The good and bad of peak-bagging

  • Steven Albert


"Above this memorable spot, the face of the mountain is ... a maze of yawning chasms and gullies, in the angles of which rise beetling crags and piles of detached boulders that seem to have been gotten ready to be launched below. But the strange influx of strength I had received seemed inexhaustible. I found a way without effort, and soon stood upon the topmost crag in the blessed light," John Muir wrote in The Mountains of California. That's right, nature-loving boys and girls: John Muir was a peak-bagger. 

Long celebrated for his founding of the modern environmental movement and his exuberant love for the small wonders of nature - "not a sparrow falls to the ground unnoted" - Muir is perhaps even more notable as a climber. 

His books and letters are filled with wild scrambles, first ascents that reveal him to be a serious peak-bagger, and frantic, non-stop marches to distant summits before night or thunderstorms closed in. According to a new biography by Graham White, Muir was "the greatest climber in America during the last quarter of the nineteenth century. He scaled dozens of remote peaks and achieved first ascents of Mt. Ritter and Mt. Whitney years before mountaineering existed as a sport ... in America." 

I was thinking about John Muir a few weeks ago while in the San Juan Mountains of southwest Colorado, where I climbed two 14,000-foot peaks, Redcloud and Sunshine. There are 69 "fourteeners" in the continental U.S. (54 of them in Colorado) and dozens of clubs and Web sites dedicated to the pursuit of climbing them. Mostly, I was thinking about the two very different ways to enjoy the mountains: peak-bagging vs. relaxation and solitude. I love both dearly and equally, as I would two children. And like two children, they rarely get along with each other. 

It's a guilty pleasure, peak-bagging. Among many backpackers, its practitioners have a reputation for being rude, condescending and not caring for any part of nature that isn't the highest ground. When I'm on a peak-bagging trip, I often just tell friends that I'm going "camping." 

STARTING AT FIRST LIGHT, I make it up Redcloud by 9 a.m. Sunshine Peak, at 14,001 feet the most modest fourteener, beckons a mile to the west, but it's already clouding up, and the forecast is thunderstorms. Absurdly, if Sunshine were just two feet lower, I would not attempt the climb. Clearly, the wise choice is a rapid descent. Instead, I run across the saddle, scramble to the top, and then descend as fast as I can, berating myself for stupidity but sky-high on adrenaline and endorphins. 

The mountains are different today than in John Muir's time, when climbing any mountain was always a solitary wilderness experience. Today, routes up all the fourteeners are like cattle trails. The trailheads get packed with cars, and the summits become more crowded than the mall - all while thousands of square miles of high country within plain sight remains untrodden. 

Ask a member of the "Fourteener Club" if he or she has ever summited Grizzly Peak, 13,988 feet, and you'll probably get a blank stare. 

In one respect, I'm glad the high peaks act as Gore-Tex magnets. On trips when I steer clear of the major peaks and trails, I know I can find oceans of empty country. Surrounded by "thirteeners," I won't see another soul and can lie back in an alpine meadow and watch the clouds sail over the high peaks. 

MANY YEARS AGO, I CLIMBED MOUNT RAINIER with two friends. But instead of the Muir route by which the long lines of roped and guided hikers ascend, we went up the Cowlitz Glacier, a more technical undertaking. We picked our way around crevasses in a vast, blue, black and white sculpture garden of ice, rock and snow. Except for the sound of our breathing and rhythmic, crunching footsteps, it was mostly silent. 

Back in our private world on the descent, I wanted to stop and sit, to burn a mental photo of the weird shapes. But the day was warming, and rock and ice were starting to break loose from the slope above. A few melon-sized boulders whizzed by. Without a word, we kept moving. 

Steven Albert is a wildlife biologist in Zuni, New Mexico.

Sep 05, 2007 04:22 PM

Peak bashing? 

Perhaps my mind is in a fog from lack of oxygen, but I fail to get the point of your article.  Yes, we're dismayed that the masses are overtaking the mountains but does berating "peak baggers" and asserting that you've found solidude on 13ers really helpful.  Over the past two decades, I have climbed many fourteeners in Colorado and California, ascending both technical (rock and ice) and non-technical routes.  I've ascended more than a few 3,000 foot walls in a day and hiked the Annapurna Circuit in Nepal.  I consider myself a climber and I also consider myself an environmentalist (I'm also a professional fisheries biologist).  While "many backpackers" might be correct in their assumptions about "many" climbers, we cannot be lumped easily into the "rude" and uncaring categories.  And, it is a mischacterization to state that "routes up all the fourteeners are like cattle trails" and a gross exageration to state that "summits are more crowded than malls".  Not even Long's Peak on Labor Day weekend fits that description.  While I cannot guarantee that you'll find it relaxing, solitude can be had quite easily on Colorado fourteeners if you simply avoid Summer Holidays or, on some peaks, avoid Summer weekends altogether!  Want solitude?  Try San Luis, Mt. Lindsey or even Crestone Peak in October.  I can assure that even the famous Mt. Elbert or Long's Peak are not crowded in early May.  I can also tell you from experience that one need not try very hard to find relaxation AND solitude if one knows where, and when, to look.  I've been alone on high peaks more often than not and have not experienced any of the crowds you describe on 14ers.  My advice is: Put away your low top, peak-bagging trail runners and grab your mountaineering boots, crampons, ice axe and your helmet and give me a call come October!

You are both correct
Eric Willhite
Eric Willhite
Apr 10, 2009 02:15 AM
I thought this article was well done and quite funny. Yes, there are some serious exaggerations and I would have to agree with everything in the first response. I didn’t seem to take it as personal and I’m about as obsessive about peakbagging as you can get. Unfortunately, there is a bit of truth in each exaggeration.