Ranchers like the new bill and its emphasis on cooperation with land managers, says Ken Spann, a Colorado rancher who chairs the National Cattlemen's Association federal lands committee. To most non-ranchers, the revision is little more than a paint job.
"Domenici's attitude that "it's the rancher's land" is still reflected in this bill," says Cathy Carlson, public lands specialist for the National Wildlife Federation in Boulder, Colo.
The bill continues to exclude conservationists from grazing advisory councils, and it withholds grazing permits from people outside of the livestock industry, making it "totally inadequate" in terms of involving the public in land management decisions, says Steve Moyer, staffer with Trout Unlimited. The revised bill also limits the extent to which land managers can use the National Environmental Policy Act to review management plans, and it prevents federal agencies from mandating minimum water flows through public streams.
- Mark DeGregorio on Meet the aspiring ranger locked out by National Park Service practices
- Lael Bradshaw on New documentary offers a sharp look at the West’s water crisis
- Steve Snyder on Why has the National Park Service gotten whiter?
- Jim Schumont on Stop the rock-stacking
- Kate Schimel on Biking bill is a smokescreen for opening up wilderness