It is worth noting that these mountain regions are also downwind of large human populations and sources of SO2, NOx, ozone, photochemical smog and other emissions. I would suggest that at this juncture it would make about as much sense to blame the demise of the frogs on backyard barbecue grills.
There are some other problems with the pesticide hypothesis. Synthetic organic pesticides have been used for more than half a century. If pesticides constitute the culprit, why didn’t the frog populations decline long ago, particularly since pesticide applications are now regulated far more stringently?
Also, Lassen Volcanic National Park lies downwind of the Sacramento Valley, while Sixty Lakes Basin (in Kings Canyon National Park) is downwind of the San Joaquin Valley. Cropping patterns are very different in the two areas. The principal crop in the Sacramento Valley is rice, while cotton is the main crop in the San Joaquin Valley. The same pesticides are not generally used on both.
This is a sorry excuse for scientific research.
Donald F. Anthrop
San José, California The author is a professor of environmental studies at San José State University.
- Andrew Sipocz on The great salmon compromise
- Kyle Klain on Enough is enough at the Glen Canyon Recreation Area
- Mary Sojourner on Rants from the Hill: Desert Insomnia
- Mary Sojourner on Solace at the end of Homer Spit
- Jennafer Waggoner-Yellowhorse on Why are Hopi rangers impounding sheep at Black Mesa?