Personal tools
You are here: home   Blogs   The GOAT Blog   Despite vandalism, road stays closed
Log in


Forgot your password?
New user?
 
The GOAT Blog

Despite vandalism, road stays closed

Document Actions
Tip Jar Donation

Your donation supports independent non-profit journalism from High Country News.

Enter amount:

$
Ed Quillen | Apr 28, 2009 09:20 AM


Back in mid-March, I wrote about a wonderful development on one of my favorite local dog-walking routes. The federal Bureau of Land Management had blocked motor vehicles from this half-mile stretch of old bad road along the Arkansas River just east of Salida.

I predicted that the closure sign would get knocked down, the blocking boulders would be moved, and there would be agitation to re-open the road to pickups, ATVs, motorcycles and the like.

The post with the closure sign hasn't fared well. Soon after it went up, it was pushed hard by a vehicle. It was cracked and leaning, but still standing, more or less. By last weekend, though, it was fully broken off and lying in the dirt.

However, the boulders are still in place, and we've seen only one violator, a motorcyclist who briefly intruded, then turned back.
 
As for agitation to re-open the road, it's come from a surprising place -- a local fly-fishing outfitter who claimed at a public meeting that citizens were being denied "recreational access" to the area.
 
When I called him on that, he conceded that there remained plenty of recreational access, albeit by foot, horse, or bicycle, but that he still didn't like the road being closed to vehicles.
 
He may be the only angler who feels that way, though. I don't walk the dog there every day -- three or four visits a week is typical -- but when the road was open, I typically saw one or two anglers along that stretch. Now we often see at least half a dozen who don't seem to mind walking for five or ten minutes to sample one of Colorado's "Gold Medal" fisheries.
 
In other words, the area now appears to host more fishing than before the road was closed to vehicles. Granted, much of this recent popularity may be a result of clement weather, low water and hatching flies. Even at that, though, it demonstrates that there are plenty of anglers who don't have a problem with the road closure.
 
As for the broken post with the closure sign, a public-spirited citizen (okay, I'm married to her) set it back up and placed rocks around it to hold it in place until the BLM can get in and replace it, perhaps with something more substantial.
 

beyond the locked gate
rich domingue
rich domingue
Apr 28, 2009 05:06 PM
As an avid flyfisher and occasional reader of Mr. Quillen's fine expository, I wish to express my opinion on his. The best fishing on public water is always behind a locked gate, over a pass, or at the bottom of an endless talus slope. Roads kill streams. Any outfitter who prefers the whine of motocycles to the soft murmurs of running water is an idiot who should find another line of work - say selling real estate. Here's mud in yer' eye, Ed. Give that fine wife of yours my thanks (you kin use yer lips).
Despite vandalism road stay open
Tom Biller
Tom Biller
Apr 29, 2009 12:53 PM
If BLM is sincere in keeping this "road" closed to OHV's they'll have to increase law enforcement patrols in the area. Nothing stops illegal OHV use faster than a patrol ranger writing citations and seizing off road vehicles. But, BLM management is usually against that type of activity, so they'll probably write a plan, file it, put up a few signs, then give up after a few months.

Having dealt with similiar situations during my career as a U.S.Ranger, I discovered early on that written plans and signs only work if there is someone out in the field enforcing the regulations. I also discovered that BLM management would be much happier if the Rangers stayed in the office all the time, that way they weren't out protecting the resource. Hire more Rangers!!!!
 

Email Newsletter

The West in your Inbox

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter! Follow our RSS feeds!
  1. Fearful of Agenda 21, an alleged U.N. plot, activists derail land-use planning | A two-year planning process in La Plata County, Co...
  2. Billboard corporations use money and influence to override your vote | In Salt Lake City and other Western communities, b...
  3. The logging town of Darrington, Wash., fights to save a fire lookout | A lawsuit raises questions about how far environme...
  4. Feeding the deer | A rural Californian doesn't apologize for feeding ...
  5. Residents of Montana's High Plains are angry - but not at the real threats | Though climate change and the economy are the issu...
  1. Fearful of Agenda 21, an alleged U.N. plot, activists derail land-use planning | A two-year planning process in La Plata County, Co...
  2. Billboard corporations use money and influence to override your vote | In Salt Lake City and other Western communities, b...
  3. The logging town of Darrington, Wash., fights to save a fire lookout | A lawsuit raises questions about how far environme...
  4. Residents of Montana's High Plains are angry - but not at the real threats | Though climate change and the economy are the issu...
  5. Picking ranchers' brains, from Colorado to Mongolia | Colorado State University professor Maria Fernande...
More from Recreation
When an avalanche comes calling Some backcountry skiers are triggering avalanches without regard for those who might be skiing below them.
Nothing to lose but your leash When did human beings become slaves to their dogs, required to take them everywhere, even cross-country skiing?
Tourism creates jobs, but it's still a mixed bag The White House promotes tourism as economic boon, but many positions are low wage
All Recreation

Most recent from the blogs

 
© 2012 High Country News, all rights reserved. | privacy policy | terms of use | powered by Plone | site by Groundwire | design by Ryan Foster

HCN Logo High Country News in your inbox!


Sign up now to receive our weekly email newsletter!

- The best weekly collection of Western environmental news

- An at-a-glance look at our latest news and analysis