You are here: home   Blogs   The GOAT Blog   Policies and pollinators: How the feds deepen the precipitous decline of monarchs
The GOAT Blog

Policies and pollinators: How the feds deepen the precipitous decline of monarchs

Document Actions
Tip Jar Donation

Your donation supports independent non-profit journalism from High Country News.

Krista Langlois | Feb 12, 2014 08:00 AM

The numbers are in from Mexico, and they ain’t pretty. Every fall, monarch butterflies fly thousands of miles from the Great Plains to their winter grounds in central Mexico, where they're scrupulously counted by the World Wildlife Fund. In 1996, the overwintering monarchs blanketed 45 acres of forest. This year, they cover only about 1.6 acres, and the population – already at its lowest ever recorded – has dropped by half again since just last year. Scientists fear that one of North America’s greatest migrations is in its death throes.

The stats were announced Jan. 29 by the Mexican government and the World Wildlife Fund. Blame has been sure and swift. It’s Monsanto’s fault, it’s climate change, it’s shrinking winter habitat. Yet while those are indeed factors, the biggest – and perhaps the easiest to change, relatively speaking – are U.S. government policies like the farm bill signed into law by President Obama last Friday.

Monarch
Policies that encourage the destruction of native grasslands contribute to plummeting monarch butterfly populations. Photo courtesy USFWS Mountain Prairie.

Not that you can call anything about the farm bill “easy.” The $956 billion, 949-page behemoth took three years to craft and covers a veritable Swiss army knife of programs, including agriculture, conservation, rural development, energy, forestry and food stamps. That it passed Congress at all is impressive; that it did so with the support of conservation groups like the World Wildlife Fund and Ducks Unlimited is even more so. Julie Sibbing, senior director of agriculture and forestry programs for the National Wildlife Federation, called the bill “worth the wait.” One provision in particular discourages farmers from plowing up virgin grasslands in Montana, the Dakotas and three other states, with the hope that limiting crop insurance on such fields will discourage sodbusting, thereby preserving native prairie and improving the chances of monarchs. Monarchs only lay their eggs on milkweed plants, which are rapidly disappearing under heavy machinery and herbicides.

Yet though the farm bill offers some protection for grasslands, it also maintains incentives for farmers to plant ever more corn and soybeans – a policy that’s led to a rate of grassland destruction on the northern plains greater than that of Amazonian deforestation. The new bill cuts back on the direct subsidies of the past and replaces them with crop insurance and price guarantees, but critics counter that the end result is essentially the same.

Plus, the bill cuts $6 billion in conservation programs, and the maximum number of acres enrolled in the Conservation Reserve Program (CRP) will be reduced by 8 million. The CRP allows farmers to take environmentally sensitive fields out of production for 10 or 15 years in exchange for payment, but participation is voluntary, and with continued incentives to plant more crops, hundreds of thousands of acres of milkweed-rich CRP land have been plowed into production in recent years.

Another reason pollinators like the monarch are losing habitat is the 2007 Renewable Fuel Standard, which mandates that a rising percentage of domestic gasoline be made from biofuels such as corn-based ethanol. Chip Taylor, a University of Kansas insect ecologist who founded an outreach program called MonarchWatch, points out that “while the acreage (of corn and soy production) increased by 9.5 million acres from 1996 to 2006, the acreage increased by 20 million over the last 7 years. This increase is largely due to the ethanol mandate.”

corn field
Milkweed once commonly grew on the edges of cornfields, but chemicals sprayed on herbicide-resistant crops have made it scarcer on farmland. Photo courtesty Flickr user Carol Von Canon.

Corn growers say the ethanol subsidies help keep crop prices steady and farms in business, but senators like Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., and Tom Coburn, R-Okla., argue that they raise food costs and encourage sodbusting. Feinstein and Coburn co-authored a bill in December to eliminate the mandate, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has separately proposed to cut ethanol requirements by 16 percent. So far, however, both efforts have stalled, and ethanol and biofuel subsidies remain strong in the 2014 farm bill.

Still, plowing up prairie doesn't necessarily condemn monarchs to death. Corn and other crops can be grown alongside milkweed, and were for many years before herbicide-resistant GMO strains like Monsanto's Roundup Ready were introduced. Again, federal policies come into play: the European Union regulates GMO crops much more strictly than the U.S. government, and the U.S. could easily keep tapping the brakes on the spread of GMOs, as it did last year, when it delayed the release of two engineered crops meant to withstand chemicals even more toxic than Roundup.

While federal policies have had – and continue to have – an enormous impact on butterflies, the grueling passage of the Farm Bill and the swiftly dropping monarch numbers leave little hope that the feds can move quickly enough to enact change. With most monarch habitat privately owned and spread across vast areas, the impetus may end up falling to landowners, or even states, which can make a difference simply by not mowing roadsides, says Laurie Davies Adams, executive director of the Pollinator Partnership advocacy group.

flying monarchs
Billions of monarchs migrate from the Great Plains to winter habitat in Mexico, pictured here, but their numbers are down by half since just last year. Photo courtesy Flickr user Luna sin estrellas.

Davies Adams isn’t giving up. One provision dropped from the farm bill in the 11th hour would have mandated yearly pollinator counts and forced federal agencies to cooperate in addressing their decline. Davies Adams is traveling to Washington, D.C. next week to shop around for a new home for the policies.

“We’re going to work really hard to make them happen,” she says. “It doesn’t have to happen in the farm bill. The farm bill is one vehicle. If you don’t get ‘em in (there), you simply find another way.”

Krista Langlois is an editorial fellow at High Country News. She tweets @KristaLanglois2.

Dale Lockwood
Dale Lockwood Subscriber
Feb 13, 2014 05:34 PM
It never ends,really the bottom line is there is too many people in a country that is not even 250 years old. We are demanding more from finite resources every day. About 40 years population will double again.
No immigration bill in a country that is beyound carrying capacity and lacks surplus land and resources. Some day will match China's present population,were working on it.
Paul Cherubini
Paul Cherubini
Feb 14, 2014 07:10 PM
The monarch butterfly population was down in 2012 and 2013 due to natural causes and will rebound in 2014 again due to natural causes. The taxpayer's walets need not be raided to solve a problem that doesn't need solving to begin with.
David Dube
David Dube
Apr 17, 2014 12:21 PM
"Natural causes" such as? overpopulation? We sometimes elect politicians that make bad decisions or decisions based on self-serving interests. There needs to be accountability and that accountability is us, the taxpayer.

Email Newsletter

The West in your Inbox

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Follow our RSS feeds!
  1. The death of backpacking? | Younger people don’t seem interested in this out...
  2. Why I am a Tea Party member |
  3. The privatization of public campground management | All the info you need to decide whether you love o...
  4. Efficiency lessons from Germany |
  5. The Latest: Interior commits to restoring bison on select lands | The “odd ungulate out” gets a tentative win.
  1. The death of backpacking? | Younger people don’t seem interested in this out...
  2. A graceful gazelle becomes a pest | Inrroducing an African gazelle called the oryx for...
  3. What's killing the Yukon's salmon? | An ecological mystery in Alaska has scientists and...
  4. Plains sense | Ten years after Frank and Deborah Popper first pro...
  5. North Dakota wrestles with radioactive oilfield waste | Regulators look at raising the limit for radiation...
 
© 2014 High Country News, all rights reserved. | privacy policy | terms of use | powered by Plone