Start with the Rocky Flats plant history. Indeed, there were devastating fires. To the best of my understanding, no plutonium contamination outside the facility boundary resulted from any of them. Yes, workers were exposed to hazardous materials; undoubtedly, some of them became ill in consequence. Is there any other manufacturing activity that has been free from occupational health issues? And the famous (or infamous) FBI raid was based upon allegations that were never proven, then or in the 15 years since, despite the complete dismantlement of the facility and full FBI access to all documents. What the raid DID accomplish was the unilateral abandonment of the nuclear weapon production program, even though preserving the quality of the U.S. stockpile was predicated upon newly manufactured replacement weapons.
Would a new pit facility be more damaging? Hardly. It would not be operating under Cold War imperatives. Even at peak production, it would produce only a fraction of the Rocky Flats output. And we all know that the oversight by DOE and other government agencies, not to mention concerned citizens’ groups, would be far more extensive. Something will have to change in the world political picture before pit production would approach the top figure quoted in your article.
Which brings us to one of the issues of the article: whether anyone but Carlsbad should have input into the process. That’s a phony issue, as the Energy Department representative recognized; whether pit production resumes depends upon the will of Congress and the administration. Is it a bad thing to resume production, assuming that the new warheads will simply replace old? I don’t think so. I think that, if we are to have a nuclear stockpile at all, it should be modern, safe and reliable. I’ll leave the issue of whether a stockpile is needed to wiser heads than mine.
Albuquerque, New Mexico
- C.C. Havens on A day on the river that ended in a death
- Robb Cadwell on Did Obama's Interior hobble the Endangered Species Act?
- Trey Turnbull on Wolf pups, and the return of wild wonder
- Michael Jakubcin on Two degrees warmer and rising: A review of A Great Aridness
- Roy Brophy on Forest Service’s mission goes up in flames