Underground movement

In northern Colorado, newcomers to the area lead the charge against planned uranium mining

  • Robin Davis on the northern Colorado property she and her husband bought with a plan to board horses and open a riding school. Now the couple worries that uranium mining will cover their land with wells and pipelines and contaminate their water

    KEVIN MOLONEY
  • Exploratory drilling near Nunn, Colorado, where Powertech wants to mine for uranium

    COURTESY COLORADOANS AGAINST RESOURCE DESTRUCTION
  • Sleepy Nunn, Colorado, with its watertower slogan "Watch Nunn Grow." Opponents of uranium mining planned for the area suggest a new slogan, "Watch Nunn Glow."

    KEVIN MOLONEY
 

Updated Sept. 28, 2007

NUNN, COLORADO 

Early last year, Robin and Jay Davis bought 80 acres of rolling prairie in north-central Colorado. As is often the case in Western states, the "split estate" property included only the surface rights, not the rights to any minerals that might lie beneath the land. So before they signed the deal, the couple carefully researched potential mineral development. "We looked into oil, gas and coal," Robin Davis says. "Even diamonds." Deciding that the risk was negligible, they bought the land, planning to board horses and open a riding school. 

Then, last fall, a Canadian-owned energy company informed the Davises and their neighbors that it wanted to extract not coal or natural gas, but uranium from beneath their property. "When we got a letter about it, we thought it was a joke," Robin Davis says. "Uranium mining? Here? Yeah, right." 

But Powertech (USA) Inc. is serious. The company recently bought 5,760 acres of mineral rights near the high-tech mecca of Fort Collins. Powertech hopes to extract about 8 million pounds of uranium, worth nearly $700 million at current market prices, mostly through in-situ recovery, which involves injecting a solution underground to dissolve uranium. 

In-situ uranium projects are on tap for other places in the West as well, including New Mexico, and Powertech is exploring for uranium in South Dakota and Wyoming. But in many ways, Powertech's Colorado proposal is different. The West's uranium mining has historically taken place in sparsely settled deserts, not near booming urban centers. Affected residents have been mostly poor and rural, and opposition has often been slow to develop. About 300,000 people live within 30 miles of Powertech's proposed operations; Weld County, in which the project is located, is one of the 50 fastest-growing counties in the nation. Universities and computer companies in Fort Collins and nearby Greeley have attracted well-educated academics and scientists, some of whom own homes and land near the project site, and they've organized a robust grassroots resistance. 

Their biggest fear? Contamination of the area's groundwater. Powertech plans to drill deep into an aquifer that supplies local homes and farms. In-situ processing, say critics, could do more than just ravage the surface of the land: It could permanently taint groundwater with heavy metals and radioactivity. "We can live without a lot of things," says Robin Davis, "but water is not one of them." 

The countryside around Powertech's planned operation is mostly shortgrass prairie, dotted with sagebrush and golden blooms of rabbitbrush. Swainson's hawks soar overhead; meadowlarks and red-winged blackbirds perch on fenceposts. A few old farmhouses stand amid corn and wheat fields, but most of the homes are new, tidy and moderately sized, on 40- to 80-acre plots. The occasional fencerow, house or pickup sports a bright yellow sign with a black radiation symbol and the words "No Uranium Mining in Colorado. www.nunnglow.com." (The closest town is the farming hamlet of Nunn, whose water tower displays the slogan "Watch Nunn Grow." Opponents have suggested changing the last word to "Glow.") 

Powertech's project would be the first use of in-situ extraction techniques in Colorado, beyond a few tests in the 1970s, and the state is scrambling to get up to speed before Powertech submits permit applications in late 2008. 

The company is also considering some open-pit mining, but the geology of the Nunn area is mostly suited to in-situ recovery. Many of the uranium ore deposits lie beneath the water table in sandstone and are confined above and below by impermeable mudstone. Workers would drill a grid of wells 50 to 150 feet apart and pipe a sodium bicarbonate solution into the underground ore. The alkaline solution dissolves the uranium, and is then pumped to the surface and piped to a mobile processing facility. The pure uranium adheres to resin beads, which are trucked to a mill. Then the uranium is stripped off and processed into "yellowcake," the raw material for the fuel rods used in nuclear power plants. 

