You are here: home   Issues   Innovate   Tough choices
Topic: Culture & Communities     Department: Letters

Tough choices

Document Actions

The Feb. 16 issue manages to spotlight the "I want"/"I don't want" schizophrenia of many who claim to love the environment. First, the article "Wind setbacks": How can some of you look in the mirror after expressing rabid support for alternative energy sources like wind, if you insist that the turbines that generate the energy aren't too close to your property line and don't disrupt your viewshed? It doesn't work that way; to get, you need to give. Would you rather have a wind farm a mile from your house, or a coal-fired plant over the horizon that acidifies your rain? We all should be welcoming alternative-energy sources to our part of the world, instead of making it impossible for such sources to find sufficient room to contribute significantly to our energy portfolio.

And second -- yet another letter criticizing Yucca Mountain as the proposed repository for disposal of high-level radioactive waste. Well, let's see. ... You don't want global warming, you don't want nuclear power, and the U.S. cannot be powered entirely by alternative-energy sources. Choices are to be made, it appears. More people are killed on the highways every year than would ever die as a result of radioactive material that might be released from Yucca Mountain, even in a catastrophic eruption. Yucca Mountain would not be perfect, but perhaps you might not spend so much energy fighting it if you objectively weigh your alternatives. Clean nuclear power, with a small (yes, small) risk from the resulting waste, or carbon dioxide-generating power generation? You can't say "neither," if all of us are going to maintain the lifestyle to which we have become accustomed.

Fran Nimick
Edgewood, New Mexico


Nuclear is Not the Answer
Nunya Asunto
Nunya Asunto
Mar 28, 2009 03:19 PM
Nuclear power is not clean. The green washing of the nuke industry in this century is one of the most amazing feats of public disinformation I have ever witnessed. Any energy source that produces dangerous and polluting WASTE, is not clean. The uranium mining industry has a wretched history of environmental, public health, and human rights disasters. No, nuclear is not clean. Not when the environment is destroyed, people are made sick, and indigenous communities in Niger and the U.S. are displaced by the production of the fuel for these reactors.

Nuclear is not an economically feasible solution to climate change. A nuclear reactor has not been built in the U.S. for decades. That is because it is just too expensive. The nuclear industry relies heavily on tax payer money just to remain competitive. The nuclear industry has had the time to develop competitive technologies and has simply failed to create a product that can survive in an open market. Rather than bailing the nuclear industry out, it should be left to the market to decide. The full cost of nuclear, considering the whole fuel cycle is so mind boggling it is hardly understood by scientists. Energy Secretary Chu openly admitted that he didn't understand the full cost of nuclear. The amount of new reactors that would need to be built is one every couple of years to even come close to offsetting carbon emissions. The cost to do that would be enormous and I don't know of a single developer that even has the capacity of funding to do that kind of thing. If the government and private industry were to start throwing the amount of money it wastes on nuclear research and development at Truly clean, renewable, and sustainable forms of energy we could overcome this problem. A country free of carbon and nuclear is attainable.

Email Newsletter

The West in your Inbox

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Follow our RSS feeds!
  1. Trappers catch a lot more than wolves | Mountain lions, eagles, bobcats, geese and domesti...
  2. In the field with a Montana couple hunting wolves | Amid bitter controversy over allowing hunters and ...
  3. Seeking balance in Oregon's timber country | Can logging towns and old-growth forests both thri...
  4. (Still) getting the lead out | When will hunters stop poisoning condors with ammu...
  5. Rants from the hill: Trapping the bees | What to do when 50,000 honeybees hive up inside th...
  1. Don't mess with the Forest Service | How a determined and feisty Forest Service held of...
  2. Sacrificial Land: Will renewable energy devour the Mojave Desert? | An unlikely group of activists is championing a ne...
  3. California's carbon market may succeed where others have failed | The Golden State's new cap-and-trade program aims ...
  4. How right-wing emigrants conquered North Idaho | Conservative transplants largely from California h...
  5. The Forest Service battles placer mining with an obscure law | A little-known 1955 law gives the Forest Service a...
Subscriber Alert
HCN Classifieds
More from Culture & Communities
Have a ponytail? Watch out for owls! And more oddities from Heard Around the West
A lesson from a pig called Eddie The author learns to eat meat responsibly
A tireless documenter of Native America: A review of "Short Nights of the Shadow Catcher" Timothy Egan on the life and work of photographer Edward Curtis
All Culture & Communities
 
© 2013 High Country News, all rights reserved. | privacy policy | terms of use | powered by Plone | site by Groundwire | design by Ryan Foster

HCN Logo High Country News in your inbox!


Sign up now to receive our weekly email newsletter!

• The best weekly collection of Western environmental news

• An at-a-glance look at our latest news and analysis


This box was designed to only appear once. It uses a "cookie" (a small file stored on your computer) to remember that it has shown the box to you.

If you are seeing this box appear multiple times, then something is not allowing the cookie to be stored properly. Browsers can be set to not allow cookies, and some people choose to disallow cookies for security reasons. If your browser is setup this way, please consider adding "www.hcn.org" as an exception to your no-cookies rule. For information about how to do this, just search the Web for "browser cookie exceptions."

If you're sure this isn't the problem, then it could be related to how your browser has stored information from our site in previous visits. Browsers often "cache" images, text and other website content in order to make them appear faster if you ever go back. Sometimes the browser's cache can be corrupted or become outdated. The simplest fix for this is to try reloading the page. If that doesn't fix the problem, it may be necessary to clear your temporary items from your browser. Again, a web search will provide you with lots of options and instructions.

Either way, we're sorry to hear that this box is getting in the way of your enjoyment of the HCN website. If you continue to have trouble, please contact our Subscriber Services team.