Feds enabled oil drillers, others to cheat Fort Berthold tribes

 

Editor's note: This ProPublica story follows up on our 2012 story "The Other Bakken Boom" with additional information on lawsuits alleging that the U.S. government allowed the Fort Berthold tribes to be cheated by energy companies.

Native Americans on an oil-rich North Dakota reservation have been cheated out of more than $1 billion by schemes to buy drilling rights for lowball prices, a flurry of recent lawsuits assert. And, the suits claim, the federal government facilitated the alleged swindle by failing in its legal obligation to ensure the tribes got a fair deal.

This is a story as old as America itself, given a new twist by fracking and the boom that technology has sparked in North Dakota oil country. Since the late 1800s, the U.S. government has appropriated much of the original tribal lands associated with the Fort Berthold reservation in North Dakota for railroads and white homesteaders. A devastating blow was delivered when the Army Corps of Engineers dammed the Missouri River in 1953, flooding more than 150,000 acres at the heart of the remaining reservation. Members of the Three Affiliated Tribes -- the Mandan, Hidatsa and Arikara -- were forced out of the fertile valley and up into the arid and barren surrounding hills, where they live now.

But that last-resort land turns out to hold a wealth of oil, because it sits on the Bakken Shale, widely believed to be one of the world's largest deposits of crude. Until recently, that oil was difficult to extract, but hydraulic fracturing, combined with the ability to drill a well sideways underground, can tap it. The result, according to several senior tribal members and lawsuits filed last November and early this year in federal and state courts, has been a land grab involving everyone from tribal leaders accused of enriching themselves at the expense of their people, to oil speculators, to a New York hedge fund, to the federal government's Bureau of Indian Affairs.

The rush to get access to oil on tribal lands is part of the oil industry's larger push to secure drilling rights across the United States. Recent estimates show that the U.S. contains vast quantities of oil and gas. As fracking has opened new fields to drilling, and the U.S. has striven to get more of its energy from within its borders, leases from Louisiana to Pennsylvania have been gobbled up. Now the pressure is increasing on one of the last sizeable holdouts -- lands owned by Native Americans.

Johnnie Snider
Johnnie Snider
Feb 26, 2013 03:22 PM
So in otherwords you're saying that your own people did this and to date have gone unpunished
Vance Gillette
Vance Gillette Subscriber
Feb 27, 2013 08:41 AM
a similar lease to spotted hawk oil co. is being challenged in
tribal court, SOAR v Mervin Packineau et. al. Filed Feb l2, 2013. Council approved 32,000 acre lease on: only 2 yes votes,
when council member had conflicts of interests. Copy of buffalos fire website. Lease at cheap rate - like Dacota 3 lease. Suit seeks to cancel lease and get fair value for oil
lands. vance gillette new town nd ft berth. ind res.