases and instead deferred to federal agencies. That changed during Scalia’s nearly 20 years on the bench in large part because of his fervor. “Not only have they taken up a lot of cases, they’ve really gotten into the minutiae of the Clean Water Act and the Clean Air Act, and to a fair extent that was driven by Justice Scalia’s interest in playing around in that field,” says Sivas. Going forward, Sivas predicts the court will be less interested and take fewer cases.

Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonin Scalia testifies before the House Judiciary Committee's Commercial and Administrative Law Subcommittee on Capitol Hill May 20, 2010 in Washington, DC
Stephen Masker CC/Flickr

It wasn’t just environmental rules that Scalia scrutinized to see if the executive branch was overstepping its authority, but all sorts of executive decisions. The court is scheduled to hear arguments in April over Obama administration moves to stop the deportation of several million undocumented immigrants, largely parents of citizens or legal residents, and offer them a way to stay and get work permits. Scalia would have set a high bar to ensure the administration followed all proper procedures and didn’t usurp congressional power. Scalia’s death “could alter the calculus for all of those cases, because they too, often were very closely divided,” says Amanda Tyler, a University of California Berkley School of Law professor.

Scalia’s absence also makes it much less likely that the Supreme Court will decide against the California Teachers’ Union in a case the court already heard but has not yet decided. During oral arguments, Scalia seemed to side with the conservative majority for what looked likely to be a 5-4 decision to stop public unions from collecting fees from nonmembers. “It would have crippled the ability of unions to function because they’ve got to be reimbursed in some way,” says Stanford Law professor William Gould, a former chairman of the National Labor Relations Board.

As for the Pacific Legal Foundation, Schiff says his group is working on new strategies to come up with cases that will be attractive to a Supreme Court without Scalia.

Elizabeth Shogren is HCN's DC Correspondent.

High Country News Classifieds
    THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY is seeking a Community Conservation Specialist, for the Crown of the Continent DEPARTMENT: Conservation CLASSIFICATION: Grade 6 Specialist/Representative (Low of $54K) REPORTS...
    About The Organization Building community through fresh vegetables is at the heart of the Sisters-based non-profit, Seed to Table Oregon. Based on a four-acre diversified...
    CARPENTER WANTED. Come to Ketchikan and check out the Rainforest on the coast, Hike the shorelines, hug the big trees, watch deer in the muskeg...
    VARD is seeking an Executive Director to lead a small legal & planning staff dedicated to the health and sustainability of Teton Valley Idaho and...
    Based in Tucson or Sierra Vista, AZ., the Upper San Pedro Project Manager develops, manages, and advances freshwater conservation programs, plans, and methods focusing on...
    Southeast Alaska Conservation is hiring. Visit for info. 907-586-6942 [email protected]
    The Blackfoot Challenge, located in Ovando, MT, seeks a self-motivated, detail-oriented individual to conduct bookkeeping, financial analysis and reporting, and grant oversight and management. Competitive...
    A once in a lifetime opportunity to live and run a business on the shore of one of the most beautiful lakes in SW Montana....
    High Country News is seeking a Contributing Editor for Books, Culture and Commentary to assign and edit inquisitive, inspiring, and thought-provoking content for HCN in...
    ABOUT US Better Wyoming is a nonprofit, nonpartisan advocacy organization that educates, organizes, and mobilizes Wyoming residents on behalf of statewide change. Learn more at...
    TwispWorks is a 501(c)3 that promotes economic and cultural vitality in the mountainous Methow Valley, the eastern gateway to North Cascades National Park in Washington...
    Location: Helena, Montana Type: Permanent, full time after 1-year probationary period. Reports to: Director of Policy and Legislative Affairs. Travel: Some overnight travel, both in-state...
    Custom Geospatial Solutions is available for all of your GIS needs. Affordable, flexible and accurate data visualization and analysis for any sized project.
    Restore Hetch Hetchy, a 501 (c)(3) nonprofit organization, seeks experienced development professional to identify and engage individuals and institutions who are inspired to help underwrite...
    The successful candidate will be the organization's lead counsel on public lands issues, including reviewing federal administrative actions and proposed policy and helping to shape...
    Solar Energy International (SEI) is a 501(c)3 non-profit education organization with a mission to provide industry-leading technical training and expertise in renewable energy to empower...
    This is a full-time position based out of our Paonia office. This position is responsible for organizing all of Solar Energy International's renewable energy trainings....
    NEW BOOK showcases 70 national monuments across the western United States. Use "Guide10" for 10% off at
    40 acres: 110 miles from Tucson: native trees, grasses: birder's heaven::dark sky/ borders state lease & National forest/5100 ft/13-16 per annum rain
    "More Data, Less Digging" Find groundwater and reduce excavation costs!