GRAND CANYON NATIONAL PARK - As thunder rumbled in
the distance and a hawk wheeled overhead, Grand Canyon Park
Superintendent Rob Arnberger stood on the canyon's rim and stared
into a bank of television cameras.
He said what
a year ago he doubted he would ever get to tell the world: "Today
we are saying "no more." Today marks the first step in a long
journey to put those words into practice. The eyes of the world are
not upon us, but on what we are here to protect."
The occasion was the June 10 announcement, by a
Western commission of governors, Indian tribes and their advisors,
of a strategy to restore clean air over the 16 national parks and
wilderness areas of the Colorado Plateau.
Many
here, including utility executives, conservationists and county
commissioners, called the promise "historic."
"I
was not always sure this would succeed," admitted Felicia Marcus,
senior EPA official. "This is a new way." She was not alone in her
doubts, which began five years ago when Congress created a regional
air quality commission of Westerners and told it to find a solution
to the manmade pollution that sullied the air. But on this day she
was full of hope.
Highlights of the proposed
air-quality cleanup blueprint include:
* An
agreement by 17 electric power companies on the Colorado Plateau to
slash sulfur stack emissions by 50 to 70 percent by 2040. If they
do not cut these emissions 13 percent by the year 2000, mandatory
caps will be enforced, although companies can buy and sell
pollution credits to bring themselves into
compliance;
* Accelerated studies will begin at
Southern California Edison's coal-fired Mojave Power Plant, 50
miles upwind of Grand Canyon, to determine whether emission
"scrubbers' similar to those being installed at the Navajo
Generating Station should be installed;
*
Incentives, similar to those offered in the 1980s, will be
reinstated to builders of energy-efficient
buildings;
* Renewable energy sources for power
production will be supported;
* Low-emission
vehicle standards, starting in 2001, will be supported on a
nationwide basis.
* Clean-fuel demonstration
zones will be established;
* Standards for
heavy-duty vehicles will be developed;
*
Engine-emission regulations for new off-road vehicles will be
supported.
Utah Gov. Mike Leavitt said the pact
"shows that we in the West can develop solutions without
prescriptive dictates from Washington. What we have is a balance of
Western interests working on a Western problem."
Yet Rob Smith, the Sierra Club's representative
in the Southwest, said the agreement was remarkable for
demonstrating the willingness of some Westerners to set up and
follow regulations, in this case by the Environmental Protection
Agency.
The commission's strong stance toward
reducing air pollution would not have been predicted last fall.
What seemed to move members in the final days of intense
deliberation were the hundreds of oral and written comments from
private citizens, businesses and local governments, said Bill
Auberle, chairman of the commission's Public Advisory
Committee.
After reading letters from the public,
he said, "We revised several sections of the report, including
proposals for preventing pollution and reducing emissions at large
industrial facilities."
Ambitious as the plan
is, some Westerners are disappointed that there was no directive to
the huge coal-fired power plant owned by Southern California Edison
in Laughlin, Nev., one of the largest polluters upwind of Grand
Canyon. The problem of major smelters in Mexico was also not
addressed.
Recommendations of the Grand Canyon
Visibility Transport Commission now go to the EPA, which has 18
months to write regulations. The recommendations are available from
the Western Governors' Association. Call 800/659-5858 for a copy.
* James Bishop
Jr.
James Bishop writes in
Sedona, Arizona.






