Idaho's Sewer System

Subscription Preview

This article by Richard Manning first appeared in the August 04, 2014 issue of High Country News.

To read the full article, you must log in or subscribe. Enter your email address:

Idaho’s sewer system is the Snake River

As Big Ag flourishes, this massive waterway suffers.

Begin where the Snake River begins, as crystal-clear, clean water on the calderas of the Yellowstone Plateau, on the edge of the vibrant national park. In late spring, the largest tributary in the headwaters, the Henry's Fork of the Snake River, is still locked in a head-high layer of snowpack. On wind-blown ridges rimming the water, hundreds of elk graze under the late morning sun. A-frames and log cabins hibernate, boarded and silent, awaiting the summer arrival of the fly fishers who treasure this place. Everything appears at peace and as it should be.

But for those who know what to look for, a less pristine reality is evident, even here in the river system's headwaters. It's represented by the 7,000-acre Island Park Reservoir on the Henry's Fork, built in 1938 to benefit farmers downhill from here by holding back and controlling the flow for irrigation diversions. This repurposing of the water becomes obvious 20 miles south of Island Park, where the plateau tips to deliver the Henry's Fork to the Snake River Plain, a rapid descent from the residue of a high-elevation winter to a more recognizable spring, from the postcard Idaho to the real Idaho, from what was to what is.

From here on, the Snake, to use the euphemism of record, becomes a "working river" – wholly subservient to agriculture. There are many ways to describe how a river system gets harnessed to ag, but we'll begin with the most basic, the dams and reservoirs. The Snake's drainage is interrupted by no fewer than 23 large dams that form reservoirs, and there are many smaller dams that divert water for irrigation without stalling the river's flow. The reservoirs impound about half of the river's 1,078 miles. None of this is news; we began damming this river – the largest tributary of the Columbia – more than a hundred years ago, and the dams were only the first step in the creation of one of the world's largest concentrations of industrialized agriculture.

Sample Gallery

Included in this article

Snake River map Snake River map

Comments about this article

Jan Weber Subscriber
Aug 04, 2014 03:23 PM
On first glance, I thought the title might be more attention-grabbing hyperbole than reality. Then I read the article. Having done over a decade's work, mostly in the midwest, of documenting the effects of industrial farming on the land, the environment, small & midsized farms, and farmers & their communities, I see a familiar story best summed up in the title of my first project: As We Sow.....This article is the answer to that biblical mantra.
James Nelson Subscriber
Aug 06, 2014 07:09 AM
Well-done article. But please note that nitrogen is a gas and is not a water pollutant or toxic. The problem in water is nitrate, not nitrogen. Also the chemical reaction that renders mercury organic is methylation, not methylization.

From our friends

HCN in the outhouses of the West

From my Alaska trip: I flew into a small town that is not reachable by road, then hopped on a motorboat and drove across lakes and rivers for 2.5 hours to reach the scientists' camp way out in the boondocks -- out there they have a few rough cabins and a generator that makes electricity only in the evening and two outhouses -- and lo and behold, for reading material in the outhouses they have issues of the Economist magazines and HCN -- amazing to discover HCN readers way out there!

Ray Ring, HCN Senior Editor

Sweet-talk from a loyal reader:

"I have been a loyal reader ever since the famous/infamous roadkill issue, years back. I just wanted to note that I regard HCN as the finest magazine I have ever read in my life and it keeps being so."

Tim Kingston, California