Personal tools
You are here: home   Issues   The Half-life of Memory   Culture and family
 

Culture and family

Letter to the Editor - From the February 16, 2009 issue of High Country News by Manuel Carranza

Besides being a way to ensure that only Indians got the pitiful and paltry benefits that the federal government was giving to the Natives they made treaties with, blood quantum was an insidious way of permanently removing the land and memory of a people (HCN, 1/19/09).

What has happened to many Native families is a tragedy. To be told you are no longer native because you fail a minimum blood quantum must be heartbreaking, and it's totally false. Many Eurasian peoples moved and interbred over centuries of war, conquest, migration and political alliance. They were who they were by culture, ethnicity and nationality. It was kinship, family and self-declaration that made them Hungarian (East Europeans mixed with Mongol), Spanish (Celts, Iberians mixed with African and Arabian) or Italian (Mediterranean diaspora).

Many tribes have rid themselves of the blood quantum system while others have reinstituted it because of casino greed. No matter how you look at it, blood quantum is about exclusion when times are good and inclusion when times are bad. If money and benefits abound, the rolls are restricted so it can't be shared.

Blood quantum is especially cogent to my situation. I am Mexican (part indigenous/part European) and although I look completely Native, I have to prove my heritage. Natives are Natives by culture and family, not solely by blood. If you don't believe me, try looking into the eyes of your blond-haired niece and telling her she is not part of you and your heritage.

Manuel Carranza

  1. Roadless-less | Judge Clarence Brimmer is determined to bring down...
  2. Commitment issues | White House pledges further collaboration with tri...
  3. Can't see the forest for the skyscrapers | The nation's capital gets stimulus funds to fight ...
  4. "A deeply troubled idea from the start" | Valles Caldera's experiment in public lands manage...
  5. Frack 2, Scene 1 | New York City fights drilling in its watershed, an...
  1. Roadless-less | Judge Clarence Brimmer is determined to bring down...
  2. Socialism and the West | Despite our reflexive fear of the word "socialism,...
  3. The Lost Art of Listening | Can the Arapaho language be saved from extinction?...
  4. Return of the pod man | Arizona farmer Mark Moody raises mesquite trees fo...
  5. Is the BLM practicing unsafe CX? | The Bureau of Land Management used a large number ...

JOIN THE High CountryEmail Commons

Award-winning content delivered weekly.

RSS FEEDS

Keep in touch! Find us on Facebook & Twitter
More from Culture & Communities
A ride on the Big Love bus Polygamy tours begin in Utah.
Reader Photo - Cowboy Up A classic Western image, in black and white
The Eastern Frontier New York City is really the West, buried under time's wrapping.
All Culture & Communities
 
© 2009 High Country News, all rights reserved. | privacy policy | powered by Plone | site by Groundwire and Web Collective | design by our very own Ryan Foster