In groundwater, the sodium bicarbonate solution dissolves not only uranium, but also heavy metals such as molybdenum and selenium. Uranium can cause kidney problems and increase cancer risk. In minute doses, molybdenum and selenium are essential nutrients. In higher amounts, molybdenum can cause joint pain and liver dysfunction in humans and birth defects in animals. Selenium can damage the nervous system, and in livestock it can cause reproductive failure and "blind staggers," marked by impaired vision, aimless wandering and even paralysis. 

Although in-situ recovery is more economical and safer than traditional open-pit mining, it "tend(s) to contaminate the groundwater," according to a Nuclear Regulatory Commission report. That's why the government will not permit in-situ projects in drinking water aquifers. Powertech plans to drill into the Laramie-Fox Hills aquifer, which supplies local drinking and irrigation water. The company says that the portions of the Laramie-Fox Hills aquifer it wants to use are already unsafe for drinking due to high mineral levels. It plans to seek exemptions from the Environmental Protection Agency; the project can't proceed unless the agency officially declares those parts of the aquifer undrinkable. 

Even if Powertech gets exemptions, it still must prove that its operations won't cause lasting harm to any groundwater, drinkable or not. But that may not be easy: No in-situ uranium project has ever succeeded in restoring the surrounding groundwater to its original baseline condition. Last fall, the Corpus Christi Caller-Times examined 32 permits for south Texas in-situ projects, most closed in the '80s and '90s, and reported that none were able to meet all of the groundwater restoration goals in their original permits. Some met the specification for one mineral but found ten- and twenty-fold increases in others. 

In Wyoming and Nebraska, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission relaxed some restoration goals for in-situ well fields after the operations could not meet all of the water-quality standards specified in the original permits. "Those (lower) standards are still protective of human health and the environment," says William von Till, chief of the Uranium Recovery Licensing Branch. And, he adds, the relaxed standards applied only to the exempted portions of the aquifers. The drinkable water outside those areas remained safe: "We are not aware of any instance where in-situ uranium milling has impacted a water well user." 

The history of in-situ recovery, though, provides many examples of accidents and unexpected results: pump failures, breaks in underground pipes, wastewater pond failures, water movement within aquifers. "There are lots of problems associated with any well operation that could breach the integrity of an aquifer and spread contamination," says Eric Eidsness, a Reagan-era appointee to the EPA who was assistant administrator for water programs. "It just happens." 

neptunecity
neptunecity
Sep 28, 2007 08:17 PM

There is a long history of mining companies failing to adequately restore groundwater at numerous in-situ uranium mining projects in South Texas, many in populated areas.

Anonymous
Oct 02, 2007 11:19 AM

This Uranium mining will affect the whole state of Colorado. This company will go through two aquifers, and the aquifers start at the state line of Wyoming and goes to the city of Colorado Springs. No one really knows it is going on, so thanks for the coverage. Let's hope that people will realize what is going on before the water in the state is completely contaminated. The next thing we will be fighting for, after oil, is water. The reason this uranium is so valuable is because nuclear power companies are saying they are the new "green" power. Oh my god!! If you completely discount the digging of the uranium and the disposing of the uranium, it might be a stretch, but even then there are contaminants.

We need our water and a company based out of Canada should not be allowed to come in and leave us a mess when the price of uranium goes down and they can no longer afford to re-mediate the problems they will surely incur. This company has now bought additional leases in Eastern Colorado recently. We need to stop this mining. Everyone should write the congress critters and the Governor about these concerns. 

Susan Pennington/Windsor, Colorado

Anonymous
Oct 03, 2007 11:30 AM

The Federal-state-corporate collusion against local human rights (such as the right to clean earth, air, water) can only be fought on the local level -- counties, cities, towns, communities declaring that corporations have no inalienable right to profits, only the privilege to exist granted by the state and revocable if state laws are violated. Over 100 communities (surprisingly mostly Republican) in Pennsylvania are effectively organizing their rights against polluting corporations with the help of talented pro bono attorneys under the aegis of a national nonprofit organization (Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund) with the goal of US Supreme Court challenges. I would hope that the Colorado groups would contact this organization and join the effort to take back those Constitutional rights given only to human beings and that have been usurped by corporations: Website: www.celdf.org and email: info@celdf.org Lou Puls Boulder, Colorado

rjlaybourn
rjlaybourn
Oct 10, 2007 01:03 AM

Do you know what a NIMBY is? They are people not moved by the predicaments of others; global or otherwise. But they get worked up when it's 'their Back yard!'. 

Anonymous
Nov 19, 2007 11:35 AM

For more information, please visit www.powertechexposed.com

Jim Woodward, webmaster