You are here: home   Issues   170   No new vision needed

No new vision needed

Document Actions
Dear HCN,


I was interested in the views of William Cronon, and his defender, William R. Dickinson, that we need a new vision of wilderness that takes into account the effects humans had on the North American environment in the pre-Columbian period (HCN, 12/6/99).


These views are also similar to those of Prof. Charles Kay at Utah State University, who stresses the large effects earlier peoples had in areas that are now officially designated as wilderness or are managed for naturalness, such as the northern range of Yellowstone National Park.


I must disagree with them. We do not know the degree by which the aboriginal population was reduced by European diseases. We don't know what the impacts of earlier humans were, and so we cannot restore these environments, even if we were to try.


If their population was large, and they degraded their environment, we certainly have no obligation to restore that. It is true that pre-Columbian America was different than the authors of the Wilderness Act imagined. That's interesting, but it is not relevant. The purpose of wilderness, as defined by the Wilderness Act, remains valid in my set of values. Those with another set of values ought not disguise them. Their anthropology has no bearing on the issue except inasmuch as it is useful as a rhetorical weapon against wilderness.





Ralph Maughan


Pocatello, Idaho


Email Newsletter

The West in your Inbox

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Follow our RSS feeds!
  1. Rancher vs BLM: a 20-year standoff ends with tense roundup |
  2. Photos of a standoff | Armed militia members join a Nevada rancher to pro...
  3. The energy haves and have-nots | Will rooftop solar owners get off the grid — and...
  4. Why homes are lost to wildfire | This Forest Service expert says it's as much a soc...
  5. The future of the Sacramento Delta hangs in the balance | But few Californians seem to grasp what is at stak...
  1. Why homes are lost to wildfire | This Forest Service expert says it's as much a soc...
  2. Photos of a standoff | Armed militia members join a Nevada rancher to pro...
  3. The energy haves and have-nots | Will rooftop solar owners get off the grid — and...
  4. Will the Colorado River reach the Gulf of California once more? | Photographs of last month's historic water pulses....
  5. Locals resist a Bakkenization of the Beartooths | South-central Montanans oppose new drilling, forew...
HCN Classifieds
Subscriber Alert
 
© 2014 High Country News, all rights reserved. | privacy policy | terms of use | powered by Plone